Outlawing written child porn..
Author
Discussion

bitchstewie

Original Poster:

68,529 posts

241 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Ever find yourself slightly surprised that something is legal.. WTF?!

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-19574487

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Vladimir Nabokov is going to be in trouble!

TheForceV4

543 posts

218 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Personally I thought that all materials depicting child abuse would be a chargeable offence whether written or image based.

Obviously I was wrong.

banghead

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Vladimir Nabokov is going to be in trouble!
"Only "absolutely vile" material would be targeted, he said, adding by way of example that well-known novels such as Vladimir Nabokov's Lolita - which explores a middle-aged man's obsession and sexual involvement with a 12-year old girl - would not be covered."

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Vladimir Nabokov is going to be in trouble!
It does actually say that the law will be written so tightly that this would not be brought in.

Whilst I applaud the intent I think that, like the law on images, it is going to be a fecking ststorm if it ever happens, perhaps even more so than images.

Most PHer's have a healthy concern for the abilities of our politicians, that is nothing compared to the pathetic state of those currently charged with drafting our laws and statutes who need the Clarkson treatment.

Coming soon to a sink estate near you the burning of copies of Lolita on top of the fires kindled with Led Zep posters.


Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Wow, I agree with the op never even thought about it let alone knew it was legal. It seems a very strange loophole to me.


Just wondering where does this leave something like paedo bear joke pictures?

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Pesty said:
Just wondering where does this leave something like paedo bear joke pictures?
This is exactly the sort of problem we are going to have. I would suggest in the same place as the jokes about the Englishman, the Irishman and the Scot. Most will not care, many will try to make PC and at some point someone is going to get crucified as the boundaries are tested in court.

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Leon was a tricky film and could easily fall into this catagory, if the law is not drafted carfully. I have read a book with graphic descriptions of child abuse written by the abused child in later life. This book highlights what can happen when a parent abuses the trust placed in them by the child. It told the story of how it happened and the betrayal of the family, to the little girl. It was very chilling and enlightening how cruel people can be to an innocent child. This book highlights the silent suffering of a few children and if it were to be covered by a ban would be a great loss to understand the suffering of these children. Books of this kind bring knowledge of this type of suffering to the masses and can be a force for good, I only wish it had been enforced reading in the diocise of Chichester. Maybe the bishops would act quicker if they know the long and deep suffering caused by this abuse.

HundredthIdiot

4,477 posts

315 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
At the risk of inflaming opinions and inviting accusations of supporting paedophilia, why should this be illegal?

Until somewhat recently, child porn (in photographic or video form) was deemed to be harmful because of the horrific abuse necessarily inflicted on the unwilling participants. There was (is) a direct link between the production of such material and actual abuse.

A written account, or a painting, comic or whatever depicting the same thing does not require any actual abuse to have happened, in fact it makes no sense for the producer to base it on fact.

So where is the harm? Just because something is disgusting doesn't mean it should be illegal.

I guess there's an argument that satisfying these perversions might increase demand for the real thing (gateway porn?), but equally it could be argued that it reduces that demand. I have no idea.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
HundredthIdiot said:
At the risk of inflaming opinions and inviting accusations of supporting paedophilia, why should this be illegal?

Until somewhat recently, child porn (in photographic or video form) was deemed to be harmful because of the horrific abuse necessarily inflicted on the unwilling participants. There was (is) a direct link between the production of such material and actual abuse.

A written account, or a painting, comic or whatever depicting the same thing does not require any actual abuse to have happened, in fact it makes no sense for the producer to base it on fact.

So where is the harm? Just because something is disgusting doesn't mean it should be illegal.

I guess there's an argument that satisfying these perversions might increase demand for the real thing (gateway porn?), but equally it could be argued that it reduces that demand. I have no idea.
Fair play to you, was thinking the same but didn't have the balls to say it. Does smack a bit of a thought crime issue.

I'll bow out now before I'm accused of noncery.

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
HundredthIdiot said:
At the risk of inflaming opinions and inviting accusations of supporting paedophilia, why should this be illegal?

Until somewhat recently, child porn (in photographic or video form) was deemed to be harmful because of the horrific abuse necessarily inflicted on the unwilling participants. There was (is) a direct link between the production of such material and actual abuse.

A written account, or a painting, comic or whatever depicting the same thing does not require any actual abuse to have happened, in fact it makes no sense for the producer to base it on fact.

So where is the harm? Just because something is disgusting doesn't mean it should be illegal.

