Ed Balls refuses to apologise for Labour economic record
Ed Balls refuses to apologise for Labour economic record
Author
Discussion

FiF

Original Poster:

49,060 posts

282 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all

Digga

48,650 posts

314 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
All this is very encouraging because, even the BBC take the (un-assailable) view that it was Labour who were at the controls before, during and after the crash. Furthermore, Brown's record is equally dire, so Balls sticking to this line shouuld at least put a final hole beneath the water-line of Labour's economic credentials, such as they are.

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
How dare you, Gordon Brown saved the world!

Du1point8

22,987 posts

223 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
I like the way that he's saying we should build 100,000 more houses, as that will instantly boost the housing market instead of investing the money into business... cause they are not desperate for loans are they?

also this quote:

‘We were a borrow-to-invest and balance the current budget party.'

I dont remember any of that when they were in charge, because correct me if Im wrong, if you budget is balanced, you can spend your way out of recession, but who was sorting out those balanced budgets last time, that might not have balanced at all?


0a

24,161 posts

225 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
I love their use of the term 'windfall' to cover up for massive new spending commitments. I wonder how many times this 4G windfall will be spent - the banker bonus tax was due to be spent 7 or 8 times. It's not like the 4G windfall is something the Tories wouldn't have in any case, but it should go into the massive debt pot.

Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
He got grilled by Humphrys on Radio 4 this morning. A classic 'but you're not answering the question, are you?'-type interview. Balls employed a filibuster, just waffling on until he knew time was up.

He really is an odious little st. His claim now is that Labour were actually in the process of paying off the deficit when a financial crash they had absolutely nothing to do with went and ruined everything, and therefore was not their fault at all.

Flip Martian

23,851 posts

221 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
After the balls up they made of the economy, they have absolutely no right to pontificate about the economy now. Especially when they try to rewrite history. Odious wkers (and I used to support Labour).

Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Flip Martian said:
After the balls up they made of the economy, they have absolutely no right to pontificate about the economy now. Especially when they try to rewrite history. Odious wkers (and I used to support Labour).
Thing is, I recognise the importance of balance in the political system, and support the intellectual, Fabian side of the Labour party in the same way I appreciate the One Nation wing of the Tory party and the Mill/On Liberty element of the Liberal Democrats. Fuse all those viewpoints together and you end up with a system that reasonably represents all views and might produce governance that works.

Unfortunately, what we've got is a bunch of polarised idealogues running every party. Labour is run by a bunch of tax-and-spend zealots who get borderline violent if you dare to question their judgement, and you suspect secretly hanker after a Nineteen Eighty-Four/V For Vendetta-type state in which all 'variables' are controlled 'for our own good'. The Tories, on the other hand, just come across as a socially-detatched party of privilege, running the country in a way that ensures the interests of George Osbourne's multibillionaire-inheritor mates aren't troubled too much, and their knowledge of life outside that circle is so distant and theoretical that it shows time and again ('plebgate' being its latest surfacing but it seems to occur nearly every other week in some form or other).

I don't mind Labour when it's run by people of genuine principle. Unfortunately the last time this happened was when John Smith was in charge. I suspect had he not died, the country would be in a far better state than it ended up in. I don't think for one minute he would have been so chummy with the Chimp and sent the army off to die in the desert quite so readily for starters, nor would he have let private borrowing (or the banks lending it) get quite so out of hand either.

loafer123

16,769 posts

246 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
0a said:
I love their use of the term 'windfall' to cover up for massive new spending commitments. I wonder how many times this 4G windfall will be spent - the banker bonus tax was due to be spent 7 or 8 times. It's not like the 4G windfall is something the Tories wouldn't have in any case, but it should go into the massive debt pot.
If you're heavily in debt, and spending more than you earn, and an elderly auntie dies and leaves you £1000, do you spend it on chocolate?

You do if your name is Ed Balls... the .

ralphrj

4,135 posts

222 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
also this quote:

‘We were a borrow-to-invest and balance the current budget party.'
This is a bare-faced lie.

