How to complain about a garage?
How to complain about a garage?
Author
Discussion

mike9009

Original Poster:

10,571 posts

270 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Long story this one, but it has left me fuming......

I have owned a VW T25 Camper for about six months. Two months ago it broke down and i couldn't get it started again. I called the AA . Symptoms were the van was back firing then cutting out. No other obvious issues.

The AA subcontracted to a local garage who came out at about 10PM. They could not get it running reliably and so towed me back to their own garage. Then the problems started.

Firstly they tried coils and ignition amplifier. Then they said the compression was low on two cylinders and it needed a new engine. This took six weeks of constant chasing them (20+ phone calls, with not many returned....). I have been waiting two weeks for a price for a new engine......

Yesterday, i swung into action (works been hectic.....) and rescued my van from these clowns. Unfortunately i broke down three miles away, having the van cut out once and loosing power going up a slight hill. Called AA again and a different subcontract garage came out. He noticed the brake servo hose was not connected, reconnected and evrything now seems fine. So a 15pence jubilee clip or new engine?

The first garage have pissed me off so much that I want to report them. How or who do i report this to? They are a small independent garage, will the AA be bothered? Will trading standards care? I'm luckily not out of pocket (another story.....) despite them fitting various new parts, or should I just leave it......

Thanks

Mike

nadger

1,413 posts

167 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Not out of pocket?!
I've got the episode of max and paddy's road to nowhere with noddy holder running through my head now!

M666 EVO

1,129 posts

189 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Sounds like the second garage got lucky "noticing" the hose was not connected

Maybe the first garage genuinely thought it needed a new engine

Or is it the customer support (or lack of it) that has pissed you off?

I would try trading standards though and just generally spread the word they are toilet


McSam

6,753 posts

202 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Get a compression test done independently. If it's showing good compression on all four cylinders, which I expect it will be, then you can completely destroy the first garage. The AA should be informed as they won't want to use them, and then so should trading standards, but if you have no written quotes then there's not a lot of legal action to be taken.

mike9009

Original Poster:

10,571 posts

270 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
McSam said:
Get a compression test done independently. If it's showing good compression on all four cylinders, which I expect it will be, then you can completely destroy the first garage. The AA should be informed as they won't want to use them, and then so should trading standards, but if you have no written quotes then there's not a lot of legal action to be taken.
Not interested in taking legal action ( not my style) but just want these dodgy garages shut down or given a serious worry. Especially as they are AA subcontractors.....

Mike

philmots

4,665 posts

287 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
I'd inform the AA and leave at that.

rawkyjnr

259 posts

198 months

Tuesday 11th September 2012
quotequote all
Most people in my experience are clowns, they are businesses with profit in mind! I've heard of services on Porsches coming back without the filter being changed and all sorts.

AtticusFinch

28,861 posts

210 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
I complained to the RAC. I don't think it helped. Main dealer reccomended new engine after small Ford recovered in after filling it with derv.
Drain and refill with petrol renew filters (myself) and the car was fine.

dh2009

19 posts

209 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
mike9009 said:
Long story this one, but it has left me fuming......

I have owned a VW T25 Camper for about six months. Two months ago it broke down and i couldn't get it started again. I called the AA . Symptoms were the van was back firing then cutting out. No other obvious issues.

The AA subcontracted to a local garage who came out at about 10PM. They could not get it running reliably and so towed me back to their own garage. Then the problems started.

Firstly they tried coils and ignition amplifier. Then they said the compression was low on two cylinders and it needed a new engine. This took six weeks of constant chasing them (20+ phone calls, with not many returned....). I have been waiting two weeks for a price for a new engine......

Yesterday, i swung into action (works been hectic.....) and rescued my van from these clowns. Unfortunately i broke down three miles away, having the van cut out once and loosing power going up a slight hill. Called AA again and a different subcontract garage came out. He noticed the brake servo hose was not connected, reconnected and evrything now seems fine. So a 15pence jubilee clip or new engine?

The first garage have pissed me off so much that I want to report them. How or who do i report this to? They are a small independent garage, will the AA be bothered? Will trading standards care? I'm luckily not out of pocket (another story.....) despite them fitting various new parts, or should I just leave it......

Thanks

Mike
Hi Mike,

Sorry to hear of your recent troubles with the vehicle. We welcome all feedback and we would like to take further details so we can take a closer look to address any concerns. Please email chat@theaa.com including reference FOR18696. Regards The AA



Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

282 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Report it to the internet!

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

292 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
dh2009 said:
Hi Mike,

Sorry to hear of your recent troubles with the vehicle. We welcome all feedback and we would like to take further details so we can take a closer look to address any concerns. Please email chat@theaa.com including reference FOR18696. Regards The AA
Job done.

Excellent.

crosseyedlion

2,380 posts

225 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
doogz said:
Mechanics noticing things wrong with engines isn't luck. It's their job.
+1

As a (Former) mechanic I agree with this, something as simple as that should have been noticed.

Most people have got a garage horror/shock story. It really bothers me, other service industries can get it right - Something I'd like to remedy...just need some funds.

trickywoo

13,962 posts

257 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
M666 EVO said:
Maybe the first garage genuinely thought it needed a new engine
rofl

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

282 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
crosseyedlion said:
Most people have got a garage horror/shock story. It really bothers me, other service industries can get it right - Something I'd like to remedy...just need some funds.
Are you planning to make other service industries as bad as garages then? hehe