Council tenants banned from displaying anti Labour election
Council tenants banned from displaying anti Labour election
Author
Discussion

chris watton

Original Poster:

22,552 posts

291 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
I know this comes from a Tory blog (I clicked on link from Guido's site), but is this legal?




part of article said:
A housing officer from Newark and Sherwood Homes, the Council's housing almo, decided that posters attacking Mr Peck were in breach of the tenancy agreement - on the grounds it was likely to cause offence. However it was decided that posters in support of Mr Peck were quite in order as they would not cause offence. So rather than getting on with tackling genuinely anti social behaviour we see Newark and Sherwood Homes launching the most astonishing attack on freedom and democracy.

http://conservativehome.blogs.com/localgovernment/...
Does this mean that, if you have a council house, you MUST be a Labour supporter, or else?



GadgeS3C

4,727 posts

195 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
Do you know what the posters actually said?

"Don't vote for John Peck" seems reasonable.

"John Pack should be (insert rude word)" might be offensive.

recalluk

816 posts

267 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
According to the blog it said

"No John Peck Rubbish here thankyou"

230TE

2,506 posts

217 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
recalluk said:
According to the blog it said

"No John Peck Rubbish here thankyou"
Mr Peck is a sitting councillor. Sounds as though one of his friends thought she was doing him a favour. It will be interesting to see how the man himself responds.

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
I suspect that Dawn Turner, Housing Officer in Newark & Sherwood Homes, is getting a little "training in PR" even as I write this wink

StottyZr

6,860 posts

194 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
I was about to say the letter seems fair, no polital agenda on display and all that. But they're allowed to show support for Mr Pecker... confused WTF??

Hackney

7,443 posts

239 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
StottyZr said:
I was about to say the letter seems fair, no polital agenda on display and all that. But they're allowed to show support for Mr Pecker... confused WTF??
And presumably for any other candidate / the opposition or whatever.

Just because the poster is negative to Peck doesn't mean the area has banned anti-labour posters or you're only allowed to put up pro-labour posters.

What they're asking tenants not to do is put up (admittedly not very) offensive posters.

MadMullah

5,299 posts

224 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
i read that as your not allowed to display any posters in your window etc

clearly i think someone's complained about it and its not been a generic letter sent out by some one from the housing office having seen it.

seems fair to me

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
I think it was 'banned' because it was denegrating/abusing John Peck.

If the poster had simply said 'Vote BNP/Tory/Labour/Jedi' then I assume that would have been fine.

Although I assume any poster could be said to risk offending a neighbour.

Unfortunately the reasoning in the tenancy agreement would also seem to ban posters that tell cold callers/lucky heather sellers to stay away.

ninja-lewis

5,507 posts

221 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
Is it not a fairly standard clause included to discourage tenants from hanging tatty flags out the window and causing an eyesore?

chris watton

Original Poster:

22,552 posts

291 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
ninja-lewis said:
Is it not a fairly standard clause included to discourage tenants from hanging tatty flags out the window and causing an eyesore?
I understand and agree with that. However, if the story is to be believed, those tenants showing pro-Labour material were left alone and allowed to show them.

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
chris watton said:
I understand and agree with that. However, if the story is to be believed, those tenants showing pro-Labour material were left alone and allowed to show them.
Positive posters would be allowed, negative ones wouldn't.

For example, if I said something negatively discriminatory such as "All blacks are stupid!", I'd rightfully be called a racist. However if I said something positively discriminatory such as "All blacks are extremely clever!" then I wouldn't.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
chris watton said:
I understand and agree with that. However, if the story is to be believed, those tenants showing pro-Labour material were left alone and allowed to show them.
I know many here would love to believe councils make these decisions based on party politics but the boring fact is the rules are clear and you can't put up negative posters or slogans. The people told to take their posters down were displaying an anti message, if they were showing support posters for an alternative candidate instead that'd be fine.

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
chris watton said:
However, if the story is to be believed, those tenants showing pro-Labour material were left alone and allowed to show them.
Therefore, don't believe the story at face value. There is something else going on here.

For my sins, I was a "Housing Officer" with a local council back in the 80s. These are lowly graded people whose lives are generally made a misery by low grade people. If my experience is anything to by, 10% of this girl's tenants cause 90% of her problems.

Housing Officers are the ones that are complained to about neighbours (when the police don't get that joy, and even if they do it usually gets referred straight back to them), untaxed cars, dog crap, fly tipping and everything else anti-social that tends to happen on social housing estates. If she's drawn a particularly short straw, she gets to do the rent arrears chasing as well rolleyes

When I was a Complaints Officer for a Housing Association, I found that a fair proportion of my "customers" were intelligent people who had got themselves into dire circumstances and had too much time on their hands. These people often dabble in politics, be it only going along to council meetings to be awkward, or sometimes actually standing for election.

I'll hazard a guess that something like this has happened:

The tenant who has put up a poster is a local pain in the arse in some way. Almost certainly he's got up the noses of some of his neighbours since he moved in, and one or more of them has been bending young Dawn's ear down the phone about his latest escapade with a poster. Frustrated or pissed off or both, she has decided that she can at least send a letter to the bugger - that way, if the complaints keep coming she can honestly say that she's "done something about it."

The letter goes out (a simple "please abide by the terms of your tenancy agreement" thing - all lowly stuff at this stage, no need for a superior to look at it or sign it) and is received by the tenant, who then goes into orbit. When he comes back down, he realises that he's just been given some manna from heaven by his landlord in the shape of this letter, and takes it to the press.

The first that Newark & Sherwood Homes officially knows about it is when some local hack gets on the phone to their PR Officer asking for the details.