I guess there's an argument that satisfying these perversions might increase demand for the real thing (gateway porn?), but equally it could be argued that it reduces that demand. I have no idea.
there can be fantasies that can be written that people take and try to make reality.

we have all probably read fantasies then tried to get the wife to act them out.

no just me!

getmecoat

HundredthIdiot

4,477 posts

315 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
SplatSpeed said:
there can be fantasies that can be written that people take and try to make reality.

we have all probably read fantasies then tried to get the wife to act them out.
I'm sure there are men who get their wives/girlfriends to dress up as schoolgirls. And then video it. And then sent it to someone. Is that the same as distributing child porn? Does it matter how old the subject "looks", or "is"? Probably enough to get them on the sex offenders register anyway.

Total minefield, morally and legally.

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
HundredthIdiot said:
At the risk of inflaming opinions and inviting accusations of supporting paedophilia, why should this be illegal?

Until somewhat recently, child porn (in photographic or video form) was deemed to be harmful because of the horrific abuse necessarily inflicted on the unwilling participants. There was (is) a direct link between the production of such material and actual abuse.

A written account, or a painting, comic or whatever depicting the same thing does not require any actual abuse to have happened, in fact it makes no sense for the producer to base it on fact.

So where is the harm? Just because something is disgusting doesn't mean it should be illegal.

I guess there's an argument that satisfying these perversions might increase demand for the real thing (gateway porn?), but equally it could be argued that it reduces that demand. I have no idea.
Interesting point of view.
Not sure now.

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
HundredthIdiot said:
At the risk of inflaming opinions and inviting accusations of supporting paedophilia, why should this be illegal?

Until somewhat recently, child porn (in photographic or video form) was deemed to be harmful because of the horrific abuse necessarily inflicted on the unwilling participants. There was (is) a direct link between the production of such material and actual abuse.

A written account, or a painting, comic or whatever depicting the same thing does not require any actual abuse to have happened, in fact it makes no sense for the producer to base it on fact.

So where is the harm? Just because something is disgusting doesn't mean it should be illegal.

I guess there's an argument that satisfying these perversions might increase demand for the real thing (gateway porn?), but equally it could be argued that it reduces that demand. I have no idea.
Pseudo-images of abuse (e.g. cartoons, computer-generated imagery etc.) are also illegal.

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
HundredthIdiot said:
I'm sure there are men who get their wives/girlfriends to dress up as schoolgirls. And then video it. And then sent it to someone. Is that the same as distributing child porn? Does it matter how old the subject "looks", or "is"? Probably enough to get them on the sex offenders register anyway.

Total minefield, morally and legally.
the trouble is to judge how someone will use a fantasy from a normal person point of view.

The problem is, the people that force their will on others, are not normal but selfish barstards, that have no thought for others.

I am sure there is a corrolation between abusers and this sort of material. That link will cause it to be banned. Only by interograting abusers will it be shown if this material actually leads to abuse or possibly more abuse.

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Are we trusting the police and the CPS to decide what's literature, erotica or pornography now? It's very difficult to stand up to a baying mob and no-one wants to be perceived to be supporting the cause of protecting the rights of paedophiles but one does rather wonder what's next. We shouldn't forget that there are those who will be thrilled to see this and would like it to go further and the authoritarians need to kept in check.

Edited by rohrl on Wednesday 12th September 18:13

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
rohrl said:
Are we trusting the police and the CPS to decide what's literature, erotica or pornography now? It's very difficult to stand up to a baying mob and no-one wants to be perceived to be supporting the cause of protecting the rights of paedophiles but one does rather wonder what's next. We shouldn't forget that there are those who will be thrilled to see this and would like it to further and the authoritarians need to kept in check.
True. very concerning that, PC means you can't say words and the context is ignored. But unlike nasty words this is the saftey of children in mind. difficult to balance free speech and child saftey. Who decides what is litrature or porn. much harder than a photo, which is hard enough to work out someones age.

HundredthIdiot

4,477 posts

315 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
marshalla said:
Pseudo-images of abuse (e.g. cartoons, computer-generated imagery etc.) are also illegal.
Indeed. The Register covered some of it:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/05/28/government...

"The Children And Young Persons (Harmful Publications) Act 1955 made it an offence to publish cartoons depicting crime, violence or “incidents of a repulsive or horrible nature”. Only one prosecution was ever brought – for a Conan the Barbarian cartoon. And that failed. ®"

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
HundredthIdiot said:
Indeed. The Register covered some of it:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/05/28/government...

"The Children And Young Persons (Harmful Publications) Act 1955 made it an offence to publish cartoons depicting crime, violence or “incidents of a repulsive or horrible nature”. Only one prosecution was ever brought – for a Conan the Barbarian cartoon. And that failed. ®"
iirc there was also another with Tony the Tiger that also failed.

Really don't like this slippery slope we are on. Ban the pictures (I can see the sense in this), ban the written word, what next the spoken word (deny that paedophilia happens).

Then what comes next BDSM, group sex, toys all considered wrong by some.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
I'd have thought the argument to ban Grand theft auto and Call of Duty is just as strong.