The town that never retired
Discussion
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01kv8wv/The_...
Did anyone see this last night?
Scarey that so many of the young people given a chance of work proved to be so feckless.
How on earth do we as a nation fix kids like that?
Did anyone see this last night?
Scarey that so many of the young people given a chance of work proved to be so feckless.
How on earth do we as a nation fix kids like that?
Eric Mc said:
Editorial agenda at work?
I am extremely suspicious of such programmes - essentially setting out to reinforce stereotypes.
Hmmm - News or TV?
I did wrangle with the news/tv question. In the end I decided news not simply because of the program, but because of my own experience of the subject matter which sadly echoed some of the points covered in the program.I am extremely suspicious of such programmes - essentially setting out to reinforce stereotypes.
Hmmm - News or TV?
This starts at home. Discipline them to be of the mindset that they might be out on their ear when they turn 16 or 18 and make sure they know that there reaches a point where they will have to fend for themselves. I was taught this as a kid, I got reasonable gifts from my parents but was told that once into my mid teens if i wanted more i should work to buy things myself. So I have been in employment since the age of 14. I am by no means a mega success but there is fear within me of the prospect of not being in work or not working to my full potential.
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I'm not sure when it starts. A friend of mine has always worked (until recently), and although his wife has claimed benefits (not sure what), there is no reason for his kids to not work.Instead, one is 22-23 now and he has NEVER done a days work. That's not a joke. But he's signed off because he's listed as a carer for some old uncle (that he does f-all for), and the guys daughter was just a piece of work, left home at 15, got married at 17 (they were glad to see the back of her), married some t
t who again has been signed off for life, had 2 children by 19 - and I believe she's now just turned 20 and the kids are in care after the local social workers gave up trying to work with her (and after one of the children was injured by the halfwit father.)Just to boil your piss, she's never worked in her life, and after the first child, at the grand old age of 18, she was given a brand new flat!
What is annoying is that there isn't a lack of jobs - they live next door to one of Amazon's distribution centres who are always looking for trained chimps!
JDRoest said:
I'm not sure when it starts. A friend of mine has always worked (until recently), and although his wife has claimed benefits (not sure what), there is no reason for his kids to not work.
Instead, one is 22-23 now and he has NEVER done a days work. That's not a joke. But he's signed off because he's listed as a carer for some old uncle (that he does f-all for), and the guys daughter was just a piece of work, left home at 15, got married at 17 (they were glad to see the back of her), married some t
t who again has been signed off for life, had 2 children by 19 - and I believe she's now just turned 20 and the kids are in care after the local social workers gave up trying to work with her (and after one of the children was injured by the halfwit father.)
Just to boil your piss, she's never worked in her life, and after the first child, at the grand old age of 18, she was given a brand new flat!
What is annoying is that there isn't a lack of jobs - they live next door to one of Amazon's distribution centres who are always looking for trained chimps!
I don't know them but one would assume the message wasn't loud or clear enough?Instead, one is 22-23 now and he has NEVER done a days work. That's not a joke. But he's signed off because he's listed as a carer for some old uncle (that he does f-all for), and the guys daughter was just a piece of work, left home at 15, got married at 17 (they were glad to see the back of her), married some t
t who again has been signed off for life, had 2 children by 19 - and I believe she's now just turned 20 and the kids are in care after the local social workers gave up trying to work with her (and after one of the children was injured by the halfwit father.)Just to boil your piss, she's never worked in her life, and after the first child, at the grand old age of 18, she was given a brand new flat!
What is annoying is that there isn't a lack of jobs - they live next door to one of Amazon's distribution centres who are always looking for trained chimps!
Perhaps they are caring parents who loved their kids as they grew up but guidance and discipline may have been lacking.
I know a bloke who's grown up to be a complete turf but looking at his parents there was definitely no shortage of love there. They wouldn't have a bad word said against their lad and that was probably the problem. They too were hardworking, he is a bum. Don't mean to judge and it's bad to hear about the grandkids.
anonymous said:
[redacted]
This is true but in Europe, poverty means promising footballers have the right to steal/do nothing and expect the state to provide whereas in Africa, poverty means you die of starvation. Most people in 1st world countries do not know what hardship really is. It only exists on television.
kuzushi said:
Who do you blame? Why should they work when they don't have to? They didn't create the system like this.
This is the thing that gets me, they aren't earning a fortune on benefits in the first place (well, at least not the son). He has managed to make do with JSA and some form of housing benefit for a bedsit, and he seems happy with that! His parents have no idea what to do about him either - he just will not get a job.(Idle hands though, has been caught stealing money from his parents and grandparents house, smashed up an association house, etc).
