Reasonable charge for diagnostics
Reasonable charge for diagnostics
Author
Discussion

ss1977

Original Poster:

89 posts

216 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
I've recently been experiencing some rather loud knocking coming from the front suspension on the Z4. It's under the BMW warranty so booked it in to be looked at at a dealership.

I've been advised that following 2 hours-ish of diagnostic work, no warranty fault had been found and the noise was probably due to bolts not being torqued up to the correct spec during adjustments/work etc..., so it's chargeable. The car has had the front thrust rods and a NSF wheel bearing replaced during my ownership and has only ever had work done at an official BMW dealer.

Just wondering what people's opinions are of this being chargeable? Is it worth challenging that BMW themselves didnt't torque nuts and bolts to spec on previous occasions when work was carried out leading to the problem or do I swallow it and pay up?

Thanks!

318is boy

106 posts

233 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
If the only work to have ever been completed was by the main dealer then you have a very fair point and shouldn't have to pay. However, I believe there is an exclusion in the Mondial warranty regarding them not paying for reasonable diagnostic procedures.

Your argument however is that the work was not completed properly in the first place but maybe that is the argument to be having with the dealer who carried out the repair and you suspect didn't torque the bolts up correctly....

farbbm

335 posts

221 months

Friday 21st September 2012
quotequote all
I've recently been quoted £30 to investigate an oil leak on my 5 series which i didn't think was too bad, admittantly it is 6 years old, but it was still cheaper then the £75 VW wanted to look at my mates Golf air con.

ss1977

Original Poster:

89 posts

216 months

Friday 21st September 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies, chaps. Quick update on this. The dealer decided to waive the charges for diagnostics and has charged 1 hour for the work done to re-torque the nuts and bolts of the front suspension and check the alignment (it would otherwise have been almost 4 hours at main dealer rates - ouch!) Result is no further banging and crashing from the suspension on the drive home. Fair outcome in the end IMO.