Discussion
With the current question for eco-power (I'm not trying to start and debate on the rights/wrongs of this), why is there so little use of tidal energy? To a layman it looks plentiful and predictable, which for an island nation like us with unpredictable wind and little sunshine it seems like a winner.
The only talk about it seems to be for huge scale projects in the Severn estuary but can't it be done on a smaller scale all around the coast? I'm imagining turbines stuck on the sea bed all over the coast.
The only talk about it seems to be for huge scale projects in the Severn estuary but can't it be done on a smaller scale all around the coast? I'm imagining turbines stuck on the sea bed all over the coast.
Fittster said:
The only talk about it seems to be for huge scale projects in the Severn estuary but can't it be done on a smaller scale all around the coast? I'm imagining turbines stuck on the sea bed all over the coast.
The engineering involved in something that sits in the sea means even smaller scale tidal equipment costs a lot of money and even then it hasn't proven reliable.I was under the impression that tidal power generation was still experimental?
I wish that wind farms would stop getting used. They're a blight on the landscape and only produce power when it's windy, not when it's needed - meaning that normal methods of power generation are needed regardless.
Baffles me, there must be a better way?
I wish that wind farms would stop getting used. They're a blight on the landscape and only produce power when it's windy, not when it's needed - meaning that normal methods of power generation are needed regardless.
Baffles me, there must be a better way?
High maintenance costs. Very hard to engineer in reliability. Expensive to develop, and a lot of the designs from the 80s and 90s were IIRC bought up as patents and shelved by some of the big energy companies. I'm not suggesting nefarious reasons here, just that the alternates were cheaper and thus attracted the dev budgets.
Will be interesting to see what happens WRT the mooted private Seven development.
Will be interesting to see what happens WRT the mooted private Seven development.
You can lock a wind turbine or gear it up to stop it being damaged in extreme wether events, you can't do that to tidal power, the snake type ones I've seen anyway, which don't actually work on the tide they work by harnessing the "perpetual" motion of the sea.
But as above sea water is not an environment friendly to moving parts and reliable, cheap engineering.
FWIW whilst I'm typing I like looking at the offshore windmills and enjoy driving through the wind farms on the M74, I can see a single windmill from my house at the local cheese factory and find it aethestically pleasing - but that's just me.
But as above sea water is not an environment friendly to moving parts and reliable, cheap engineering.
FWIW whilst I'm typing I like looking at the offshore windmills and enjoy driving through the wind farms on the M74, I can see a single windmill from my house at the local cheese factory and find it aethestically pleasing - but that's just me.
Fittster said:
With the current question for eco-power (I'm not trying to start and debate on the rights/wrongs of this), why is there so little use of tidal energy? To a layman it looks plentiful and predictable, which for an island nation like us with unpredictable wind and little sunshine it seems like a winner.
The only talk about it seems to be for huge scale projects in the Severn estuary but can't it be done on a smaller scale all around the coast? I'm imagining turbines stuck on the sea bed all over the coast.
The Severn Barrage was first muted in the 70's i believe.The only talk about it seems to be for huge scale projects in the Severn estuary but can't it be done on a smaller scale all around the coast? I'm imagining turbines stuck on the sea bed all over the coast.
It basically involves a large gate that becomes a damn wall. At high tide, the wall is put up, and a reservoir is created behind that then empties via hydro turbines.
It's a great plan, and has the potential to create 20% or so of the whole UK's power. But apparently some crayfish spawn there so it's a no-go*. (*Slightly true)
(N.b. It's a huge project, just too huge for any Government to progress for fear of backlash. It would involve flooding many areas and the biggest compulsory purchase in the Uk's history)
Oh, and the oil companies don't approve.
As for other smaller schemes, see above. Saltwater and elctro-mechanical systems aren't best bed fellows.
Fittster said:
With the current question for eco-power (I'm not trying to start and debate on the rights/wrongs of this), why is there so little use of tidal energy? To a layman it looks plentiful and predictable, which for an island nation like us with unpredictable wind and little sunshine it seems like a winner.