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I have no idea why his children are such failures. Because that's what they are.I do judge, and I hate to say it - the grandkids will get a better bringing up for being taken into care and adopted out. I feel sorry for my friend and his wife (the grandparents) as they don't deserve to be treated this way, but the safety and upbringing of the grandchildren is paramount. Frankly, the only thing we couldn't work out was why it took social services only 2.5 years to take the children off the parents, we all had a book running for 6 months.
I'm just waiting for the call that 'she' is pregnant again.
I've seen an episode of this before and what concerns me more than the BBC selected young people is the thought of people working into their 80s and jobs never opening up. If old people never stop working then we'll be paying for the young to sit on benefits into their 40s or if we kick the old out of work then the young will be paying for elderly care the country cannot afford. That's the bigger picture and what we should be discussing, rather than ranting about the benefits system or some blokes kids.
What a lovely sheltered life you must've had. The truth is people in 1st world countries do not see the hardship which exists in their own countries because they only see it on television.

Don't get me wrong, I love the whole 1950's parenting mentality by which you believe kids must be shoved up chimneys at 14 to appreciate the value of work but seriously, get over yourself. I don't go to work for my self respect - not much of that left anyway. Nor dignity - see self respect comment for full details. I don't go to work because living off of your money would offend me, nor do I feel a moral obligation to give money to George Osborne to pay down a debt I didn't create.
I go to work because I like to buy nice things. What's depressing is there's so many youngsters now who are content to live in a subsidised bedsit and have nothing to live for but the next iPhone purchased via a catalogue. It's the fact they don't want better is what depresses me.
arguti said:
Most people in 1st world countries do not know what hardship really is. It only exists on television.
What a lovely sheltered life you must've had. The truth is people in 1st world countries do not see the hardship which exists in their own countries because they only see it on television.
otolith said:
kuzushi said:
Why should they work when they don't have to?
Dignity, self respect, honour, not being a selfish parasite?
Don't get me wrong, I love the whole 1950's parenting mentality by which you believe kids must be shoved up chimneys at 14 to appreciate the value of work but seriously, get over yourself. I don't go to work for my self respect - not much of that left anyway. Nor dignity - see self respect comment for full details. I don't go to work because living off of your money would offend me, nor do I feel a moral obligation to give money to George Osborne to pay down a debt I didn't create.
I go to work because I like to buy nice things. What's depressing is there's so many youngsters now who are content to live in a subsidised bedsit and have nothing to live for but the next iPhone purchased via a catalogue. It's the fact they don't want better is what depresses me.
martin84 said:
Don't get me wrong, I love the whole 1950's parenting mentality
I had relatively easy-going parents but i would still help around the house and garden. It's not about getting paid £3 an hour to do menial jobs - it's about trying to achieve something. Even as you put it succintly, if it's only to increase the number in your bank account (from work - not benefits).martin84 said:
The truth is people in 1st world countries do not see the hardship which exists in their own countries because they only see it on television.
the so called 'hardship' in the UK from being out of work is nothing compared to the rest of the world.I work in Asia .. if you dont work because you're a lazy f
ker ... you won't eat. [some backup exists for the truly disadvantaged but it isnt a lot ]whereas in the UK - you can play the 'job hunt' 'game' at the DSS to make it look like you're looking for work but arent really.. .. and get housing and other benefits to perpetuity ...
- real* hardship by global standards doesnt exist in the UK [unless deliberately self induced] : free education , free health care , and [often] free or cheap housing
alfaman said:
the so called 'hardship' in the UK from being out of work is nothing compared to the rest of the world.
Good. I'd actually be proud to go abroad and tell people that is the case in my country.alfaman said:
whereas in the UK - you can play the 'job hunt' 'game' at the DSS to make it look like you're looking for work but arent really.. .. and get housing and other benefits to perpetuity ...
The DSS hasn't existed for 20 years. You can get all of those things while not bothering but the mistake PH makes is in believing all or the vast majority do. The odd family with 9 kids on benefits featuring on The Sun's front page is not representative of the population. They're just the only ones you see - or in PH's case bother to notice. But no matter, you carry on.Is the point really about poverty levels or hardship when it appears these kids are so feckless becauce they have it so EASY!
Again I say some kids need a bit of encouragement or a cold hard shock, from their parents, early on before they reach school or college leaving age. We can't assume this is a result of the benefits system solely.
Society and state then have to create or create the conditions for a healthy employment market.
Again I say some kids need a bit of encouragement or a cold hard shock, from their parents, early on before they reach school or college leaving age. We can't assume this is a result of the benefits system solely.
Society and state then have to create or create the conditions for a healthy employment market.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





