When people die in old films,
Discussion
funkyrobot said:
why do they always leak blood from their mouth?
Because the blood capsules are cheaper than make-up, and nobody cares if the meat puppet has a nasty taste for a bit?Negative Creep said:
and if they get shot in the head, why is it always dead centre right between the eyes? (this applies to modern films as well)
Probably because the art director is uttering something about visual impact, and things. Interestingly (well, a little) I was watching Broken Arrow last night, and when the park lady killed the weapons chap with a hammer, it was off-centre, and looked a little odd.I've noticed something else about old film deaths. As far back as the original 1933 King Kong, there's been the throat- clutching death. When K.K had been shot to bits by the biplanes, he grabbed his throat, wavered a bit then fell off the Empire State building. It happened just after this...

Spin on 30 years, to 'Jason and the Argonauts'. In this, Talos - a giant bronze warrior statue - comes to life after Hercules nicks some of the gods' treasure. First standing on two promontories of land (Colossus of Rhodes?), Talos is killed by Jason's undoing a bronze stopper and letting molten metal out of his (Talos's) heel (Achilles?). Before he cracks up (literally), Talos goes through the throat-clutching routine. Not long after this...

A number of other movies contain that choking thing as an indicator of impending doom. However, I suppose it's reasonable for Ray Harryhausen to have based Talos on King Kong!
Spin on 30 years, to 'Jason and the Argonauts'. In this, Talos - a giant bronze warrior statue - comes to life after Hercules nicks some of the gods' treasure. First standing on two promontories of land (Colossus of Rhodes?), Talos is killed by Jason's undoing a bronze stopper and letting molten metal out of his (Talos's) heel (Achilles?). Before he cracks up (literally), Talos goes through the throat-clutching routine. Not long after this...
A number of other movies contain that choking thing as an indicator of impending doom. However, I suppose it's reasonable for Ray Harryhausen to have based Talos on King Kong!
Because they can't breathe.
More to the point, why don't they just die? They always have to hang of for their big scene so they can witter on about something to do with the plot or maybe get a message to someone or just get to the important revelation before they die. Most deaths would be fairly inmstantaneous and, even if not, they would be out of it with the pain.
Give me the Indiana Jones gun scene where he shoots the guy dead, instantly.
I always laugh at the "knock-out punch" fights too - the baddies get conveniently knocked out so the hero can fight someone else and then they come round at a convenient point when the hero is able to fight them again. Nobody ever gets a broken or fractured jaw either - amazing.
More to the point, why don't they just die? They always have to hang of for their big scene so they can witter on about something to do with the plot or maybe get a message to someone or just get to the important revelation before they die. Most deaths would be fairly inmstantaneous and, even if not, they would be out of it with the pain.
Give me the Indiana Jones gun scene where he shoots the guy dead, instantly.
I always laugh at the "knock-out punch" fights too - the baddies get conveniently knocked out so the hero can fight someone else and then they come round at a convenient point when the hero is able to fight them again. Nobody ever gets a broken or fractured jaw either - amazing.
LuS1fer said:
Because they can't breathe.
More to the point, why don't they just die? They always have to hang of for their big scene so they can witter on about something to do with the plot or maybe get a message to someone or just get to the important revelation before they die. Most deaths would be fairly inmstantaneous and, even if not, they would be out of it with the pain.
Give me the Indiana Jones gun scene where he shoots the guy dead, instantly.
I always laugh at the "knock-out punch" fights too - the baddies get conveniently knocked out so the hero can fight someone else and then they come round at a convenient point when the hero is able to fight them again. Nobody ever gets a broken or fractured jaw either - amazing.
What gets me is when the two fighters have received two dozen knockout punches or kicks each, but they're both still standing. See Rocky films as an example.More to the point, why don't they just die? They always have to hang of for their big scene so they can witter on about something to do with the plot or maybe get a message to someone or just get to the important revelation before they die. Most deaths would be fairly inmstantaneous and, even if not, they would be out of it with the pain.
Give me the Indiana Jones gun scene where he shoots the guy dead, instantly.
I always laugh at the "knock-out punch" fights too - the baddies get conveniently knocked out so the hero can fight someone else and then they come round at a convenient point when the hero is able to fight them again. Nobody ever gets a broken or fractured jaw either - amazing.
People in general die far too quickly and cleanly in films. Gunshot or stabwound to the torso usually results in a quiet closing of the eyes and a whispered last breath, which couldn't be further from the truth really. Saving Private Ryan shows a fairly realistic death from haemorrage due to a bullet in the chest.
Death, in many forms, is nowhere near as quick or smooth as depicted in cinema, I suppose because the reality is too brutal for the censors or cinemagoers to handle.
Death, in many forms, is nowhere near as quick or smooth as depicted in cinema, I suppose because the reality is too brutal for the censors or cinemagoers to handle.
Mastodon2 said:
People in general die far too quickly and cleanly in films. Gunshot or stabwound to the torso usually results in a quiet closing of the eyes and a whispered last breath, which couldn't be further from the truth really. Saving Private Ryan shows a fairly realistic death from haemorrage due to a bullet in the chest.
Death, in many forms, is nowhere near as quick or smooth as depicted in cinema, I suppose because the reality is too brutal for the censors or cinemagoers to handle.
A good illustration of old way against modern (ish) way there would be virtually every western ever made (where "1 shot and they're dead" rules ok) vs Clint's Unforgiven (where people get shot and die rather painfully and not straight away). Death, in many forms, is nowhere near as quick or smooth as depicted in cinema, I suppose because the reality is too brutal for the censors or cinemagoers to handle.
Whether it matters or not, I don't know. Never really found painful/gory/long suffering deaths on film very entertaining and they get in the way of the story for me.
juan king said:
I was just about to post this. Gassing Station | TV, Film, Streaming & Radio | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





