Ed on Marr show this morning
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Sunday 30th September 2012
quotequote all
Another cracker from Ed this morning when talking about how if there was an election tomorrow the first thing he would do would be to reverse the 50% top rate of tax decision.

Apparently .. And I quote "Cameron is writing a check for £40k for each of his millionaire chums" by reducing the top rate of tax by 5%.

First of all Ed ( you fecking moron ), someone would have to be earning £1m per year and not mearly just be a millionaire for this to be true.

Secondly, and more importantly, it's the tax payers OWN fecking money in the first place! The government wouldn't be writing anyone any checks, they just wouldn't be robbing them quiet as much as they are doing today.

Marr of course didn't even pull him up on this.

I won't even go into his "Tax on bankers to get more young people into work "nonsense again.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Sunday 30th September 2012
quotequote all
Bandit said:
Marr of course didn't even pull him up on this.
I thought Marr cornered Red Ed nicely over "pay". I paraphrase,

Marr: "So Ed, you're not going to increase public spending but you want to help the unions get higher pay for private sector workers - doesn't this mean higher pay for public sector workers as well, paid for by the taxpayer?"

Ed: "Waffle, waffle, waffle, waffle, when we can afford it."

Yeah right.

Slaav

4,377 posts

241 months

Sunday 30th September 2012
quotequote all
He was a total this morning - Ed that is! Although let off too lightly by Marr.

Every time he got slightly picked up on something he would just "Well if you would just let me explain it to you...." ad nauseum frown

Absolute odious little cretin - Ed that is smile

The Millionaire thing happened previously on QT I think it was; that little prick who is responsible for teh Chavs book - He came out with similar and seemed rather befuddled when it was pointed out that the EARNINGS had to be £1M+ for teh '£40K giveaway'. Really doesnt matter though as the vast majority simply hear the bks being said and choose to believe it - without thinking or questioning....

croyde

26,551 posts

261 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
I was working on that show but at first I thought Ed was some little work experience tosspot trying to get into journalism.

Since when did party leaders get so young biggrin

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Having never received a bankers bonus I am unfamiliar with the mechanics of it so could someone more in the know explain exactly why the idea of a 'tax on bankers bonuses' wouldn't work? Is a bonus already taxable income? Could it be paid as 'salary' to avoid an extra levy or something along those lines?

On the subject of Miliband, someone probably should point out the top rate of tax kicks in at £150,000 which GCSE level maths will tell you isn't a millionaire. I'm also not sure where Labour get the figure of £3billion from when explaining how much the tax cut will cost. My problem with his rhetoric is he seems to believe my money is his money and anything my Government lets me keep is a 'giveaway.'

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Having never received a bankers bonus I am unfamiliar with the mechanics of it so could someone more in the know explain exactly why the idea of a 'tax on bankers bonuses' wouldn't work? Is a bonus already taxable income? Could it be paid as 'salary' to avoid an extra levy or something along those lines?

On the subject of Miliband, someone probably should point out the top rate of tax kicks in at £150,000 which GCSE level maths will tell you isn't a millionaire. I'm also not sure where Labour get the figure of £3billion from when explaining how much the tax cut will cost. My problem with his rhetoric is he seems to believe my money is his money and anything my Government lets me keep is a 'giveaway.'
Go on I will bite. Why tax just bankers bonuses?

Considering it was 'a one off' last time, why again should bankers pay from their bonus alone?

It raises very little and people often get paid in shares not in multi million cash deals, it stops them walking away.

Oh and the biggest thing is that most of the bonuses are already taxed at 40% anyway, so making them take it in shares to protect their money reduces the normal tax money grab.

Last time Labour did this, London lost 1/4 of all hedge funds and lost several hundred million in taxes (direct and indirect). But no one remembers that eh.

fuking idiots

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/19d6e46c-cd97-11df-9c82-...

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
Go on I will bite. Why tax just bankers bonuses?

Considering it was 'a one off' last time, why again should bankers pay from their bonus alone?
I'm not arguing about principle. I'm asking why it wouldn't/couldn't work. We both know why he's mentioning bankers bonuses, to get the public onside. I was taken aback by the notion of those working for a bank which required a taxpayer bailout receiving 'bonuses' but in the case of Bob Diamond - whose bank is not propped up by us - I really didn't care how big his payoff was.

Du1point8 said:
It raises very little and people often get paid in shares not in multi million cash deals, it stops them walking away.

Oh and the biggest thing is that most of the bonuses are already taxed at 40% anyway, so making them take it in shares to protect their money reduces the normal tax money grab.
Thank you. That goes some way to answering my question.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Ed Milliband is the Tories' secret weapon.

Ed Balls is very, very dangerous. He doesn't care what he says so long as it sounds good. You read it here....


fandango_c

1,993 posts

217 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
On the subject of Miliband, someone probably should point out the top rate of tax kicks in at £150,000 which GCSE level maths will tell you isn't a millionaire. I'm also not sure where Labour get the figure of £3billion from when explaining how much the tax cut will cost. My problem with his rhetoric is he seems to believe my money is his money and anything my Government lets me keep is a 'giveaway.'
Labour (Miliband and Balls) are confused between assets and income - a millionaire being someone who has in excess of £1m in assets, as opposed to someone who earns £1m pa. Income tax being paid on income and not assets. Worrying that this is coming from the shadow chancellor - he's either incompetent or lying.

