Mau Mau - torture allegations to be litigated.
Discussion
I worked - until 2007 - with a Kenyan. Colonial - born there. His recollection of that period is vivid, and not a little terrifying. Undoubtedly unpleasant things happened, but it's only the UK gov't that remains as an entity that can be sued. There is little or no redress for (the many) slaughtered in front of their families, or partially dismemebered 'pour encourager les autres' in tribal villages all over country.
That this court action is happening will make a lot of hand wringers happier, but it has little to do with bringing justice to the Kenyan people as a whole. But that's politics...
That this court action is happening will make a lot of hand wringers happier, but it has little to do with bringing justice to the Kenyan people as a whole. But that's politics...
Breadvan72 said:
The Empire had its good points, but Kenya was where all the dregs of the Empire went to profiteer and run riot. Amazingly, Niall Ferguson's history of the Empire manages to avoid mentioning Kenya, save for one mention of his happy Colonial childhood there.
Never knew that was where he grew up.I suppose, given the infamy of the Happy Valley set (it still has a bit of that about it round there today IMHO) perhaps he thought it hardly needed re-visiting.
The Don of Croy said:
So was Khadaffi, McGuiness, Gerry Adams and that former Red Brigade bloke sitting in the German parliament.
So what?
Are the Free Syrian Army terrorists or freedom fighters, ditto for the guys in Libya who we also supported. What are we complicit in today that will bite us in the butt later?So what?
Mermaid said:
Are the Free Syrian Army terrorists or freedom fighters, ditto for the guys in Libya who we also supported. What are we complicit in today that will bite us in the butt later?
We're straying...you're already into the Syrian thing elsethread!Kenya was a mess - a created country. Tribal peoples brought together as a nation after x thousand years roaming and scratching an existence. Tribes that had a history of conflict.
Not a pretty sight, but then again, not unfamiliar. See recent post election bloodbath (2009?). Could easily slip into a Rwanda type monstrosity during those developmental times.
What I get from talking to my Kenyan friend, is the picture of Africa as it could be (should be?). An incredible opportunity. Good climate, natural resources, abundance of nature etc etc. If only...
The Don of Croy said:
..What I get from talking to my Kenyan friend, is the picture of Africa as it could be (should be?). An incredible opportunity. Good climate, natural resources, abundance of nature etc etc. If only...
Agree with all that - if only the West had been allowed to harness the resources? Uganda/Tanzania it seems did not suffer the torture allegations, so I wonder what the difference was.Mermaid said:
The Don of Croy said:
..What I get from talking to my Kenyan friend, is the picture of Africa as it could be (should be?). An incredible opportunity. Good climate, natural resources, abundance of nature etc etc. If only...
Agree with all that - if only the West had been allowed to harness the resources? Uganda/Tanzania it seems did not suffer the torture allegations, so I wonder what the difference was.Doing a lot better now thankfully.
The biggest problem, IMHO, is 'western arrogance' in that we think they would be happier living like us, and they like what they see in the shops etc., but it is a culture shock compared to x thousand years of tribal living. It looks less and less like they - or anyone - has a choice.
The Don of Croy said:
Kenya was a mess - a created country. Tribal peoples brought together as a nation after x thousand years roaming and scratching an existence. Tribes that had a history of conflict.
Not a pretty sight, but then again, not unfamiliar. See recent post election bloodbath (2009?). Could easily slip into a Rwanda type monstrosity during those developmental times.
What I get from talking to my Kenyan friend, is the picture of Africa as it could be (should be?). An incredible opportunity. Good climate, natural resources, abundance of nature etc etc. If only...
I was there in the aftermath of the riots in early 2008, though thankfully not in the same hotel as Kofi Anan and the media circus and I was extremely impressed by the majority view on the riots; that they were politically motivated, perpetrated by poor, impressionable young men, and that Kenya (emphatically) did not have a tribal problem. This was a view echoed all over the country. they even felt those who'd incited the riots for political gain (a la S.A. miners today) never intended to create such a frenzy.Not a pretty sight, but then again, not unfamiliar. See recent post election bloodbath (2009?). Could easily slip into a Rwanda type monstrosity during those developmental times.
What I get from talking to my Kenyan friend, is the picture of Africa as it could be (should be?). An incredible opportunity. Good climate, natural resources, abundance of nature etc etc. If only...
The Don of Croy said:
..The biggest problem, IMHO, is 'western arrogance' in that we think they would be happier living like us, and they like what they see in the shops etc., but it is a culture shock compared to x thousand years of tribal living. It looks less and less like they - or anyone - has a choice.
As Cameron said, in relation to China:'We are different countries, we have different histories, different stages of development.
The Don of Croy said:
The biggest problem, IMHO, is 'western arrogance' in that we think they would be happier living like us, and they like what they see in the shops etc., but it is a culture shock compared to x thousand years of tribal living. It looks less and less like they - or anyone - has a choice.
A lot of the Massai I met had a mobile 'phone and were chuffed to bits with them too. Solar-powered masts being cheap and easy to maintain has revolutionised comms in the bush.Not sure if it's handy or not when you have wives in several villages though!
The Foreign Office had a plan, circa 1900, to transform the Empire, by about 2000, into a free Commonwealth. The events of the Twentieth Century, and unintended consequences of educating local elites in the Colonies, scuppered this plan. Boris Johnson courted controversy, but had a point, when he said that Ghana did not suffer from too much Imperialism, but too little. By this he meant that another 20 to 50 years of Colonial rule might have better equipped the country for modernity.
Differential rates of development are, of course, nothing to do with innate characteristics of peoples. "Guns, Germs, and Steel" explains this well.
None of this is to disguise the shameful aspects of the Scramble for Africa, in which most of the European powers participated, with much bloodshed and unfairness in consequence.
Differential rates of development are, of course, nothing to do with innate characteristics of peoples. "Guns, Germs, and Steel" explains this well.
None of this is to disguise the shameful aspects of the Scramble for Africa, in which most of the European powers participated, with much bloodshed and unfairness in consequence.
Breadvan72 said:
The events of the Twentieth Century, and unintended consequences of educating local elites in the Colonies, scuppered this plan. Boris Johnson courted controversy, but had a point, when he said that Ghana did not suffer from too much Imperialism, but too little. By this he meant that another 20 to 50 years of Colonial rule might have better equipped the country for modernity.
Indeed. And had the EICo. not bugged out of the North Western Frontier Province, the Pakistan and Afghanistan 'problem' may have been sorted far more peacefully and partition might never have happened.Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


