BAE and EADS merger talks
Author
Discussion

digger_R

Original Poster:

1,809 posts

237 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
An interesting one if this goes through, the fact it's gone public is hardly insignificant


http://uk.reuters.com/article/2012/09/12/uk-eads-b...

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
It'll never work, that won't stop them doing it, but it'll never work.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
I should think the EU will wave it through - they'd love to have the world's largest defence contractor.

munky

5,328 posts

279 months

Wednesday 12th September 2012
quotequote all
Made 10% on my BaE shares today. Still not convinced it's a good idea though.

Fatman2

1,464 posts

200 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
I think this could be a good move. When they pulled out originally this left EADS with zero UK contribution, yet Airbus, Astrium and MBDA still have a strong presence here.

The French generally look down their noses at the UK, possibly because of the lack of financial input from our government. Yet we still want the work to prop up the economy.

Without any UK contribution I can see all major work being spread out in the rest of Europe and that's the last thing we need for our slowly diminishing engineering base.

From a defense POV though, I think the combination of EADS and BAE would result in a pretty impressive portfolio. Also bear in mind that the Yanks still don't trust the French (hence all the added security) so this would be of benefit to EADS no doubt. Whether that also benefits the UK is anyones guess but time will tell.

AndyClockwise

689 posts

193 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Fatman2 said:
I think this could be a good move. When they pulled out originally this left EADS with zero UK contribution, yet Airbus, Astrium and MBDA still have a strong presence here.

The French generally look down their noses at the UK, possibly because of the lack of financial input from our government. Yet we still want the work to prop up the economy.

Without any UK contribution I can see all major work being spread out in the rest of Europe and that's the last thing we need for our slowly diminishing engineering base.

From a defense POV though, I think the combination of EADS and BAE would result in a pretty impressive portfolio. Also bear in mind that the Yanks still don't trust the French (hence all the added security) so this would be of benefit to EADS no doubt. Whether that also benefits the UK is anyones guess but time will tell.
EADS have been making in-roads into America; they set up EADS North America and their Ectocryp Black encrytption device was approved by the NSA in the summer for use for US secure communications

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Well, well, well. Interesting times ahead.

Thales reaction will be even more interesting smile

Fatman2

1,464 posts

200 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
AndyClockwise said:
EADS have been making in-roads into America; they set up EADS North America and their Ectocryp Black encrytption device was approved by the NSA in the summer for use for US secure communications
Indeed but it's a slow process and there's still a hell of a lot of stuff that the UK does that's not for French eyes, despite it all falling under the 'EADS' umbrella.

Blue62

10,587 posts

183 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Fatman2 said:
Indeed but it's a slow process and there's still a hell of a lot of stuff that the UK does that's not for French eyes, despite it all falling under the 'EADS' umbrella.
Apparently work related to national security will be ring fenced with some sort of special share issue for each of the nations involved, presumably to act as protection, but I have to confess that I don't fully understand how that is supposed to protect our interests/security.

muffinmenace

1,100 posts

219 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Oh dear, I'd have thought more competition not less was a good thing for the EU economy. Yes it'd be bigger than Boeing but at what cost? Thousands of jobs?

God I sound like martin.

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
muffinmenace said:
Oh dear, I'd have thought more competition not less was a good thing for the EU economy. Yes it'd be bigger than Boeing but at what cost? Thousands of jobs?

Hmm the manufacturing sites are fairly specific in ehat they "do" across all sectors so I don't see thousands of jobs going unless there is a widespread cull on "products".

Having said that though, some wing construction was taken overseas a month or so ago.....

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Having read it in more detail, the significant comment is the one that has gone unnoticed. Daimler positioning themselves to sell their share on the open market.

Its a get out of jail free card for the Germans. They have found it a pain in the arse to work with the French within EADS and if this new split is allegedly 60% EADS and 40% BAES, then I dont see smooth sailing ahead.

Fatman2

1,464 posts

200 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
muffinmenace said:
Oh dear, I'd have thought more competition not less was a good thing for the EU economy. Yes it'd be bigger than Boeing but at what cost? Thousands of jobs?

God I sound like martin.
That depends. Some parts of EADS, like MBDA, are already EADS/BAE so not much change there.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MBDA

Also don't forget that there is a general shortage of engineers in Europe so you just can't 'cull' something that isn't there in the first place. Perhaps with admin but as mentioned above, the sites in the UK are very specialised so closing any site is like cutting off an arm/leg.

I've not spoken to anyone in the industry that isn't understaffed and desperate for experienced engineers. It doesn't help with Boeing coming over here and holding recruitment drives either as this is also reducing the engineer count.

In stark contrast to most other industries, aero/defense is booming so is great to be in demand.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Fatman2 said:
muffinmenace said:
Oh dear, I'd have thought more competition not less was a good thing for the EU economy. Yes it'd be bigger than Boeing but at what cost? Thousands of jobs?

God I sound like martin.
That depends. Some parts of EADS, like MBDA, are already EADS/BAE so not much change there.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MBDA

Also don't forget that there is a general shortage of engineers in Europe so you just can't 'cull' something that isn't there in the first place. Perhaps with admin but as mentioned above, the sites in the UK are very specialised so closing any site is like cutting off an arm/leg.

I've not spoken to anyone in the industry that isn't understaffed and desperate for experienced engineers. It doesn't help with Boeing coming over here and holding recruitment drives either as this is also reducing the engineer count.

In stark contrast to most other industries, aero/defense is booming so is great to be in demand.
Totally agree but it doesn't start and end with the engineering jobs. Since the collapse of Nimrod BAe hav been wanting to close Warton and/or Salmesbury and I'm sure if this goes ahead it will give them the perfect reasoning to do it with the loss of thousands of admin and manufacturing jobs.

Going back to the Nimrod and the other failed projects caned in the SDR the fault has to lie with the previous governments complete incompetance to control the ridiculously MOD procurement process and the governments complete lack of understanding how to go about commisioning a large scale engineering porject. I know BAe may not have ended out of pocket but they certainly wasted many many many thousands of resource hours that could have been put into longterm revenue building ideas and IP development. Shame on them.

So I'm in two minds about this

Fatman2

1,464 posts

200 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Yeah sorry, I didn't think about those sites. Most of my experience is from working with the rest of the EADS group so looks (potentially) positive from my, albeit narrow, angle


motorizer

1,545 posts

202 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
Well the americans wont simply let a french company come in on the F35 work at samlesbury, so that will be "ringfenced" and in all likelyhood stay where it is for now.

Warton and samlesbury already work with them on eurofighter...and didn't have anything to do with nimrod really anyway

So no change there hopefully...
fingers crossed since i work there..

AshVX220

5,965 posts

221 months

Thursday 13th September 2012
quotequote all
They'd be mad to sell ship-building doogz, after we finish our current (big) job, we're we'll be doing T26, we're supposed to start cutting steel on that in 2015 apparently.

munky

5,328 posts

279 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
It has been called off, thankfully (from a BaE shareholder point of view).

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
munky said:
It has been called off, thankfully (from a BaE shareholder point of view).
Really? Officially? I know the politicians were starting to suck air through their teeth but I think that was expected.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
mattnunn said:
Really? Officially? I know the politicians were starting to suck air through their teeth but I think that was expected.
Was on the news at lunch-time, they reckoned the German Government (big shareholder in EADS) wouldn't agree.