Keynes V Hayek - Who's right?
Author
Discussion

Spiritual_Beggar

Original Poster:

4,833 posts

225 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Curious as to where PH stands on this.


Keynesian economics seems to be 'de rigueur' for Western Governments these days, but find myself agreeing a lot more with Hayek's beliefs. Certainly, given his views on Socialism and the 'Welfare State'.

So what do you all think?;

Do we need to let the world markets ebb & flow free from Government regulation & interference in order for the markets to right themselves (Survival of the fittest/ most adaptable to change)....

or

Do we need that Government interference and regulation in order to try and control/ manipulate the markets when the brown stuff hits the fan in order to 'protect' those caught up in the mess?

Discuss...

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Government interference normally creates the pile of brown stuff and then makes us pay for the fan. I'm with Hayek.

fido

18,938 posts

286 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Problem with the failed socialist states is that they didn't save up during the 'good times' to pay for the fiscal stimulus during the 'bad times'. Gordon Brown was 'free market' during the boom but turned to Keynesian ideas when he wanted to continue the spending deficit.

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
An economist is a [person who says "on the one hand.... but then on the other".

They are both right - and they are both wrong - some of time.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
This is generally why economics is no longer about attempting to codify a method of economic transaction but rather to understand the human interactions that surround markets and how markets can best be employed for the good of humanity.

I go with Adam Smith...
Adam Smith from the wealth of nations said:
As every individual, therefore, endeavours as much as he can both to employ his capital in the support of domestic industry, and so to direct that industry that its produce may be of the greatest value; every individual necessarily labours to render the annual revenue of the society as great as he can. He generally, indeed, neither intends to promote the public interest, nor knows how much he is promoting it. By preferring the support of domestic to that of foreign industry, he intends only his own security; and by directing that industry in such a manner as its produce may be of the greatest value, he intends only his own gain, and he is in this, as in many other eases, led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention. Nor is it always the worse for the society that it was no part of it. By pursuing his own interest he frequently promotes that of the society more effectually than when he really intends to promote it. I have never known much good done by those who affected to trade for the public good. [emphasis added].

IainT

10,040 posts

269 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Anyone care to do a one-para summary of the two views for those of us who don't know much about economics (And don't have the time/are too lazy to read the wiki pages)?

jdw1234

6,021 posts

246 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
IainT said:
Anyone care to do a one-para summary of the two views for those of us who don't know much about economics (And don't have the time/are too lazy to read the wiki pages)?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0nERTFo-Sk


mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
IainT said:
Anyone care to do a one-para summary of the two views for those of us who don't know much about economics (And don't have the time/are too lazy to read the wiki pages)?
Hayek is the essence of liberal economics, influenced Thatcher very heavilly, believed very strongly that markets will regulate themselves and the only way to progress is to allow unbridled market forces to act. Very 80s. Furthermore he believed the instability market forces provide were good for society and individuals, essentially a that'll keep you on your toes type of argument. He ridiculed socilaism as an intellectual folly of the middle classes (quite succesfully argued imo)

Keynes is the largest infulence on modern macroeconomic thinking he essentially thinks that mistakes will happen, economies will flow with natural peaks and troughs and thus society needs to govern and regulate the peaks and troughs such that social inpact is regulated. He believed large public sector employement is a good way to regulate the economy and provide stability.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Guam said:
Basically Keynes has been in favour for a very long time now.
Really? I don't think governments have really followed his philosophy, rather just used a part of it as a fig-leaf to justify ever higher spending.

Edited by Fittster on Wednesday 26th September 17:14

Digga

48,649 posts

314 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
mattnunn said:
I go with Adam Smith
Considering Smith was a Scott and knowing what a bunch of cronies the last lot were, I'm amazed his philosophy hand status has not been brought into play. I guess they were more Trotsky than Scottish.

Mark Benson

8,264 posts

300 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Really? I don't thing governments have really followed his philosophy, rather just used a part of it as a fig-leaf to justify ever higher spending.
Exactly, Keynes advocated (in very simplistic terms) saving during the good times so you can spend in the bad times to keep the economy going.

Someone (everyone) seems to have forgotten the 'saving' bit....

And why does it have to be Hayek or Keynes, they're both right in parts and wrong in others IMO. What's needed is a policy that suits the country and economy and balances social responsibility with economic and corporate liberty. Bloody difficult line to tread though (which is probably why no-one's pulled it off succesfully).

