E46 330 ci MOT fail - help please!
E46 330 ci MOT fail - help please!
Author
Discussion

liller

Original Poster:

1,151 posts

200 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Hi, my car failed its MOT dismally today...annoying.

The MOT centre was quite vague about the work that would need doing to ensure it passed so I took my car away so I can price it up accordingly instead of a "not sure how much it will cost until we start looking at it properly"

It failed due to the following:

Anti-roll bar linkage ball joint dust cover deteriorated.... What part will I need to replace here? the drop link from the ARB? and get a new dust cover?

Front brake juddering - I guess I will need new discs (MOT centre couldn't be sure so suggested I change both discs and pads)

Parking brake efficiency below requirements. No idea what this means and again, the MOT centre couldn't tell me what was wrong with it.

any help/advice would be really appreciated! car is an 2002 e46 330 ci coupe.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Doesn't sound too bad.

liller

Original Poster:

1,151 posts

200 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
yeah, I guess it could have been worse!

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
So you need a ARB drop link, at least a set of pads but possibly disks as well and at least the rear handbrake shoes adjusting or possibly new shoes too although doubt new soes will be required.

Not terrible at all.

eastsider

1,102 posts

254 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
liller said:
I guess I will need new discs (MOT centre couldn't be sure so suggested I change both discs and pads)

Parking brake efficiency below requirements. No idea what this means and again, the MOT centre couldn't tell me what was wrong with it.
By MOT Centre do you mean a high street drive in aimed at the masses type place?

Anyway I'd get it to a decent BMW indy for a second opinion/proper quote on what needs done. Sticky at the top has plenty of options depending on where you are.

liller

Original Poster:

1,151 posts

200 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
yes, it was Halfords

Not being very mechanical myself the vagueness and the hmmm and "don't knows" from Halfords has left me confused about what actually needs replacing for it to pass it's MOT.

So, the anti roll bar linkage ball joint - is that also known as a drop link? I can't seem to find the dust cover listed anywhere, maybe I am searching for the wrong thing?

In regards to the hand brake, they were equally as vague about this on questioning.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Gosh there isn't much wrong with that.

Pads and disks, if it needs both, are service items.

Handbrake adjustment, although a pain in the arse on BMW's, is a service issue.

Drop link ..... wearable item, so again a service issue, especially as it's a worn rubber.

Do you have your car serviced ?

If not, please do, you don't have to use a main dealer, a specialist will deal with "very" bmw issues, and most are so reasonably priced, you may as well let them do the servicing too.

Please go on recommendations, you'll find a good chap/place that way, I could help you in the midlands, but I see from your profile you're in London.

Have a scan at the sticky, as has already been suggested, and perhaps start another thread, looking for personal recommendations for your area.

It is probably beneficial, to use "proper" places for your mot too, these slowfit/hellfrauds type of places get the urine extracted out of them, because they do the same to customers.

liller

Original Poster:

1,151 posts

200 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
Gosh there isn't much wrong with that.

Pads and disks, if it needs both, are service items.

Handbrake adjustment, although a pain in the arse on BMW's, is a service issue.

Drop link ..... wearable item, so again a service issue, especially as it's a worn rubber.

Do you have your car serviced ?

If not, please do, you don't have to use a main dealer, a specialist will deal with "very" bmw issues, and most are so reasonably priced, you may as well let them do the servicing too.

Please go on recommendations, you'll find a good chap/place that way, I could help you in the midlands, but I see from your profile you're in London.

Have a scan at the sticky, as has already been suggested, and perhaps start another thread, looking for personal recommendations for your area.

It is probably beneficial, to use "proper" places for your mot too, these slowfit/hellfrauds type of places get the urine extracted out of them, because they do the same to customers.
Hi, I took my last BMW (e36) to Halfords and it passed with no problems so I took this car to them as it was a painless experience that time. This time it has been more of an annoyance, mostly because they have tried to bamboozle me and have not been straight with me on how much it will cost to fix the issues. It was going to be somewhere between £400 - £500 to sort.

I do service my car (not myself, usually I get a mobile mechanic out to do it) I have just looked through the car service history and I can see that it had new discs and pads this time last year (before I purchased it) so I am surprised that they all need replacing after 1 year and not even 5k of driving.

I'm going to get on the phone tomorrow and see if I can find a decent local indie. There wasn't an indie listed in the sticky that was anywhere near by so will ring round a couple tomorrow and pick one.

thanks for the advice!

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Your mobile mechanic should be keeping your car in better condition really, (assuming it isn't a year since it was last done, just for the mot .... a lot of people do that).

There is a "service", and there is a "service".

Some mechanics will just do plugs (whether they need it or not), filters and fluids, some will do that and check the car over, it is the latter you want.

Ask your friends who they use etc, you could always start a thread looking for a good mechanic in whatever area.

Don't just go on the fact your pads and disks were done whenever, my chap changed mine twice recently, the first disks failed within a fortnight (by failed, they began to shudder, because one had cracked, they were replced FOC of course)

Mr-B

5,146 posts

225 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
liller said:
Hi, I took my last BMW (e36) to Halfords and it passed with no problems so I took this car to them as it was a painless experience that time. This time it has been more of an annoyance, mostly because they have tried to bamboozle me and have not been straight with me on how much it will cost to fix the issues. It was going to be somewhere between £400 - £500 to sort.