The only talk about it seems to be for huge scale projects in the Severn estuary but can't it be done on a smaller scale all around the coast? I'm imagining turbines stuck on the sea bed all over the coast.
Missed your last sentence. There is an issue with both marine and wind power WRT to taking energy out of the system. In both wind and marine power projects there have been some quite serious knock on effects to the environment. With windmills there have been changes in weather patterns to the lee side of the turbines, which have resulted in SSSI bog land drying as it sees less rainfall, and the same has happened with marine turbines, which have seen changes to the deposition patterns of sand / particulates to the lee side of the turbines.The only talk about it seems to be for huge scale projects in the Severn estuary but can't it be done on a smaller scale all around the coast? I'm imagining turbines stuck on the sea bed all over the coast.
The basic problem is wind is light stuff moving fast so it isn't that difficult to take the energy from.
Tidal movement is heavy stuff moving very slowly. The fastest tide in the world (in scotland) reaches 16 knots which is freakishly fast a typical tide is closer to 2 to 3 knots which is too slow to easily gather energy from. There is a bonkers amount of energy there due to the mass of water moving just to capture it you need to divert a bonkers amount of water. The only places this can be done easily is where the land naturally funnels water into a faster stream.
I'm looking out of my office window at a valve which has been sat in hundreds of feet of seawater for 20 years and the outside of it is as good as new. Due to materials and paints used.
The subsea oil industry has the engineering challenges well under control.
Tidal movement is heavy stuff moving very slowly. The fastest tide in the world (in scotland) reaches 16 knots which is freakishly fast a typical tide is closer to 2 to 3 knots which is too slow to easily gather energy from. There is a bonkers amount of energy there due to the mass of water moving just to capture it you need to divert a bonkers amount of water. The only places this can be done easily is where the land naturally funnels water into a faster stream.
stinkysteve said:
As for other smaller schemes, see above. Saltwater and elctro-mechanical systems aren't best bed fellows.
RubbishI'm looking out of my office window at a valve which has been sat in hundreds of feet of seawater for 20 years and the outside of it is as good as new. Due to materials and paints used.
The subsea oil industry has the engineering challenges well under control.
thinfourth2 said:
The basic problem is wind is light stuff moving fast so it isn't that difficult to take the energy from.
Tidal movement is heavy stuff moving very slowly. The fastest tide in the world (in scotland) reaches 16 knots which is freakishly fast a typical tide is closer to 2 to 3 knots which is too slow to easily gather energy from. There is a bonkers amount of energy there due to the mass of water moving just to capture it you need to divert a bonkers amount of water. The only places this can be done easily is where the land naturally funnels water into a faster stream.
I'm looking out of my office window at a valve which has been sat in hundreds of feet of seawater for 20 years and the outside of it is as good as new. Due to materials and paints used.
The subsea oil industry has the engineering challenges well under control.
Yeah because the industry has an excellent record of equipment reliability Tidal movement is heavy stuff moving very slowly. The fastest tide in the world (in scotland) reaches 16 knots which is freakishly fast a typical tide is closer to 2 to 3 knots which is too slow to easily gather energy from. There is a bonkers amount of energy there due to the mass of water moving just to capture it you need to divert a bonkers amount of water. The only places this can be done easily is where the land naturally funnels water into a faster stream.
stinkysteve said:
As for other smaller schemes, see above. Saltwater and elctro-mechanical systems aren't best bed fellows.
RubbishI'm looking out of my office window at a valve which has been sat in hundreds of feet of seawater for 20 years and the outside of it is as good as new. Due to materials and paints used.
The subsea oil industry has the engineering challenges well under control.

Joking apart, the challenges are somewhat different though. A valve is very very different to a rotating turbine. A closer analogy is the prop on a ship or submarine and these do require regular maintenance - and often out of the water maintenance at that.
Surface based kit obviously has to be spec'd for 1 in 100 year (or greater) storms, which present huge wave amplitudes, and which have so far destroyed a lot of the experimental prototypes in storms much much smaller in magnitude.
