UK's 1000 a day habit...
Author
Discussion

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,431 posts

292 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/immigration...

I am pretty far from a little Englander, but I don't think we have got the levels right.

I would opt for immediate deportation for any crime requiring a Jail sentence.


Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Its ok the conservatives said they would stop all this.

How are they doing on their targets they set.........

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
So the British rapist/murderer gets to stay in prison at huge expense for decades but only the foreign one gets deported?...

Mr_B

10,480 posts

274 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Just another subject in which if you comment for something sensible to happen, also means you are just branded racist.

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,431 posts

292 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Well I can't think of anywhere sensible to deport a British National to..

But I think if you aren't a British National and you commit a serious offence, then why shouldn't we have the option to deport ?

I'd put in some other Caveats too. Currently if you have a working Visa here and you earn of £18,000 a year you can bring dependants over on the same visa.

I think I would raise that bar a little higher, to say £40,000. As I assume at £18,000 level a married couple with children would still get state handout in the form of working tax credits.

England & Wales are having a population boom, our existing migrants are considerably more fertile than the indigenous. We need to stop new immigration and stabilise in my opinion.

No-one actually asks what is the right population level for this country - but I would say where we are heading to 70m people is too many.

TEKNOPUG

20,502 posts

236 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
It's not the total population that is the greatest concern; it's the demographics. We have an ageing population. People are retiring at 60-65 and living into their 90's. Birthrate is dropping and therefore the number of people at employable age and hence, paying tax and supporting the country is falling. So we either need to rapdily increase our birthrate or import young people from abroad.

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Gargamel said:
Well I can't think of anywhere sensible to deport a British National to..
Certainly not now that those damn Australians have become independent. The cheek of it!

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,431 posts

292 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
TEKNOPUG said:
It's not the total population that is the greatest concern; it's the demographics. We have an ageing population. People are retiring at 60-65 and living into their 90's. Birthrate is dropping and therefore the number of people at employable age and hence, paying tax and supporting the country is falling. So we either need to rapdily increase our birthrate or import young people from abroad.

Country 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
United Kingdom 11.76 11.54 11.34 10.99 10.88 10.78 10.71 10.67 10.65 10.65 12.34 12.29 12.27

UK birth rate - pretty much unchanged

TEKNOPUG

20,502 posts

236 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Gargamel said:

Country 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
United Kingdom 11.76 11.54 11.34 10.99 10.88 10.78 10.71 10.67 10.65 10.65 12.34 12.29 12.27

UK birth rate - pretty much unchanged
OK not dropping then but not rising to keep in touch with the falling death rate.

Digga

48,649 posts

314 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Gargamel said:
Well I can't think of anywhere sensible to deport a British National to..
Problematic since the antipodeans stopped accepting our deliveries.

It took bigotgate for NuLabia to realise they were a long way onto the wrong side of the debate as far as the public saw it. Prior to that, to even discuss on this sort of level would see some on-message nutter scream you down and brand you a Nazi.

I'm really not sure now what sort of prompt the coalition are waiting for though. Even recent immigrants think the system is wrong.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
pablo said:
So the British rapist/murderer gets to stay in prison at huge expense for decades but only the foreign one gets deported?...
We tried that with Australia and it's taken us 200 years to beat them at sport.

cymtriks

4,561 posts

276 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
TEKNOPUG said:
It's not the total population that is the greatest concern; it's the demographics. We have an ageing population. People are retiring at 60-65 and living into their 90's. Birthrate is dropping and therefore the number of people at employable age and hence, paying tax and supporting the country is falling. So we either need to rapdily increase our birthrate or import young people from abroad.
The current cure for this is simply unsustainable.

Import people to keep the population up for no good reason.
Make the excuse that they will help pay our way without ever explaining why we couldn't do that without them.
Imported people assimilate and end up with a low birth rate and many not paying their way
Import more people...

It is not clear why a falling population should be bad. Our ability to provide for ourselves is not defined by our numbers but by our wealth. A reform of the tax and benefit system could easily make a slowly reducing population viable. A falling population will mean more affordable houses, lower environmental concerns and ease pressure on resources and infrastructure.