Some 10 seconds later, the story gets to the Chief Executive. Who turns pale. Young Dawn's line manager is then summoned, and given a bking for letting his/her staff send out letters like this. Young Dawn gets summoned within the next 30 minutes and gets told not to do it again if she's lucky (or be told in the friendliest way "I'm afraid we're going to have to let you go" if she's not), whilst in the meantime the Chief Executive, the senior management and the Board members are running around like headless chickens indulging in rather a lot of damage limitation.

Forget the conspiracy theory, this is clearly a cock-up of monumental proportions smile

Edited by rs1952 on Tuesday 18th September 19:12

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
I think it was 'banned' because it was denegrating/abusing John Peck.

If the poster had simply said 'Vote BNP/Tory/Labour/Jedi' then I assume that would have been fine.

Although I assume any poster could be said to risk offending a neighbour.

Unfortunately the reasoning in the tenancy agreement would also seem to ban posters that tell cold callers/lucky heather sellers to stay away.
Just how was it denigrating /abusing John Peck?

All it was saying was that they didn't want any of his rubbish.

Borghetto

3,286 posts

214 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
Unsurprisingly this issue was raised with Eric Pickles in Parliament yesterday and he was referring it to the the local returning officer, with a strong recomendation that he takes action.

shoestring7

6,196 posts

277 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
rs1952 said:
chris watton said:
However, if the story is to be believed, those tenants showing pro-Labour material were left alone and allowed to show them.
Therefore, don't believe the story at face value. There is something else going on here.

For my sins, I was a "Housing Officer" with a local council back in the 80s. These are lowly graded people whose lives are generally made a misery by low grade people. If my experience is anything to by, 10% of this girl's tenants cause 90% of her problems.

Housing Officers are the ones that are complained to about neighbours (when the police don't get that joy, and even if they do it usually gets referred straight back to them), untaxed cars, dog crap, fly tipping and everything else anti-social that tends to happen on social housing estates. If she's drawn a particularly short straw, she gets to do the rent arrears chasing as well rolleyes

When I was a Complaints Officer for a Housing Association, I found that a fair proportion of my "customers" were intelligent people who had got themselves into dire circumstances and had too much time on their hands. These people often dabble in politics, be it only going along to council meetings to be awkward, or sometimes actually standing for election.

I'll hazard a guess that something like this has happened:

The tenant who has put up a poster is a local pain in the arse in some way. Almost certainly he's got up the noses of some of his neighbours since he moved in, and one or more of them has been bending young Dawn's ear down the phone about his latest escapade with a poster. Frustrated or pissed off or both, she has decided that she can at least send a letter to the bugger - that way, if the complaints keep coming she can honestly say that she's "done something about it."

The letter goes out (a simple "please abide by the terms of your tenancy agreement" thing - all lowly stuff at this stage, no need for a superior to look at it or sign it) and is received by the tenant, who then goes into orbit. When he comes back down, he realises that he's just been given some manna from heaven by his landlord in the shape of this letter, and takes it to the press.

The first that Newark & Sherwood Homes officially knows about it is when some local hack gets on the phone to their PR Officer asking for the details.

Some 10 seconds later, the story gets to the Chief Executive. Who turns pale. Young Dawn's line manager is then summoned, and given a bking for letting his/her staff send out letters like this. Young Dawn gets summoned within the next 30 minutes and gets told not to do it again if she's lucky (or be told in the friendliest way "I'm afraid we're going to have to let you go" if she's not), whilst in the meantime the Chief Executive, the senior management and the Board members are running around like headless chickens indulging in rather a lot of damage limitation.

Forget the conspiracy theory, this is clearly a cock-up of monumental proportions smile

Edited by rs1952 on Tuesday 18th September 19:12
Calm and sensible post is NP&E shock.

Thanks RS1952.

SS7

Riley Blue

23,218 posts

257 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Make up of Newark and Sherwood council:

Conservative: 22 members
Labour: 15 members
Independent: 4 members
Liberal Democrat: 3 members
Newark and Sherwood Independent: 2 members


AJI

5,180 posts

248 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Does the meaning of free speach these days mean you can only say positive things about 'things'?
Or can there be no balance in terms of saying negative things about 'things'?

In this case of the thread the word 'rubbish' being used as a 'negativity' in turn leading to people believing it is degenerating/abusive.
I thought 'abusive' was reserved for realy agressive sayings, but thesedays it seems any negative word is to be used leaving only positive comment acceptable?

Not what I would call 'free speach', but just my own opinion.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
rs1952 said:
Therefore, don't believe the story at face value. There is something else going on here.
I lived in a little village in Kent. It didn't have a pub, but what it did have was a colonel (rtd) who had too much time on his hands. He organised a group which bought some land to ensure no buildings were put on it. It just happened to be in front of his house, but it had to be somewhere. He then got a sponsor to put children's swings and stuff in there.

So far, so good, but he became a bit of a pain after that, demanding a place for a bonfire, a roundabout, that sort of thing. The he tried his piece de resistance: my village didn't have a public toilet.

It was true of course, and some of the older blokes were obliged to use bushes on a little piece of waste ground not far from the crossroads, in the centre of the village, and now a roundabout.

The council came up with objections, such as cost, but our colonel continued to push, writing to papers, vicars and such. In the end he got his way, but not quite as he intended.

The piece of rough ground was found to be unsuitable for some reason (probably too much old men's urine) so they had to look for an alternative location. The one they found was on the green, directly opposite the colonel's bungalow.

I thought it a bit cruel but if the intention was to stop the colonel campaigning, it fulfilled its purpose.