Labour ran the maximum deficit allowed under EU rules (3% of GDP). A consequence of this structural deficit was that they were "forced" to use PFI on capital projects. Had they not deliberately chosen to run such a large structural deficit for such an extended period of time (9 years) then when the recession hit we would have been far better placed to offset the effect with a Keynesian injection of spending on capital projects.

Hackney

7,444 posts

239 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Good on him.

I'm sick to death of people apologising.

mattviatura

2,996 posts

231 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Twincam16 said:
Stuff
I agree with much of your post there, the country seems to work with a decent Conservative Government and a strong Labour opposition.

We've now got wkers in power and wkers in waiting.



Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Hackney said:
Good on him.

I'm sick to death of people apologising.
I'd agree with you if it was someone else's fault (ie Cameron for Hillsborough or who ever did it for the slaves), but Balls was an integral part of Labour's economics team.

Asterix

24,438 posts

259 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
I like the way that he's saying we should build 100,000 more houses, as that will instantly boost the housing market instead of investing the money into business... cause they are not desperate for loans are they?

also this quote:

‘We were a borrow-to-invest and balance the current budget party.'

I dont remember any of that when they were in charge, because correct me if Im wrong, if you budget is balanced, you can spend your way out of recession, but who was sorting out those balanced budgets last time, that might not have balanced at all?
This is the political party that is virtually bankrupt as it can't keep it's own finances in check.

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Telegraph said:
The shadow Chancellor joins Ed Miliband in evoking the spirit of post-Second World War Britain. He says similar "tough and unpopular decisions" were needed back then to help repair a country ravaged by war.
So he's liking the effects of 13 years under Labour to the 2nd World War? My god, that's some admission!

Murph7355

42,098 posts

287 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
FiF said:
The problem with him latching onto the banker bashing bandwagon? Most of the voting public won't see it for the lie it is.

They aren't interested in the figures on our deficit prior to 2008, nor interested in the reality of how much money has actually been lost since then, or what is at risk.

Repeated often enough these mantras will become true in the queues of every benefit office (and Coogan's mansions) across the country.

Part of me holds with the view that they should be put back in power and let them burn the country in the hope we start again stronger. But I can't help thinking the country would never recover. So many people are dependent on benefits handouts that getting the deficit under control is pretty much an impossible task.

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
And while we're in the post-war spirit, can we hang the traitors please?

Flip Martian

23,851 posts

221 months

Monday 1st October 2012
quotequote all
Twincam16 said:
I don't mind Labour when it's run by people of genuine principle. Unfortunately the last time this happened was when John Smith was in charge. I suspect had he not died, the country would be in a far better state than it ended up in. I don't think for one minute he would have been so chummy with the Chimp and sent the army off to die in the desert quite so readily for starters, nor would he have let private borrowing (or the banks lending it) get quite so out of hand either.
Totally agree. I think John Smith was the last time I was impressed by a politician...

Trax

1,601 posts

263 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Thought I would add here rather than a new thread. But noticed both labour MP's who spoke on radio 4 today and yesterday in the 8.15 ish slot, said things were going to be hard when they/if they win the next election, as they are going to inherit a right economic mess, and increasing massive debt, caused by the coalition. This is after balls up yesterday saying the economy issue was all due to the banks/world economy....

No one pulled either up on this, or even mentioned who is responsible for the mess the country is in, which will take a generation of adult thinking to sort out.

Twincam16

27,647 posts

289 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2012
quotequote all
Trax said:
Thought I would add here rather than a new thread. But noticed both labour MP's who spoke on radio 4 today and yesterday in the 8.15 ish slot, said things were going to be hard when they/if they win the next election, as they are going to inherit a right economic mess, and increasing massive debt, caused by the coalition. This is after balls up yesterday saying the economy issue was all due to the banks/world economy....

No one pulled either up on this, or even mentioned who is responsible for the mess the country is in, which will take a generation of adult thinking to sort out.
True - thing is, I actually think there's a lot of merit in Milipede's plan for a Technical Baccalaureate.

Which makes me wonder why on earth they didn't implement it during the 13 years they were in power, instead of swinging a wrecking ball repeatedly into the education system, which is what they did.

In retrospect I thank my lucky stars that I went to school under Major. I reckon I'd have emerged much less intelligent and more directionless had I been educated under Blair and Brown.