MP suspended from Commons after blaming 'lying' ministers,
MP suspended from Commons after blaming 'lying' ministers,
Author
Discussion

Du1point8

Original Poster:

22,986 posts

223 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
MP blames the lying ministers for british deaths in Afghanistan... I do understand his point, but its shame his voice only appears now and not when his boss decided to invade in the first place. Then there would have been a whole lot less death.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2204998/La...

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 18th September 2012
quotequote all
If he was talking about Iraq I'd agree more strongly, we shouldn't mix the two up. Invading Afghanistan was justified, sure you can ask why we joined the Americans right from the off in 2001 but after 2005 we would've had little choice.

The biggest lie in the case of Afghanistan is the suggestion that we ever had an exit strategy or we could ever win this war. High school history lesson will tell you we can't win a war in Afghanistan. We're coming out in 2014 when things will be no better than in 2012 which makes you wonder why we don't just pull everybody out now and to hell with the 'special relationship.'

As I understand it the basic objective was to defeat the Taliban and help form a democratic Afghan state. Is that going to happen by 2014? Of course not.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
If he was talking about Iraq I'd agree more strongly, we shouldn't mix the two up. Invading Afghanistan was justified, sure you can ask why we joined the Americans right from the off in 2001 but after 2005 we would've had little choice.

The biggest lie in the case of Afghanistan is the suggestion that we ever had an exit strategy or we could ever win this war. High school history lesson will tell you we can't win a war in Afghanistan. We're coming out in 2014 when things will be no better than in 2012 which makes you wonder why we don't just pull everybody out now and to hell with the 'special relationship.'

As I understand it the basic objective was to defeat the Taliban and help form a democratic Afghan state. Is that going to happen by 2014? Of course not.
So how do you justify it?

Not by your last paragraph. Those objectives were there well over a hundred years ago. We couldn't do it then and I don't believe anyone thinks we can now.

So give me a good reason.

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Defeating the Taliban in Afghanistan should have been relatively simple. Unfortunately we all went in with no actual strat. for doing what was wanted other than trying to find OBL and blowing the crap out of him.

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
DJRC said:
Defeating the Taliban in Afghanistan should have been relatively simple.
Not being contrary here, but really? Simple? Surely history has demonstrated to us that no invading force has ever had a real victory in Afghanistan?

What should we have done to defeat the Taliban and secure absolute victory that we haven't done?

DJRC

23,563 posts

267 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Marf said:
DJRC said:
Defeating the Taliban in Afghanistan should have been relatively simple.
Not being contrary here, but really? Simple? Surely history has demonstrated to us that no invading force has ever had a real victory in Afghanistan?

What should we have done to defeat the Taliban and secure absolute victory that we haven't done?
The Taliban arent Afghans. They are a foreign force aswell, core from Pakistan mixed with Islamic mercenaries. They were as unwanted in Afghanisatan anybody else. Asghanistan and Kabul especially through much of the 20th C had been one of the more enlightened areas of that part of the world.

Ousting a foreign, despised core with their ideology then should have been relatively simple. Indeed, militarily it was. We then cocked up by not having a proper policy of wtf to do with actually running, governing the place. The remit got expanded into taking on the bloody warlords, policing the country and generally pissing everybody off, then leaving again.

Talk if an exit strategy is almost laughable because we never really had a proper operational strategy whilst we were there to even get to an exit!

Afghanistan isnt centralised. It doesnt want to be. The centre around Kabul holds, the outlying provinces are essentially independant ruled by warlords and tribal elders and thats just the way they want. The warlords are happy to play the Taliban and Western allies off against one and other. The tribal elders dont want to get involved because they know the Taliban have only melted across the border anyway and will be back when the Western boys leave. The troubles now if trying to establish an independant Afghanistan military and police, of central structures are of our own making because we didnt have this planning in place when we went in. Instead we just pissed a lot of people off.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
People who claim defeating the Taliban should've been easy are the same people who think the Taliban is just a group of ragheads with rifles and mules. The reality is somewhat different. Mind you it might've been easier if we were invading the country where the Taliban actually are instead of giving multi-billions in aid to them. Just a thought.

REALIST123 said:
So how do you justify it?

Not by your last paragraph. Those objectives were there well over a hundred years ago. We couldn't do it then and I don't believe anyone thinks we can now.

So give me a good reason.
They attacked us, we had to respond. The Americans went in to Vietnam without us so it's not like they needed us to go into Afghanistan, but it did make half decent political cover I suppose. By 2005 we'd have had to join because it's what you do when somebody attacks you. Is it what your attackers want and expect? Yes. Is it stupid to take the bait? Yes. But we do it anyway.

It's less easy to justify the Iraq War except on the count that removing dictators who have killed their own people for decades is generally something most people can get behind.

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Marf said:
DJRC said:
Defeating the Taliban in Afghanistan should have been relatively simple.
Not being contrary here, but really? Simple? Surely history has demonstrated to us that no invading force has ever had a real victory in Afghanistan?

What should we have done to defeat the Taliban and secure absolute victory that we haven't done?
Nuke the from orbit, its the only way to be sure!