I do service my car (not myself, usually I get a mobile mechanic out to do it) I have just looked through the car service history and I can see that it had new discs and pads this time last year (before I purchased it) so I am surprised that they all need replacing after 1 year and not even 5k of driving.

I'm going to get on the phone tomorrow and see if I can find a decent local indie. There wasn't an indie listed in the sticky that was anywhere near by so will ring round a couple tomorrow and pick one.

thanks for the advice!
I had an MOT with a Halfords type place a couple of years ago, they failed it and quoted me around £600 to get it passed. Took the car to another garage without having any work done on it and they passed it without any advisories. Make of that what you will.

Ona separate note regarding the handbrake you can do a quick and dirty fix by lifting up the covering over the handbrake lever and tightening up the nuts a couple of turns, not a long term fix but probably good enough to get it through the MOT.

liller

Original Poster:

1,151 posts

200 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
I am usually suspicious of MOT testing centres so used to take it to a council depot where they didn't do any remedial works!!

Reardy Mister

13,758 posts

253 months

Wednesday 26th September 2012
quotequote all
Is it a manual? I now someone who might want the box out of it...

All is not lost.

:heheh:

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Halfords garages are not a great place to start, the shops are fine just avoid the garages. Your discs should last 50k plus and 15-30k for the pads. Shouldn't be anything wrong with them.

eastsider

1,102 posts

254 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
If you are in North or East London I would personally recommend Highams Park motor company. In Highams park just north of Walthamstow, just off north circ. you can leave car with them for the day walk to HP train & be back central at Liverpool st in 30mins. Top chaps there Ive used them for several years.

liller

Original Poster:

1,151 posts

200 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
Reardy Mister said:
Is it a manual? I now someone who might want the box out of it...

All is not lost.

:heheh:
not ready to be stripped just yet!!

I'm in west london so North and east are a bit of a mission for me but thanks for the garage tips.

eastsider

1,102 posts

254 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
liller said:
I'm in west london so North and east are a bit of a mission for me but thanks for the garage tips.
Ok well I hope someone else will be along in a moment to make a personal recommendation on one nearer to you from the sticky. You know enough and have enough interest in cars to know you have an E46 BMW, to come here for advice and to have bought yours in the first place (rather than a Kia/hyundai/toyota/astra etc), please just find out a bit more about who can help you keep yours in good order for a fair price smile

ETA: what about these in NW London http://www.technosport.co.uk/

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
It sounds like it simply needs a dust cover (rubber boot type thing) for the ARB joint and the handbrake adjusted.

I didn't realise the MOT now covered 'juddering' brakes - as my M5 used to pass with juddering brakes all the time (due to pad material build up from track days). As long as the braking efficiency/balance met the requirements then it passed.

I wonder if they are simply going down the Kwik-Fit fail-it-on-something-minor-so-we've-got-something-to-charge-for route.

There's a council one in Hounslow (Bridge Rd Depot, Pears Rd, Hounslow, TW3 1SQ, 020 8583 5430)

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
I didn't realise the MOT now covered 'juddering' brakes - as my M5 used to pass with juddering brakes all the time (due to pad material build up from track days). As long as the braking efficiency/balance met the requirements then it passed.
Quite. For brake 'judder' to be felt on brake test rollers you'd have to have some seriously contaminated disks.

mmm-five said:
I wonder if they are simply going down the Kwik-Fit fail-it-on-something-minor-so-we've-got-something-to-charge-for route.
Given the type of pace that has done the MOT, you're probably bang on.

liller

Original Poster:

1,151 posts

200 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
E30M3SE said:
mmm-five said:
I didn't realise the MOT now covered 'juddering' brakes - as my M5 used to pass with juddering brakes all the time (due to pad material build up from track days). As long as the braking efficiency/balance met the requirements then it passed.
Quite. For brake 'judder' to be felt on brake test rollers you'd have to have some seriously contaminated disks.

mmm-five said:
I wonder if they are simply going down the Kwik-Fit fail-it-on-something-minor-so-we've-got-something-to-charge-for route.
Given the type of pace that has done the MOT, you're probably bang on.
Indeed, and no 'judder' can be felt at the wheel when braking! I'm fairly certain that they just wanted me to reach in to my wallet and pay for a new set of discs, pads and sensors for £230. I asked if I could just replace the one that was 'warped' and he said no as discs can only be bought in pairs. This in itself is utter bullsh!t

I have it checked in at a decent indie tomorrow morning so hopefully I'll get some straight talking.

Cheers for the council depot info in Hounslow, I have been to the one in wansdworth before so it's handy to know there is one closer to home.

liller

Original Poster:

1,151 posts

200 months

Thursday 27th September 2012
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
It sounds like it simply needs a dust cover (rubber boot type thing) for the ARB joint
the wording they use on the fail sheet is what has confused me as apparently the 'dust cover' is actually part of the ARB link and not like a rubber boot that goes over the ball joint.