taxation is the enemy of aspiration
Discussion
Nick Ross has made a massive profit on the sale of his London (home) I emphasize the word home, at a time when the libdems want to push their mansion tax plans.This is the mans home and surely this should be the one thing that taxman should leave alone, good look to him I say.Give a man the knowledge that he can keep more of the money he earns and he will work hard.Tax him to death and yes we cant evan die without paying tax, and he will give up. Or he will try to avoid the tax.taxation is the enemy of aspiration
rocky65 said:
...but seeing people who dont and have never worked drive new cars...
Aside from maybe disabled people with a motability cars and young lottery winners, who exactly do you see driving brand new cars having never worked?We seem to have this discussion every time a Liberal Democrat says something about tax. We've discussed tax rates to death, most notably in the fallout of budget-gate regarding the 50% tax rate. In the 1970s, Britain had a tax rate of 83% on incomes over £25,000 (roughly £155,000 in todays money) and the 1970's ended with mass unemployment, no electricity, a huge strike and an IMF bailout. By the end of the 1980s the tax rate reduced to 40% and the Government's tax take increased four-fold. There's arguments about the 'laffer curve' etc but we have generally found 40% to be the level where we get the most out of the highest earners without encouraging them to either not bother working or to go abroad.
Even Gordon Brown recognised 40% was probably as high as you could go, in 11 budgets he never raised the top rate of income tax (although he did other things to make more people pay that rate and others). The 50% tax was his idea after leaving the office in order to leave a timebomb for the next guy to fix.
davepoth said:
Karl Marx said:
From each according to his ability, to each according to his need.
I hope that one day I'm in a position to justify having an accountant to look after my financial affairs. I also hope that when the time comes I ask him not to look for loopholes but to ensure I pay my fair share.
Hackney said:
Maybe 40% is the right amount. The difficulty is getting the "wealthy" (and I have no firm definition of that, but I know it's more than I earn) who actually pay less than that by technically living abroad, or by paying themselves a nominal salary etc, etc.
I hope that one day I'm in a position to justify having an accountant to look after my financial affairs. I also hope that when the time comes I ask him not to look for loopholes but to ensure I pay my fair share.
If you get to that point and still hold the same view, there would be no need to employ an accountant.I hope that one day I'm in a position to justify having an accountant to look after my financial affairs. I also hope that when the time comes I ask him not to look for loopholes but to ensure I pay my fair share.
I suspect there are very few "rich" people paying significantly under what most others pay even in percentage terms. And when you consider how much they are paying in hard £s, how anyone could consider the amounts "unfair" is laughable.
Any tax that takes more than half of someone's income or wealth is just plain wrong.
martin84 said:
Aside from maybe disabled people with a motability cars and young lottery winners, who exactly do you see driving brand new cars having never worked?
We seem to have this discussion every time a Liberal Democrat says something about tax. We've discussed tax rates to death, most notably in the fallout of budget-gate regarding the 50% tax rate. In the 1970s, Britain had a tax rate of 83% on incomes over £25,000 (roughly £155,000 in todays money) and the 1970's ended with mass unemployment, no electricity, a huge strike and an IMF bailout. By the end of the 1980s the tax rate reduced to 40% and the Government's tax take increased four-fold. There's arguments about the 'laffer curve' etc but we have generally found 40% to be the level where we get the most out of the highest earners without encouraging them to either not bother working or to go abroad.
Even Gordon Brown recognised 40% was probably as high as you could go, in 11 budgets he never raised the top rate of income tax (although he did other things to make more people pay that rate and others). The 50% tax was his idea after leaving the office in order to leave a timebomb for the next guy to fix.
Wow - i agree with martin84!We seem to have this discussion every time a Liberal Democrat says something about tax. We've discussed tax rates to death, most notably in the fallout of budget-gate regarding the 50% tax rate. In the 1970s, Britain had a tax rate of 83% on incomes over £25,000 (roughly £155,000 in todays money) and the 1970's ended with mass unemployment, no electricity, a huge strike and an IMF bailout. By the end of the 1980s the tax rate reduced to 40% and the Government's tax take increased four-fold. There's arguments about the 'laffer curve' etc but we have generally found 40% to be the level where we get the most out of the highest earners without encouraging them to either not bother working or to go abroad.
Even Gordon Brown recognised 40% was probably as high as you could go, in 11 budgets he never raised the top rate of income tax (although he did other things to make more people pay that rate and others). The 50% tax was his idea after leaving the office in order to leave a timebomb for the next guy to fix.
rocky65 said:
You said it right, legal theft at that and also a way of keeping us down.Im all for working hard but seeing people who dont and have never worked drive new cars and have all the things I work hard for that realy makes paying my tax a real pain .
I too am intrigued. Tell us more about the new car thing."From each according to his ability, to each according to his need."
No thanks - or, not quite anyway.
Safety net within limits of cost and time, yes.
Decent life for those dealt a carp hand, yes.
More than that, no.
Need is too easily and too often accidentally/deliberately confused with want; when need is supplied instead, shop windows go in and instead of jail, some Marxist pops up and blames the innocent hardworking class for daring to have shiny things that wasters can't afford. Tough s
t.
No thanks - or, not quite anyway.
Safety net within limits of cost and time, yes.
Decent life for those dealt a carp hand, yes.
More than that, no.
Need is too easily and too often accidentally/deliberately confused with want; when need is supplied instead, shop windows go in and instead of jail, some Marxist pops up and blames the innocent hardworking class for daring to have shiny things that wasters can't afford. Tough s
t.Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