BoRED S2upid said:
I really don't see the issue with windmills if they work but put them out to sea not on land, there must be 50 or so off the North Wales coast it wouldn't make any difference if there was 500.
Because they affect weather. They act like a big hill and change where the rain gets dropped. rhinochopig said:
thinfourth2 said:
The subsea oil industry has the engineering challenges well under control.
Yeah because the industry has an excellent record of equipment reliability 
Joking apart, the challenges are somewhat different though. A valve is very very different to a rotating turbine. A closer analogy is the prop on a ship or submarine and these do require regular maintenance - and often out of the water maintenance at that.
Surface based kit obviously has to be spec'd for 1 in 100 year (or greater) storms, which present huge wave amplitudes, and which have so far destroyed a lot of the experimental prototypes in storms much much smaller in magnitude.

As to ships the stern seal only gets changed on every 2nd docking so that is about once every 5 years
I can't see why you can't have a nice reliable mechanical type seal especially if you pressurised the generator housing.
As to wave power i can't see that ever working well due to the utter kicking anything on the surface can get from waves
rhinochopig said:
Yeah because the industry has an excellent record of equipment reliability 
Joking apart, the challenges are somewhat different though. A valve is very very different to a rotating turbine. A closer analogy is the prop on a ship or submarine and these do require regular maintenance - and often out of the water maintenance at that.
Surface based kit obviously has to be spec'd for 1 in 100 year (or greater) storms, which present huge wave amplitudes, and which have so far destroyed a lot of the experimental prototypes in storms much much smaller in magnitude.
Tidal power wouldn't use underwater turbines, like hydro electric does, it would use articulated floating thingies, like these bad boys...
Joking apart, the challenges are somewhat different though. A valve is very very different to a rotating turbine. A closer analogy is the prop on a ship or submarine and these do require regular maintenance - and often out of the water maintenance at that.
Surface based kit obviously has to be spec'd for 1 in 100 year (or greater) storms, which present huge wave amplitudes, and which have so far destroyed a lot of the experimental prototypes in storms much much smaller in magnitude.
http://www.pelamiswave.com/
Yes the technology exists, it's not impossible to overcome the engineering issues, but it's a question of cost, the off shore oil and gas industry is incredibly profitable and has the money to spend on engineering, it's very hard for new technologies to get a foot into the market let alone create the revenue and economies of scale to drive down the cost per unit of production.
It's still cheaper by a long long way to dig stuff up and burn it than these renewable form of energy.
rhinochopig said:
BoRED S2upid said:
I really don't see the issue with windmills if they work but put them out to sea not on land, there must be 50 or so off the North Wales coast it wouldn't make any difference if there was 500.
Because they affect weather. They act like a big hill and change where the rain gets dropped. thinfourth2 said:
rhinochopig said:
thinfourth2 said:
The subsea oil industry has the engineering challenges well under control.
Yeah because the industry has an excellent record of equipment reliability 
Joking apart, the challenges are somewhat different though. A valve is very very different to a rotating turbine. A closer analogy is the prop on a ship or submarine and these do require regular maintenance - and often out of the water maintenance at that.
Surface based kit obviously has to be spec'd for 1 in 100 year (or greater) storms, which present huge wave amplitudes, and which have so far destroyed a lot of the experimental prototypes in storms much much smaller in magnitude.

As to ships the stern seal only gets changed on every 2nd docking so that is about once every 5 years
I can't see why you can't have a nice reliable mechanical type seal especially if you pressurised the generator housing.
As to wave power i can't see that ever working well due to the utter kicking anything on the surface can get from waves

But back on topic. You could probably engineer something that would hit reliability targets, but having to lift, or maintain in-situ using ROV / Divers, is a huuuuuge maintenance on-cost if you have several hundred turbines out at sea. In terms of energy density they are poor compared to a power station, be that coal, nuke or geo thermal. I prefer nukes as they keep me in beer tokens.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


