Liquid air 'offers energy storage hope'....
Discussion
Some science bods are going to be needed for this one to explain.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-1978...
using power when not needed to chill air then heat up when needed somehow is worth while and efficient.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-1978...
using power when not needed to chill air then heat up when needed somehow is worth while and efficient.
Isn't this just the same as the pumped hydro schemes - use energy when available to create a potential (in pumped hydro, that potential energy is height, in this it's decompression causing a flow of gas). Physical methods of storing energy seem to be more efficient that using batteries. All of these schemes are there to smooth out the peaks and troughs of demand and supply.
Du1point8 said:
It says its 70% efficient, however thats only if the waste heat from industry can be used, so suggests its not as good as it seems.
If this is the same as the piece on R4 this morning then it's nto about waste heat, it's about using surplus electricity. Wind farms generate electricity whenever the wind blows, but if this happens when there is little demand for it (in the middle of the night, for instance), this electricity needs to be stored as some other form of energy. Turning air into liquid air is a way of doing this; it uses electricity to do this, and you can then turn the liquid air back into gaseous air and generate electricity in the process. The liquid air therefore is a store of energy. The 70% efficiency means that for every 100watt-hours of electricity you feed into the system you get 70watt-hours out, so you waste 30watt-hours in the process.
Think of it as being like a battery, but more efficient and cheaper.
Oli.
ETA: Just read the piece on the BBC site, and it said:
piece said:
IMechE says this process is only 25% efficient but it is massively improved by co-siting the cryo-generator next to an industrial plant or power station producing low-grade heat that is currently vented and being released into the atmosphere.
So it looks like it does use low grade heat output of some other plant, which I didn't realise and which I don't understand - apologies. Perhaps the low-grade heat is used to warm up the liquid air to cause it to evaporate and run the turbines? Edited by zcacogp on Tuesday 2nd October 10:46
zcacogp said:
So it looks like it does use low grade heat output of some other plant, which I didn't realise and which I don't understand - apologies. Perhaps the low-grade heat is used to warm up the liquid air to cause it to evaporate and run the turbines?
I think the analogy would be like using surplus electricity to power a fridge. The waste heat from the heat exchanger (at the back of the fridge) is the low-grade heat source. The refrigerator alone is not very efficient but it is relatively simple to maintain and build.aclivity said:
Isn't this just the same as the pumped hydro schemes - use energy when available to create a potential (in pumped hydro, that potential energy is height, in this it's decompression causing a flow of gas). Physical methods of storing energy seem to be more efficient that using batteries. All of these schemes are there to smooth out the peaks and troughs of demand and supply.
Which makes you wonder what advantage it has over a pumped water system (if any). thinfourth2 said:
I wander how much energy you get store in really really big flywheels as in a couple of hundred tons of concrete spinning not very quickly
I do recall reading about a scheme to store energy in very large superconducting flywheels, spinning very fast in a vacuum, suspended on magnets. The drag was just about zero as a consequence of them being in a low-pressure environment, and the magnets required no energy to function. Apparently the rate of energy decay per year was miniscule (much less than 1%, from memory) although I don't know what the system efficiencies were when you considered putting the energy in to store and taking it out to release. Oli.
sugerbear said:
aclivity said:
Isn't this just the same as the pumped hydro schemes - use energy when available to create a potential (in pumped hydro, that potential energy is height, in this it's decompression causing a flow of gas). Physical methods of storing energy seem to be more efficient that using batteries. All of these schemes are there to smooth out the peaks and troughs of demand and supply.
Which makes you wonder what advantage it has over a pumped water system (if any). zcacogp said:
thinfourth2 said:
I wander how much energy you get store in really really big flywheels as in a couple of hundred tons of concrete spinning not very quickly
I do recall reading about a scheme to store energy in very large superconducting flywheels, spinning very fast in a vacuum, suspended on magnets. The drag was just about zero as a consequence of them being in a low-pressure environment, and the magnets required no energy to function. Apparently the rate of energy decay per year was miniscule (much less than 1%, from memory) although I don't know what the system efficiencies were when you considered putting the energy in to store and taking it out to release. Oli.
My understanding was that everything was fine until someone asked what would happen if the flywheel broke free...
clockworks said:
Just saw this guy on BBC News. He's spent 40 years figuring out that you don't need steam to power a steam engine!
I've heard of that massive flywheel thing before, many years ago. Was it in a sci-fi book, or was it a genuine idea backed by research and experimentation?
There's a genuine application of it in the West Midlands - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parry_People_Movers - a train powered by a 2 litre engine & a big flywheel!I've heard of that massive flywheel thing before, many years ago. Was it in a sci-fi book, or was it a genuine idea backed by research and experimentation?
ewenm said:
sugerbear said:
Which makes you wonder what advantage it has over a pumped water system (if any).
No need for a big hill and a lot of water.I posted this in Science anyway and those egg heads were far less interesting than you lot.
sugerbear said:
Which makes you wonder what advantage it has over a pumped water system (if any).
The main advantage is location location location. Finding a site for hydro is harder than it may seem, you can't just chuck a dam on any old valley. It also comes with a host of NIMBY problems, especially if the proposal is to put your back yard 20 meters under water. Then there's the transmission lines to these often remote schemes which are unsightly, expensive and inefficient.In comparison the liquid air system is best suited to being built next to industrial sites and existing fossil or nuclear power stations, so it can use their waste heat. I imagine this would give considerable savings in terms of infrastructure.
Sway said:
Slightly off topic, but in the good old days of racing there was a Le Mans entrant that had no onboard motor, instead it had a flywheel that was to be spun up to store enough energy to power the car for 24 hours.
My understanding was that everything was fine until someone asked what would happen if the flywheel broke free...
Crumbs! My understanding was that everything was fine until someone asked what would happen if the flywheel broke free...
That would be a LOT of energy in a spinning flywheel! If it wasn't to weigh a ton, it would have to spin at (literally) millions of RPM, surely? The precession effects would be massively detrimental to handling, before you start to think about the armour plating necessary to make it safe ... Mind you, aren't Porsche considering a flywheel arrangement for regenerative braking in some of their motorsport applications? Clearly much smaller and lighter and storing much less energy, but the principle is the same.
Oli.
ewenm said:
sugerbear said:
Which makes you wonder what advantage it has over a pumped water system (if any).
No need for a big hill and a lot of water.zcacogp said:
Mind you, aren't Porsche considering a flywheel arrangement for regenerative braking in some of their motorsport applications?
997gt3r hybrid. been competing for 2 years with decent results. 480bhp n/a + 163bhp flywheel/electric. theres also the audi r18 etron lmp1!as for running lemans with only a flywheel;
500bhp=370kW
370kW=8880kWh/race
to put that in perspective the porsche/williams gt3r carbon composite flywheel stores 0.2kWh and weighs 103lb!
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