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Also banker bonus wouldnt work as it will end up being like those people in France... the people who get paid the most are very very mobile and do not care where they live.

You push them and they will leave and go somewhere else as will the banks trading departments... I hear Swiss are quite accommodating.

If I remember last time it was like this:

Banks must pay a 50% tax on any bonuses worth more than £25,000. So a bonus of £35,000, the bank would pay half of the amount above the £25,000 threshold - in this case a fee of £5,000.

However that doesnt affect traders as much as they will never really get a £2million bonus in cash, so the people who do get affected are middle and back office staff.

Also in addition its discretionary bonuses only that were affected, lots of traders are on Contractual.

So ways round it include:

Banks paying the tax for staff (doubt that will happen again)
Converting bonus to salary now.
Pay in shares
defering the payment (only worked last time)
Calling it something other than a bonus.
Make staff contractors.

I really dont see why they would even try and take them on again...

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
fandango_c said:
Labour (Miliband and Balls) are confused between assets and income - a millionaire being someone who has in excess of £1m in assets, as opposed to someone who earns £1m pa. Income tax being paid on income and not assets. Worrying that this is coming from the shadow chancellor - he's either incompetent or lying.
Certain supporters of Labour and probably Labour themselves are also confused between Government spending and financial crisis. There's still plenty who believe we're cutting public spending because the banks crashed.

Labour have a different definition of rich than I do. Someone who earns an awful lot of money obviously has the potential to become rich, they should be managing their money properly to ensure they're stable but a large income can always be taken away. I define a rich person as someone who doesn't need to work anymore, who can carry themselves through to death in their current lifestyle without worrying.

Ari

19,841 posts

246 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
Last time Labour did this, London lost 1/4 of all hedge funds
Lost hedge funds!!? Bloody hell, it's a wonder the world is still turning, what with the impact on... on... err, help me someone? biggrin

croyde

26,551 posts

261 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
I love the way that all political parties avoid the obvious thing which is to raise income tax for all over the minimum level. It has got to be the fairest tax and better than all the other taxes they have brought in over the years to make up for the 'low' income tax.

Last week Clegg was banging on about his 'mansion tax' which like the council tax does not take in to account how much money the individual actually has. There are oldies round here in SW London who moved here and paid for their houses back in the 50s, 60s and 70s who now find themselves sitting in houses that are worth over one million yet they are surviving on their pensions.

Taxing, yet again, on home worth will only force people to sell their one big asset which may be due to become an inheritance, a pension fund or pay for old age care.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Du1point8 said:
Du1point8 said:
It raises very little and people often get paid in shares not in multi million cash deals, it stops them walking away.

Oh and the biggest thing is that most of the bonuses are already taxed at 40% anyway, so making them take it in shares to protect their money reduces the normal tax money grab.
Thank you. That goes some way to answering my question.
Not really. If someone receives shares as a bonus that will still trigger a 40% tax liability on their value. Share options might not but I don't think that is the norm with bank bonuses.

I am firmly on the side of reducing tax all round, in line with major cuts in public spending. Increasing taxes for anyone is not gong to help anyone. But one can see how the massive bonuses to bankers for very little perceived benefit to anyone but themselves has caused resentment.


Digga

48,649 posts

314 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
My problem with his rhetoric is he seems to believe my money is his money and anything my Government lets me keep is a 'giveaway.'
Welcome to the ideology of 'dependency culture'.

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
martin84 said:
Du1point8 said:
Du1point8 said:
It raises very little and people often get paid in shares not in multi million cash deals, it stops them walking away.

Oh and the biggest thing is that most of the bonuses are already taxed at 40% anyway, so making them take it in shares to protect their money reduces the normal tax money grab.
Thank you. That goes some way to answering my question.
Not really. If someone receives shares as a bonus that will still trigger a 40% tax liability on their value. Share options might not but I don't think that is the norm with bank bonuses.

I am firmly on the side of reducing tax all round, in line with major cuts in public spending. Increasing taxes for anyone is not gong to help anyone. But one can see how the massive bonuses to bankers for very little perceived benefit to anyone but themselves has caused resentment.
How do you mean little perceived benefit to anyone else?

Do Taxes and spending not count?

They are a private company after all so why should anyone else benefit? I dont benefit that Apple released the IPhone 5, maybe we should tax them so that I do as its not fair I dont benefit.

Edited by Du1point8 on Tuesday 2nd October 10:33

Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Thing is, by his own admission, a tax on bankers' bonuses (which I don't think is a bad idea TBH given that the annual process of bonus buyouts all-but guarantees them, making them a de facto part of a banker's annual salary) would only raise £4bn.

Which isn't much to fund just about every single policy they've announced in the last few years, as they claim it will.