Alps / Snow in a QP
Alps / Snow in a QP
Author
Discussion

MattGTA

Original Poster:

419 posts

203 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
HI,

After a bit of advice from Quattroporte owners - we're off to Slovakia for New Year and have decided to drive there, via the Alps. I'd like to take the QP - failing that, we'll be in SWMBO's Renault Grande Scenic, which is something I'd like to avoid for obvious reasons!

My question is this - I'll be fitting winter tyres and I'm happy to carry / use chains. Am I mad to think I can do this in the QP? I'll have my 2 small children in the car, so keen not to take unnecessary risks. I'm not worried about mechanical failure; more concerned that the big fat tyres and RWD will cause me grief at the first sign of slippy roads.

All advice gratefully recieved !

M

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
I can't comment on the QP but my GranSport is shockingly poor in snow. If you do go, snow socks/chains would be a must.

Having had to get my family to push me up the smallest of inclines, I think the above plus probably turning off the TC would be the go. Wide tyres + front engined heavy car + CC gearbox = bit of a pain in the aris.

MattGTA

Original Poster:

419 posts

203 months

Sunday 16th September 2012
quotequote all
Pork said:
I can't comment on the QP but my GranSport is shockingly poor in snow. If you do go, snow socks/chains would be a must.

Having had to get my family to push me up the smallest of inclines, I think the above plus probably turning off the TC would be the go. Wide tyres + front engined heavy car + CC gearbox = bit of a pain in the aris.
indeed - that's my concern... Getting stuck with a 5 & 6 yr old would be a pain and the 'I told you so' factor would be unbearable!!!

Colossus

337 posts

245 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
Winter tyres should make a huge difference and if the Renault will be on regular summer tyres then I would take the QP every time. that said, it is still a big heavy rear wheel drive car so care will need to be taken.

sjp63

1,997 posts

303 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
Colossus said:
Winter tyres should make a huge difference and if the Renault will be on regular summer tyres then I would take the QP every time. that said, it is still a big heavy rear wheel drive car so care will need to be taken.
Agree - my RWD jag auto on snow tyres was brilliant in the snow when we lived in northern Italy whilst my wifes 4x4 was terrible until we fitted snow tyres.

crostonian

2,427 posts

203 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
I have a relative in Bolzano who had a QP until recently, he used it throughout the year but swapped his 20" Sport GT wheels for a set of standard 18"s with winter tyres during the colder months, not sure if he also used chains, but I do know that it was fine unless conditions were really bad.

Would be a big expense which I suppose could be justified if we had a cold winter here. Bear in mind also the cost of petrol on the continent, this sounds like an expensive trip to me!

EC2

1,547 posts

284 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
I've run winter tyres on my 4200 and now on my GranTurismo S Auto and find that they are great in snow. Only issue is ground clearance if the snow is too deep but that is the case on all 'normal' cars.

justin-banks

193 posts

271 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
HI M,
Dont think twice, you will be fine, see attached pics, me, Mrs JB, 3 little kids, all luggage, skiis and sledge on top, winter tyres only, alps and back every year. Ground clearance is fine and snow tyres perfect so never even close to getting stuck, go for it!, people taking pics of the car all the way.
The roof rack is inflatable so works great, its called handirack I think, kept hitting the 2m Height bars a the Peage though.





All the best,
Justin

lotuselan7

396 posts

245 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
EC2 said:
I've run winter tyres on my 4200 and now on my GranTurismo S Auto and find that they are great in snow. Only issue is ground clearance if the snow is too deep but that is the case on all 'normal' cars.
EC2 where did you get your winter tyres / wheel combo. I've just bought a new GTS and would like to run year round and planned on getting winter wheels tyres.
Thanks

MattGTA

Original Poster:

419 posts

203 months

Monday 17th September 2012
quotequote all
justin-banks said:
HI M,
Dont think twice, you will be fine, see attached pics, me, Mrs JB, 3 little kids, all luggage, skiis and sledge on top, winter tyres only, alps and back every year. Ground clearance is fine and snow tyres perfect so never even close to getting stuck, go for it!, people taking pics of the car all the way.
The roof rack is inflatable so works great, its called handirack I think, kept hitting the 2m Height bars a the Peage though.





All the best,
Justin
Brilliant!

MattGTA

Original Poster:

419 posts

203 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
So... thanks everyone for their input - discussed it with SWMBO last night and we're going for it ! bounce

I'll look into chains and treat myself to a set of std wheels and winter tyres and possibly one of those inflatable racks too.

Will keep everyone posted on preparation and progress !

Matt

EC2

1,547 posts

284 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
Well done - the right choice.

Last winter was my first with the GranTurismo so didn't really get the chance to try the winter tyres in much snow but the winter before in the 4200 was ace. Overtook a fair few SUVs which were probably on summer tyres in the snow - puzzled drivers I suspect!