Andrew Marr's History of the World BBC1 9pm
Andrew Marr's History of the World BBC1 9pm
Author
Discussion

Legacywr

Original Poster:

15,887 posts

219 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
Andrew Marr traces 70,000 years of history, beginning with the story of how the earliest humans spread around the world, surviving against the odds.

Looks quite good, and DD is quite week this series, so I shall set that to record, but it's odd scheduling from the BBC IMO!

LuS1fer

43,569 posts

276 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
I imagine it will be full of the usual gross speculation.

I've been watching The British on Sky - it's very good.

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
Might be good. Marr is a suitable voiceover/presenter man. There are so few real heirs to Attenborough, they are all so fking boring.

LuS1fer

43,569 posts

276 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
Nope, so is Marr.

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
Well I found it extremely boring and switched off after 10 mins, maybe less.
Marr was good in that recent history thing last year.

Legacywr

Original Poster:

15,887 posts

219 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
No, the programe was just pretty boring!

kenny Chim 4

1,604 posts

289 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
I imagine it will be full of the usual gross speculation.
I couldn't agree more regarding this 'modern' speculative history of human origin.

To me it's obvious that bi-pedal, sentient humans precede the age limits that these 'historians' provide.

For example, Marr suggested that homo sapiens first came on the scene 70'000 years ago (totally speculative!) He then proclaimed the 'we' first developed the sewing needle around 68'000 years later (ie 17'000 years ago). So what occurred in the intervening thousands and thousands of years? That's a serious amount of time to just learn to bore a hole in the end of a splinter of sharp bone..

As you so correctly say, speculation. In my view, it's the enemy of truth.


andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
kenny Chim 4 said:
He then proclaimed the 'we' first developed the sewing needle around 68'000 years later (ie 17'000 years ago). So what occurred in the intervening thousands and thousands of years? That's a serious amount of time to just learn to bore a hole in the end of a splinter of sharp bone..
Progress begets progress exponentially.

kenny Chim 4

1,604 posts

289 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
I understand Andy but there are several sites of human build that suggest that deliberate and long-term construction precede those of what are acclaimed by modern historians.

For example: http://www.megalithomania.co.uk/michaelarticle.htm...


andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
kenny Chim 4 said:
I understand Andy but there are several sites of human build that suggest that deliberate and long-term construction precede those of what are acclaimed by modern historians.

For example: http://www.megalithomania.co.uk/michaelarticle.htm...

Yes, I know where you're coming from; certainly Marrs is the 'populist' view, and compressing 70,000 years into an hour perhaps forked him down this road as there are probably a fair few examples of civilisations that have made advances only to be lost and reinvented millennia later.

I've no doubt we'll all be cavemen again in the distant future and be amazed when we once again discover knitting and gunpowder.

944fan

4,962 posts

216 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
I imagine it will be full of the usual gross speculation.

I've been watching The British on Sky - it's very good.
I have been watching the British too, it is good, although I felt it lost all credibility when Russel Brand appeared as one of the talking heads.

Also



They total glossed over the Norman conquest and went straight to life in Norman Britain. Given how much time was dedicated to the Romans defeating the druids I was expecting more.


Eric Mc

125,950 posts

296 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
A Sky history documentary? That's a rare thing.

Which Sky channel is it on as it had passed me by?

944fan

4,962 posts

216 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
On Atlantic / Atlantic HD

All episodes available on Anytime+ still.

chris watton

22,552 posts

291 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
944fan said:
I have been watching the British too, it is good, although I felt it lost all credibility when Russel Brand appeared as one of the talking heads.

Also



They total glossed over the Norman conquest and went straight to life in Norman Britain. Given how much time was dedicated to the Romans defeating the druids I was expecting more.

I gave up on this, too, they spent ages on things quite insignificant, and glossing over the significant. Even in their version of the Peasant's Revolt - Wat Tyler wasn't mentioned once!

Halb

53,012 posts

214 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
I thought it looked good, then I saw some of the talking heads, and thought again.

Big ups to Sky for throwing money at programmes though, they have come out with some cracking homemade stuff this year, it would have been unthinkable two years ago.

944fan

4,962 posts

216 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
Halb said:
I thought it looked good, then I saw some of the talking heads, and thought again.

Big ups to Sky for throwing money at programmes though, they have come out with some cracking homemade stuff this year, it would have been unthinkable two years ago.
Yeah the talking heads bit is odd. Some are professors of history etc and add something, others are tossers, although Helen Mirren looks freakishly good for her age.

Speaking of good Sky programs did anyone catch Networks of Power, also on Atlantic?

Was very good. Sir Christopher Meyer investigating the networks of power in 6 of the largest cities.

Eric Mc

125,950 posts

296 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
944fan said:
On Atlantic / Atlantic HD

All episodes available on Anytime+ still.
Don't have Atlantic - which explains why I wasn't aware of it.