E91 325 or 330 Petrol cars
E91 325 or 330 Petrol cars
Author
Discussion

Steve vRS

Original Poster:

5,412 posts

272 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
I am giving up my 320d company car and fancy an estate.

I'll be doing a lot of miles (25k per year) but fancy a petrol. I'll get 45p per mile (first 10k etc) and so can afford to go petrol so is the 330 significantly thirstier in the real world than the 325 and on the flip side, is the 325 much slower in the real world?

Ta

Steve

ASR1

199 posts

255 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Same economy, more performance with the 330i

Steve vRS

Original Poster:

5,412 posts

272 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
What sort of consumption do you see on a motorway run at 70mph?

Thanks

Steve

Naldrett

176 posts

178 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
I have a 2005 330i with the N52 engine which has the slightly worse MPG but is thought to be more reliable. At 80-85mph it will do around 30mpg, so at 70 I would think around 33 or so. Lovely engine and a very stable car on the motorway with excellent gearing IMO

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
If you get the newer N53 engined car it will do over 40mpg on the Motorway but at a cost of reduced reliability. At 70mph you really should be seeing lots more than 33mpg out of the N52 engined example - I averaged 35mpg over 3000 miles earlier this month (80% Motorway 70-155mph, 5% town and 15% mountains) from an older M54 engined 530i for example.

il sole

287 posts

175 months

Friday 28th September 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
If you get the newer N53 engined car it will do over 40mpg on the Motorway but at a cost of reduced reliability. At 70mph you really should be seeing lots more than 33mpg out of the N52 engined example - I averaged 35mpg over 3000 miles earlier this month (80% Motorway 70-155mph, 5% town and 15% mountains) from an older M54 engined 530i for example.
Personally I don't believe all this talk of the N53 engine being unreliable. My friend who works at the local dealer says he sees hardly any N53 engines in for warranty work. My N53 has only done 35k miles, but it has been fine. Incidentally BMW have just replaced the ignition coils as a 'technical update', so if you're buying an N53, make sure that has been done.

My E91 330i, will easily see 40mpg on cruise control at 70. What it hates is stop start driving when it'll drop to 25. Don't buy a 325i, as the performance isn't a patch on the 330i...

Steve vRS

Original Poster:

5,412 posts

272 months

Friday 28th September 2012
quotequote all
What build date did the engine change?

Steve

Riff Raff

5,462 posts

226 months

Friday 28th September 2012
quotequote all
My N53 330 gets to within a gnat's bk of 40 mpg at 70. Best so far is 39.9.

Around town as others have said, it's low twenties.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Saturday 29th September 2012
quotequote all
il sole said:
Personally I don't believe all this talk of the N53 engine being unreliable. My friend who works at the local dealer says he sees hardly any N53 engines in for warranty work.
To be fair thats probably because there are hardly any out there, outnumbered 20 to 1 by diesels! Ours in its lifetime had a new fuel pump, new injectors, new coils all on a 3 year old car. There are numerous similar reports - the direct injection engines can be a real pain, so much so that the warranty (Which I note they've just significantly jacked the price on) is essential.

The fuel system on both these and the N54 is a real nuisance. My 335i had a recall for injectors too in what was presumably an attempt to get to the bottom of it.

The N52 has none of these issues but obviously isnt as economical either.

il sole said:
Incidentally BMW have just replaced the ignition coils as a 'technical update',
They don't tend to do that if there are no issues hehe

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Saturday 29th September 2012
quotequote all
I've read a lot about problems with the engine change over.
I wouldn't be worried about it tbh.
As above run them with a warranty and have peace of mind of any minor annoyances.

My next car will likely be 25i or 30i.
I run a 320d with a warranty,ran it for 3 years now with no engine issues,they are supposed to explode all the time lol.

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Saturday 29th September 2012
quotequote all
ASR1 said:
Same economy, more performance with the 330i
I've had my 325i round to a GPS verified 155 mph.
The 330i will also be limited to 155 mph.

While the 330i will probably be a tad quicker 0-60mph,
the 325i has slightly better fuel consumption.

Your money, your choice.

For the record, I can get my 325i to do 36 mpg, only if I
drive like a pensioner and I don't mind getting there tomorrow.

In practice 30-32 mpg in my normal use, and downto 26 mpg
if I drive in town a lot.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Saturday 29th September 2012
quotequote all
dcb said:
While the 330i will probably be a tad quicker 0-60mph,
It's a lot quicker - it's almost 50bhp up!

dcb said:
the 325i has slightly better fuel consumption.
The difference is negligable. About 0.5mpg combined.