Politically neutral radio station
Discussion
Chaps,
I am an avid radio listener. And it's always Radio 4. I listen to it alot, and mainly for the news and comment. (It is, however, often turned off for an hour or so whenever 'Woman's Hour' comes on air ... )
However I am becoming ever more aware of the left-wing political bias in the BBC, and the bias on Radio 4. It's not always evident, but quite often I hear a piece and realise that the underlying assumption is a left-leaning one, and not one that I agree with.
The question therefore is what other radio stations are there? It needs to have good news and current affairs coverage, and needs to have reasonable comment. It needs to be fairly intellectual and has to cover a good, wide range of subjects. Given these requirements, what alternatives are there to Radio 4?
Oli.
I am an avid radio listener. And it's always Radio 4. I listen to it alot, and mainly for the news and comment. (It is, however, often turned off for an hour or so whenever 'Woman's Hour' comes on air ... )
However I am becoming ever more aware of the left-wing political bias in the BBC, and the bias on Radio 4. It's not always evident, but quite often I hear a piece and realise that the underlying assumption is a left-leaning one, and not one that I agree with.
The question therefore is what other radio stations are there? It needs to have good news and current affairs coverage, and needs to have reasonable comment. It needs to be fairly intellectual and has to cover a good, wide range of subjects. Given these requirements, what alternatives are there to Radio 4?
Oli.
There's just no such thing as politically neutral. I suspect the bias has always been there, you're just starting to notice it more.
When I stayed in a hotel a few weeks ago I put on the BBC world service as it was just about the only English language thing I could find, not having been in the UK for a while. I literally couldn't stand it. It was how I imagine Radio Moscow would have been in the 1950s.
It was probably always like that, but when I used to hear it regularly it didn't really bother me.
When I stayed in a hotel a few weeks ago I put on the BBC world service as it was just about the only English language thing I could find, not having been in the UK for a while. I literally couldn't stand it. It was how I imagine Radio Moscow would have been in the 1950s.
It was probably always like that, but when I used to hear it regularly it didn't really bother me.
Eric Mc said:
Sadly, "poliically neutral" would probably equate with "brain neutral".
Yes, and this is the positive spin - that listening to a left-biased station does keep me alert and attentive, spotting the various nuances which are almost invisibly placed on the words which are used. Still, it would be nice to have an alternative sometimes, and and I am wondering what that might be.
Oli.
martin84 said:
'Politically neutral' would just be reading facts off a card.
I had an arguement with a colleague earlier today, he said exactly that
I told him he was talking rubbish 
Politically neutral could mean stating the facts, then having a spokespersons with different viewpoints babble on? Why not.
StottyZr said:
martin84 said:
'Politically neutral' would just be reading facts off a card.
I had an arguement with a colleague earlier today, he said exactly that
I told him he was talking rubbish 
Politically neutral could mean stating the facts, then having a spokespersons with different viewpoints babble on? Why not.
Blib said:
BBC World Service usually plays with a pretty straight bat.
BBC WS has traditionally been funded by the Foreign Office as a form of soft power, like the British Council. It is, as you say, usually pretty neutral but on occasion the news sounds as if it's been dictated by the Foreign Secretary to paint Britain in the best light possible.The trouble with demands for political neutrality is that very few people will admit their own bias. You have some posters on PH who will swear blind that the Daily Telegraph and Fox News are not biased to the right.
Bias isn't the same as holding a reasoned viewpoint on the basis of objective evidence.
For bias to be present in journalism, there needs to be systematic and repeated lack of key indicators including balance, independence and the use of reason and logic rather than dogma in order to describe a position as biased and that description fits the BBC's news and current affairs output very well.
The painful fact for Liarbore and Libdim supporters is that on balance the least worst and least incompetent position isn't one held by either Party. If a news outlet was to reflect that fact and included an explicit defensible rationale it would not be bias.
Obviously the Tories and UKIP aren't lacking in ineptitude and when it happens they get criticised on PH too. To say that nobody criticises these Parties is a strawman/straw man (pedants take your pick). Various elements of CMD muppetry feature on here regularly.
For bias to be present in journalism, there needs to be systematic and repeated lack of key indicators including balance, independence and the use of reason and logic rather than dogma in order to describe a position as biased and that description fits the BBC's news and current affairs output very well.
The painful fact for Liarbore and Libdim supporters is that on balance the least worst and least incompetent position isn't one held by either Party. If a news outlet was to reflect that fact and included an explicit defensible rationale it would not be bias.
Obviously the Tories and UKIP aren't lacking in ineptitude and when it happens they get criticised on PH too. To say that nobody criticises these Parties is a strawman/straw man (pedants take your pick). Various elements of CMD muppetry feature on here regularly.
Radio 4 is generally excellent, and I am not aware of an alternative station which has a right wing agenda. Perhaps there is a gap in the market for Torygraph FM? Talksport's previous incarnation, Talk Radio would have been the closest thing, but they switched to a sport format many years ago.
The BBC has actually improved in the last couple of years. It used to have a strong liberal bias on issues such as immigration and the EU. Views which dissented from the liberal line were seldom given airtime. If this was obvious to a pinko Guardian reader like me, it's no wonder right wingers were pissed off. Coverage of both of these issues is now much more balanced, thankfully.
The BBC has actually improved in the last couple of years. It used to have a strong liberal bias on issues such as immigration and the EU. Views which dissented from the liberal line were seldom given airtime. If this was obvious to a pinko Guardian reader like me, it's no wonder right wingers were pissed off. Coverage of both of these issues is now much more balanced, thankfully.
Is it possible to have a viewpoint without that being biased in some way? Surely your 'bias' helps shape your viewpoint? Is it possible to be properly neutral without killing any story which might be there? For instance the BBC have to show their neutrality in news reports by showing snippets of Labour and Tory MP's talking about something. When 'gauging the public mood' they just show two people in the street nodding with approval and two others shaking their head and tutting.
zcacogp said:
Chaps,
I am an avid radio listener. And it's always Radio 4. I listen to it alot, and mainly for the news and comment. (It is, however, often turned off for an hour or so whenever 'Woman's Hour' comes on air ... )
However I am becoming ever more aware of the left-wing political bias in the BBC, and the bias on Radio 4. It's not always evident, but quite often I hear a piece and realise that the underlying assumption is a left-leaning one, and not one that I agree with.
The question therefore is what other radio stations are there? It needs to have good news and current affairs coverage, and needs to have reasonable comment. It needs to be fairly intellectual and has to cover a good, wide range of subjects. Given these requirements, what alternatives are there to Radio 4?
Oli.
I'm guessing you, like most PHers are somewhat right wing. Find a right wing radio station that agrees with your views on most issues and hey presto, no bias!I am an avid radio listener. And it's always Radio 4. I listen to it alot, and mainly for the news and comment. (It is, however, often turned off for an hour or so whenever 'Woman's Hour' comes on air ... )
However I am becoming ever more aware of the left-wing political bias in the BBC, and the bias on Radio 4. It's not always evident, but quite often I hear a piece and realise that the underlying assumption is a left-leaning one, and not one that I agree with.
The question therefore is what other radio stations are there? It needs to have good news and current affairs coverage, and needs to have reasonable comment. It needs to be fairly intellectual and has to cover a good, wide range of subjects. Given these requirements, what alternatives are there to Radio 4?
Oli.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




