E46 325i MOT fail..........
E46 325i MOT fail..........
Author
Discussion

Rob175kks

Original Poster:

169 posts

183 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
Just had the first MOT done during my ownership of the car, it failed! Front suspension linkage (which is no big deal) and a weak/loose handbrake/rear brakes. The chap said he would strip the rear brakes to see if he could clean them up but he reckons worst case to rebuild with new parts would be around £300! Does that sound right?

It may be ok, I'm just paranoid about being ripped off by a mechanic.

Cheers,

Rob

g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
Is the £300 only to sort out the handbrake situation?

Rob175kks

Original Poster:

169 posts

183 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
Yes

Salom

230 posts

207 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
£30.00 for a set of handbrake shoes, 1 hour to fit them. £100 max.

steebo888

784 posts

229 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
£300 sounds very steep unless it was for all repair work and mot test

Edited by steebo888 on Monday 8th October 13:48

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
Never have repair work done by the testing station. And that'll want a quick adjustment to bring it up to scratch.

liller

1,151 posts

200 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
Mine failed last week on these items - handbrake and suspension linkage plus some other bits. I ended up spending best part of £500 to get it through.

The hand brake shoes were £30 for the part. The anti-roll bar drop linkage thing is a £20 part. It was the labour and the cost of 2 tests that sent the price right up for me.

It was the same thing for me, they said they would see if they could tighten up the handbrake to see if they could get it through but they couldn't as they said the shoes were completely shot.

Edited by liller on Monday 8th October 18:44

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
To sort a BMW handbrake won't cost £300. A set of shoes will be required, BUT the rear discs caould also be shagged with a nasty wear lip making refitting a bit of a chore. This can be ground off though if the actual disc is okay.
You're looking at about an hour a side to fully slacken both cables at the lever itself, remove the caliper and disc, clean up the backplate, clean and lubricate the handbrake quadrant, reassemble with new shoes and retaining pins/springs, adjust up etc. Acouple of hours should see both done.

Do not just adjust the cables at the lever.

motco

17,670 posts

277 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
How do the shoes become worn when they only should make contact with a static drum?

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
motco said:
How do the shoes become worn when they only should make contact with a static drum?
They don't usually wear down as such they usually crumble and crack and the linings came off.
It's not a 300 job, I done mine on the e39 e36 and z4, takes no more than two hours and the shoes are about £20 ish.

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
iSore said:
To sort a BMW handbrake won't cost £300. A set of shoes will be required, BUT the rear discs caould also be shagged with a nasty wear lip making refitting a bit of a chore. This can be ground off though if the actual disc is okay.
You're looking at about an hour a side to fully slacken both cables at the lever itself, remove the caliper and disc, clean up the backplate, clean and lubricate the handbrake quadrant, reassemble with new shoes and retaining pins/springs, adjust up etc. Acouple of hours should see both done.

Do not just adjust the cables at the lever.
confused BMW handbrake shoes work on the inner hub. The cable is adjustable at the lever, how else would you take up the slack in it? Why would they put adjusters there if that was not what they were for?

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
roofer said:
confused BMW handbrake shoes work on the inner hub. The cable is adjustable at the lever, how else would you take up the slack in it? Why would they put adjusters there if that was not what they were for?
There are 2 adjusters, take up the slack on the shoes inside the drum, then adjust the cables to suit.

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Monday 8th October 2012
quotequote all
steve_bmw said:
roofer said:
confused BMW handbrake shoes work on the inner hub. The cable is adjustable at the lever, how else would you take up the slack in it? Why would they put adjusters there if that was not what they were for?
There are 2 adjusters, take up the slack on the shoes inside the drum, then adjust the cables to suit.
I know, i've done more than a few, however, reading the post i quoted, it sounds total bks ?

motco

17,670 posts

277 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
steve_bmw said:
motco said:
How do the shoes become worn when they only should make contact with a static drum?
They don't usually wear down as such they usually crumble and crack and the linings came off.
It's not a 300 job, I done mine on the e39 e36 and z4, takes no more than two hours and the shoes are about £20 ish.
Thanks for that Steve. I have had my low mileage 52 plate Z3 for three years but never had need to look at the handbrake shoes as it has always been good enough for the MoT. If it's not too much of a chore I may do it. My son has a 320 (E46) which has a rubbish handbrake too - two for the price of one...

Rob175kks

Original Poster:

169 posts

183 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for your help and input guys. I called up a mate of mine who is handy with a spanner and he was outraged by their quote, he said he'd change disks, pads and handbrake shoes on the rear for 150 or 200 if i wanted genuine bmw parts. Anyway i have since called the garage and said I can't afford the 400 quid they have quoted. I will take the car off them and get my mate on it.
This is my local bmw specialist, not just an mot test centre. I was getting my mot here to test them as a garage. They have failed!

BorkFactor

7,278 posts

189 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
That seems very steep, the garage I took my E46 328i to just tightened the handbrake and didn't even mention it! No bill or anything!

Sounds like they are taking you for a ride.

liller

1,151 posts

200 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
Rob175kks said:
Thanks for your help and input guys. I called up a mate of mine who is handy with a spanner and he was outraged by their quote, he said he'd change disks, pads and handbrake shoes on the rear for 150 or 200 if i wanted genuine bmw parts. Anyway i have since called the garage and said I can't afford the 400 quid they have quoted. I will take the car off them and get my mate on it.
This is my local bmw specialist, not just an mot test centre. I was getting my mot here to test them as a garage. They have failed!
This I don't get. I priced up a full set of discs, pads, handbrake shoes and sensors and the parts alone came to more than £200. How your mate can do it for £150 I don't know. I will assume he will pick up the cheapest unbranded parts possible and not charge you anything for labour. Bear in mind that most indies will charge around £70 per hour labour so it soon adds up.

Rob175kks

Original Poster:

169 posts

183 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
This I don't get. I priced up a full set of discs, pads, handbrake shoes and sensors and the parts alone came to more than £200. How your mate can do it for £150 I don't know. I will assume he will pick up the cheapest unbranded parts possible and not charge you anything for labour. Bear in mind that most indies will charge around £70 per hour labour so it soon adds up.

[/quote]

It could be that my mate just meant new disks and handbrake shoes, in any case he said £100 for parts and £50 for his labour. The part would also be VAT free for him.
The main thing for me it that I wholly trust him and I know his work is good.

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
The price depends on who you know, I got 4 discs both sets of pads and handbrake shoes for £120 ish for a z4, and similar price for my e36
All quality stuff.
If your motor spares can't supply you these bits for less than 200 just for the rear then your going to the wrong motor spares or they don't like you 😬

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Tuesday 9th October 2012
quotequote all
roofer said:
confused BMW handbrake shoes work on the inner hub. The cable is adjustable at the lever, how else would you take up the slack in it? Why would they put adjusters there if that was not what they were for?
Quite simple when you know how.......not 'total bks' at all Dear.

Over time, the shoes wear down. The correct way of adjustment is to remove the disc, clean it all out, refit the disc and use the serrated adjuster accessed via a wheel bolt hole with a long flat bladed screwdriver. If you fit new discs and shoes, you can get the adjustment 95% right with the disc off, doing the fine adjustment with the disc fitted.
The adjuster nuts on the cable at the lever end are not there to adjust the handbrake - they are there to set the cable position/tension at the lever end. That doesn't stop bodgers from doing this though - that's why the first job I do when doing this job is to wind the nuts right back out and reset them once the handbrake shoes are correctly adjusted within the drum.

Edited by iSore on Tuesday 9th October 11:58