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
They are both right - and they are both wrong - some of time.
Quite. The failures which led to our current problems are not failures of academic treatise but failures of common sense.

To wit, "We borrowed our way into trouble so now we must borrow our way out of trouble". Yeah right.

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Guam said:
Mark Benson said:
Exactly, Keynes advocated (in very simplistic terms) saving during the good times so you can spend in the bad times to keep the economy going.

Someone (everyone) seems to have forgotten the 'saving' bit....

And why does it have to be Hayek or Keynes, they're both right in parts and wrong in others IMO. What's needed is a policy that suits the country and economy and balances social responsibility with economic and corporate liberty. Bloody difficult line to tread though (which is probably why no-one's pulled it off succesfully).
So the Qe to buy debt whould be which school of thinking then?

I have SOME sympathy with Aspects of Keynes where REAL infrastructure funding is concerned to facilitate economic activity <true use of circular flow of income>, problem is that during deleveraging this gets broken, so the money <even if it gets into the economy which isnt the case now> is used to draw down debt. Pumping more in doesnt work, increasing taxes makes matters worse. We should be saying to Bernake etc, step away from the levers punks and keep your hands where we can see them smile

We need an economic Dirty Harry smile
I can't remember the guys name but he did this years Reith lectures, he says that the problem is that the social contract between the generations has effectively been ripped up and flushed, so the boomers who are doing this have had such a comfortable life (unlike the generation that came previous, WW1, depression WW2) they've lost sight of the possibility of things going bang and see no problem in simply pushing debt down the generations.

That is what QE and bond issuing is about isn't it? Just remortgaging the country and passing the repayments on to future generations.

I think this is getting traction with the population now and the liberals seem to have latched to it with the whole Alan Sugar bus pass schtik.

In my opinion this is not helped by politicians getting younger. What we need is for people to take a look at their Grand children and ask themselves what the fk they have done to deserve this burden.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
The important thing to take from both Keynes and Hayek is that both of them regarded a structural deficit in normal economic times as a very bad idea. We lost that somewhere along the line.

sidewayz

2,681 posts

272 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
I am for Adam Smith as well

Government forgot the save in the good times part with Keynes and ' to big to fail' meant a key Austrian school principle was ' forgotten' .

Theorists have value if interpreted with care and applied with intelligence.

So we are probably screwed.

IainT

10,040 posts

269 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
jdw1234 said:
mattnunn said:
Hayek is the essence of liberal economics, influenced Thatcher very heavilly, believed very strongly that markets will regulate themselves and the only way to progress is to allow unbridled market forces to act. Very 80s. Furthermore he believed the instability market forces provide were good for society and individuals, essentially a that'll keep you on your toes type of argument. He ridiculed socilaism as an intellectual folly of the middle classes (quite succesfully argued imo)

Keynes is the largest infulence on modern macroeconomic thinking he essentially thinks that mistakes will happen, economies will flow with natural peaks and troughs and thus society needs to govern and regulate the peaks and troughs such that social inpact is regulated. He believed large public sector employement is a good way to regulate the economy and provide stability.
Thanks gents! Rap battle wtf.

baz1985

3,685 posts

276 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Let's go revolutionary...Eugen (Jenő) Varga...


AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Murray Rothbard is worth a read. He's like Hayek on crack.

Hayek was a brilliant economist and writer, the Road to Serfdom is the book that influenced by political and economic thinking more than any other. But he just wasn't able to turn the tide of Keynesian thought that was dominant at that time.

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Guam said:
Basically Keynes has been in favour for a very long time now.
Really? I don't think governments have really followed his philosophy, rather just used a part of it as a fig-leaf to justify ever higher spending.

Edited by Fittster on Wednesday 26th September 17:14
Indeed a major part of Hayek's philosophy is that you bank in years of growth so it can be used to spend in bad years.

There isn't anyone following Hayek's philosophy.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
Hayek was a brilliant economist and writer, the Road to Serfdom is the book that influenced by political and economic thinking more than any other. But he just wasn't able to turn the tide of Keynesian thought that was dominant at that time.
yes It is amazing that, despite the fall of the Iron Curtain and the clearing of the Communist propaganda, his theories have not now been more widely accepted. Socialism is slavery. That's why the borders were closed. Big F*** Off example just over there to the east of us. Hello? Hello? Is this on?