Is there such thing as a neutral newspaper?
Is there such thing as a neutral newspaper?
Author
Discussion

Morningside

Original Poster:

24,147 posts

260 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Torygraph
Labours mouthpiece The Guardian.

Hell, even our local paper seems to bend to the left!

So does a politically neutral paper exist?

mattviatura

2,996 posts

231 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Don't really think so, we've got a good choice between right and left in the print media but I can't think of a neutral one.

Of course we CHOOSE to buy our print media.

paranoid airbag

2,679 posts

190 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Morningside said:
Torygraph
Labours mouthpiece The Guardian.
That's why I browse the online sections of both. They cancel each other out, and you become aware of the tricks used, and therefore capable of actually evaluating a piece instead of mindlessly repeating cliches.

I don't understand why someone would rely on a single news source. Getting one side of the story is only ever going to lead to being wrong a lot.

Morningside

Original Poster:

24,147 posts

260 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
I always wonder of there would be a market for one?

muffinmenace

1,100 posts

219 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Morningside said:
I always wonder of there would be a market for one?
There would be a market for one but papers make a loss so it would have to be propped up. The opportunity for said business to sway public opinion, government policy would be too great to pass up.

MX7

7,902 posts

205 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
FT probably.

FourWheelDrift

92,402 posts

315 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
The Independent is supposed to be neutral, can't say I have ever looked at it though. Is it?

rpguk

4,520 posts

315 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
I don't think it's possible to have a neutral newspaper - people will choose a newspaper based on what they want to hear.

Sticking to the PA newsfeeds give a stripped down version of the news - generally facts stated without comment.

People generally feel that when a paper says something in conflict with their belief it's biased anyway. People don't read newspapers to have their view changed.

paranoid airbag

2,679 posts

190 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
rpguk said:
I don't think it's possible to have a neutral newspaper - people will choose a newspaper based on what they want to hear.

Sticking to the PA newsfeeds give a stripped down version of the news - generally facts stated without comment.

People generally feel that when a paper says something in conflict with their belief it's biased anyway. People don't read newspapers to have their view changed.
+1, unfortunately. A simple narrative of 'lefties want to take our freedom/tories want to eat our babies' pulls more punters than 'here's a group of people trying to run the country, they have different ideas about the best way of doing it and some of them will be wrong but it's difficult to say which at the moment'.

speedy_thrills

7,979 posts

274 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
In my view I find bias less important than full disclosure of information. If it states all the relevant facts then at least if I don't agree with the authors point of view of the matter I can appreciate his viewpoint. The omission of important information is by far the most frequent misleading technique I see used followed closely by the over extrapolation of factual information.

don4l

10,058 posts

207 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
FourWheelDrift said:
The Independent is supposed to be neutral, can't say I have ever looked at it though. Is it?
When it first came out it was fairly balanced. It swung massively to the left some years ago.


A real pity. I used to buy it regularily.

Don
--

JagLover

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Morningside said:
So does a politically neutral paper exist?
No

There only exists degrees of bias and distortion of the underlying news story.

In terms of political alignment The Economist is the most centrist of the ones I am aware of (but that is a weekly magazine rather than a newspaper) but it still has bias in certain areas.

JontyR

1,924 posts

198 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
I know it isnt a paper...but isnt the BBC supposed to be neutral? wink

Riley Blue

23,218 posts

257 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
I always read PH's N,P&E for a well informed, balanced opinion on the world's happenings.

motco

17,670 posts

277 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
FourWheelDrift said:
The Independent is supposed to be neutral, can't say I have ever looked at it though. Is it?
It was when it started in the late eighties, but it ain't now!

Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
FourWheelDrift said:
The Independent is supposed to be neutral, can't say I have ever looked at it though. Is it?
It used to be, but got more and more left-biased (presumably responding to its customer base).

That said, I do find 'I' - the tabloid-for-people-with-a-brain version of the Indy boiled down to hard-news content with much of the opinion stripped out - fairly neutral, very informative, generally well-written and for 20p absolutely ideal for reading on trains or over breakfast.

zac510

5,546 posts

237 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
It's about as likely as finding a neutral human being.

Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
JontyR said:
I know it isnt a paper...but isnt the BBC supposed to be neutral? wink
I reckon it still is compared to most media outlets. It's only the heavy right-wing polarasis on this site (and in its persistant critic, the Daily Mail) that makes it look left-wing. I know some lefties who think it's too 'establishment', so it's probably more neutral than people give it credit for. I happen to know Question Time audiences are balanced evenly according to voting preference (it's the first thing they ask you when you phone up for tickets).

Private Eye is totally neutral. It only comes out every two weeks but there's far more to it than comedy. I get all my in-depth news analysis from it these days.

The Don of Croy

6,477 posts

190 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Twincam16 said:
I reckon it still is compared to most media outlets. It's only the heavy right-wing polarasis on this site (and in its persistant critic, the Daily Mail) that makes it look left-wing. I know some lefties who think it's too 'establishment', so it's probably more neutral than people give it credit for. I happen to know Question Time audiences are balanced evenly according to voting preference (it's the first thing they ask you when you phone up for tickets).

Private Eye is totally neutral. It only comes out every two weeks but there's far more to it than comedy. I get all my in-depth news analysis from it these days.
So if an organised group wanted to 'infiltrate' Question Time, all they need to do is specify different voting intentions?

Also Private Eye is worth reading, but it is far from neutral. They are a tiny news-gathering organisation and rely on helpful contributors, or people who want to publicise a particular cause, for a lot of their items, whether they are properly checked or not is another matter. I was a subscriber for decades but found more items I knew to be wrong, and drifted away. It also makes you very cynical.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Would it even be possible to write a fully neutral newspaper? Newspapers are written by human beings and human beings generally have opinions on things. The object of writing a newspaper is to sell it, and to sell it you need a story. Generally enforced 'balance' kills any story and although theres obviously times where there's no need for a story because all that matters is fact - take todays Hillsborough panel findings for a start - everyday political stories have multiple sides to them.

Who will buy a paper with the headline Osborne doing rather reasonable job?