looking to buy an e46 diesel
looking to buy an e46 diesel
Author
Discussion

Rib

Original Poster:

2,579 posts

220 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
Well my sister is after my recommendation, looking at a 320cd but I think shed consider anything thats a manual. Is there anything to watch out for? I think the orefacelift and post facelift had a problem with the swirl flaps, and the trailing arm bushes are notorious for wearing.

Anything else or more info of the flaps? And if anyone knows of a nice one for sale please let me know.

Cheers
Jon

rumple

15,451 posts

182 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
The swirl flaps arent on the manuals, as for rtab's i dont think they are a problem, ive done mine but its an 11 years old car, bushes will go on anycar , if you can afford a 330cd try that, its a sixpot, these cars will do interstella millages but are dependant on how they have been looked after.

Rib

Original Poster:

2,579 posts

220 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
well I did take her looking at a few over the weekend to make sure she liked them, basicly her Clio she loves but its just too thirsty for the motorway miles she does so she's looking to to do a straight swap value wise pretty much.

She LOVED the 330CD we went to see, drove it and loved the extra power, she also drove a nice 320d saloon and liked it just not as much. The thing is at the moment she's now having to manage her house + bills on her own since she split up with her fiancée so its more of a change to save money rather than a change to a car she REALLY wants, so if a 320D salon came along at the right price, well cared for, she'll have it.

I have got her into the E46 to show her an older car can actually be nicer, I love my BMW's and I think I might have her converted now.

anyway quick life story over! I take it the manuals with no flaps are just the FL? or all of them?

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
The 330D is the better car and ironically probably cost you less to buy seeing the 320d is more sought after by the budget-concious masses, and also of course you have more choice of older cars with the 330 as the 320 came in a bit later. The 330d is probably a smidge more juicy round town but you soon learn to keep your foot light and stay out of boost unless you need to really hustle.



the above was taken after getting home after a fast A-road drive from a friend's house, it was reading 46.0 on the outskirts of town but traffic lights and roundabouts started taking their toll fairly quickly. It normally sits round about 32-35mpg in day-to-day use round town.

Edited by vsonix on Tuesday 25th September 20:03

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
FWIW tax & insurance are hardly different between 320 and 330d, probably only about £20 a year difference in premiums... although the year it is made may affect the amount of tax you pay somewhat, if I recall correctly I think there may be a difference pre/post '03

Rib

Original Poster:

2,579 posts

220 months

Tuesday 25th September 2012
quotequote all
yes your right, 330's are around the same price bizarrely and I think with a de-cat and a remap are even better on the juice! insurance isn't a problem and tax is only about £30 difference so no biggy, its more about the right car at the right price, I have found one on another E46 site with 170K on the clock but has always been the BMW inc a recent clutch and looks a lovely car, just cant get hold of him!

Oh I forgot our search began with a drive of a local 318i at a dealers, jeeeez what a SHED, half the electrics didnt work, the tracking was so out she had the steering wheel pointed at 2oclock and it was clunking all over the place, it took some persuading to go see any more after that! hehe

Rib

Original Poster:

2,579 posts

220 months

Friday 28th September 2012
quotequote all
Well I have a few lined up for her to see, one of my favs is a 330d sport, owned by an enthusiest whis always used well regarded specialists, it does have highish miles but has been well looked after by the looks of it and is price d accordingly.

Got some others aswell so it looks like I will be busy this weekend!

I have seen a few especialy the 330's being remapped and decatted, is this considered a good thing to do? Makes sense to me to improve power and mpg?

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Friday 28th September 2012
quotequote all
As said above the 320cd (and 330cd) were very late cars appearing only in the last 2 years of Coupe production. Therefore there is a far better choice of saloons out there and you'll likely pick up a 2002/2003 330d for the same moiney as a 2005ish 320cd.

Though do the maths very carefully as there is a huge reliaiblity liability over both the diesels which could easily tip the case for an economical diesel very much the opposite way you would be expecting.

A 330i is probably a better choice now these cars are getting so old. It's not exactly a Honda in reliability terms but the engine is less complicated, less likely to go wrong and less expensive to fix when it does and leaves you with spare money to spend on fuel and fixing all the other stuff that goes wrong on old BMW's tongue out

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Friday 28th September 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
A 330i is probably a better choice now these cars are getting so old. It's not exactly a Honda in reliability terms but the engine is less complicated, less likely to go wrong and less expensive to fix when it does and leaves you with spare money to spend on fuel and fixing all the other stuff that goes wrong on old BMW's tongue out
Agreed. Old common rail diesels are just a ticking bomb - turbos, injectors, pumps, swirl flaps (and ALL 320d's have them irrespective of gearbox). The four cylinder Valvetronic engine is another big bill waiting to happen. The only E46's worth having are the six cylinder petrols. The 330i is superb, the 325i only slightly less so and the 2.2 litre 320i is a nice thing to punt around and not as sluggish as you'd think. The six pot engine just 'makes' the E46.