It is also not clear why the only cure for a low birth rate, assuming that this is actually an insurmountable problem with no upside, is to import people. Perhaps not having a benefit system that openly discriminates against marriage and having familly/divorce laws that discourage men from marrying at all would help. Perhaps scraping child benefit so that contributing families were no longer paying for the children of non contributing families as well as their own would help balance the future budget a bit. In fact why not replace all child related benefits with a tax allowance. Those that earn get the benefit, those that don't don't. Give it a few years and watch the effect on education and state housing...

Mr Sparkle

1,936 posts

201 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Gargamel said:
Well I can't think of anywhere sensible to deport a British National to..
British Antarctic territory?

powerstroke

10,283 posts

191 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
TEKNOPUG said:
It's not the total population that is the greatest concern; it's the demographics. We have an ageing population. People are retiring at 60-65 and living into their 90's. Birthrate is dropping and therefore the number of people at employable age and hence, paying tax and supporting the country is falling. So we either need to rapdily increase our birthrate or import young people from abroad.
Great idea!! just like borowing our way out of recession Hmm as these will be the old one day.... and sorry importing young people, they get old too or a lot work for a few years and then return
home with a good wedge..

Asterix

24,438 posts

259 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Mr Sparkle said:
Gargamel said:
Well I can't think of anywhere sensible to deport a British National to..
British Antarctic territory?
Not fair on the penguins.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
TEKNOPUG said:
It's not the total population that is the greatest concern; it's the demographics. We have an ageing population. People are retiring at 60-65 and living into their 90's. Birthrate is dropping and therefore the number of people at employable age and hence, paying tax and supporting the country is falling. So we either need to rapdily increase our birthrate or import young people from abroad.
This is it. We could actually do a lot worse than being a good place to work. Being on the edge of a large continent full of skilled workers but smothered by high taxes, I'm just racking my politicians brain to see how we could take advantage of this...

Pints

18,451 posts

225 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
pablo said:
So the British rapist/murderer gets to stay in prison at huge expense for decades but only the foreign one gets deported?...
To hell with deportation. Rapists and murderers get the gallows, irrespective of their nationality. That'll deter would-be gangsters from making the trip over here, reduce the costs of having to keep them in a cosy cell for the next 20 years 18 months, and also help reduce the population, whilst cleaning the gene pool.

Anything I'm forgetting?
Oh, I'll do it for free.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Pints said:
pablo said:
So the British rapist/murderer gets to stay in prison at huge expense for decades but only the foreign one gets deported?...
To hell with deportation. Rapists and murderers get the gallows, irrespective of their nationality. That'll deter would-be gangsters from making the trip over here, reduce the costs of having to keep them in a cosy cell for the next 20 years 18 months, and also help reduce the population, whilst cleaning the gene pool.

Anything I'm forgetting?
Oh, I'll do it for free.
Yes. You're forgetting that this is the UK in 2012 we're talking about, and that the gallows would have to have CE safety certifications, the hangmen would have to be qualified medical doctors and the prisoners would have to have death counselling, after life planning sessions and complete a risk assessment before they could be executed.

Murph7355

42,095 posts

287 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Gargamel said:
...

But I think if you aren't a British National and you commit a serious offence, then why shouldn't we have the option to deport ? ...
It's a fair enough question, and personally I'd probably want foreign nationals deported for *any* criminal activity whether it resulted in jail or not. But...

From the article you quoted I couldn't see anything that linked the net "1k per day" and criminal activity...? ie even if you deported people on the basis you note, would it make any material difference to the 1k figure?

I would guess/hope that the vast majority of foreign nationals abide by our laws. And that it is Nationals causing more of the ills (criminal or otherwise) we have here.

I do agree with your other points though, and had exactly the same thoughts about the earnings requirement. It 100% definitely should be set well above the point where any benefits might be payable. And 18k for a couple strikes me as far, far too low for that.

Digga

48,649 posts

314 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Posted elsewhere on NP&E I mentioned a fact that Clegg trotted out in his LIbDim conference speech last night; in the time the UK GDP has grown 3 fold, our welfare spending has grown seven fold.

I wonder how long before they jon the dots of their data and analyse how much of this increased spending is attributable to benefit-tourism? The UK has long enjoyed the benefits of real, genuine, working immigrants, as well as offering sanctuary to genuine assylum seekers, but if we import too many people who then spend more than they actually earn, the rest of us have to get poorer to pay for it.