What next?

Poll: What next?

Total Members Polled: 114

All well, next boom coming soon: 6%
We'll muddle through somehow: 35%
It'll take a lot of pain: 26%
We're screwed: 32%
Author
Discussion

AJS-

Original Poster:

15,366 posts

267 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
So here we are, UK, 2012 drawing to a close and the numbers are roughly thus

£1.5 Trillion GDP
£900bn debt
£120bn net borrowing requirement
51% of GDP spen t by the state
Predicted -0.4% of GDP GDP growth, I.e a contraction of this economy

What do you reckon? Some magic answer coming soon? Or are we up st creek without a paddle?

Edited by AJS- on Wednesday 10th October 17:44

AJS-

Original Poster:

15,366 posts

267 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
You might also want to factor in that 2.5 years into a government who are widely lambasted for their evil cuts, we are still no where near reducing the deficit, and in fact likely to increase it substantially over the next few years.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
Default on debt then trade barriers.

See, Dambisa Moyo - How the West Was Lost: Fifty Years of Economic Folly – And the Stark Choices that Lie Ahead.

AJS-

Original Poster:

15,366 posts

267 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Default on debt then trade barriers.

See, Dambisa Moyo - How the West Was Lost: Fifty Years of Economic Folly – And the Stark Choices that Lie Ahead.
Is it good?

Mr Sparkle

1,936 posts

201 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
I don't see how the problem or deficit can be resolved, the continued borrowing is making the problem seem much smaller than it really is. Ie. If we are borrowing £120bn/y to fund jobs & projects then isn't this making the economy seem £120bn better off a year than it really should be if the book were balanced? Given how many jobs will be lost when this public spending has to be stopped I think the UK economy is in for an absolute ststorm in 5 or 6 years.

ETA: Are you on holiday or something, whats with all the topics?

Edited by Mr Sparkle on Wednesday 10th October 18:12

rohrl

8,984 posts

176 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
The treasury are looking to levy a tax on online forum polls so we'll be fine.

jurbie

2,444 posts

232 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
we are still no where near reducing the deficit, and in fact likely to increase it substantially over the next few years.
I thought Cameron said today that it has been cut by 25% over the past 2 years?

AJS-

Original Poster:

15,366 posts

267 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
jurbie said:
AJS- said:
we are still no where near reducing the deficit, and in fact likely to increase it substantially over the next few years.
I thought Cameron said today that it has been cut by 25% over the past 2 years?
I didn't hear the speech, let alone analyze it for weasel words, but I suspect that is the rate of growth of government debt that has been cut by 25%. Either way it is still massive.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
Fittster said:
Default on debt then trade barriers.

See, Dambisa Moyo - How the West Was Lost: Fifty Years of Economic Folly – And the Stark Choices that Lie Ahead.
Is it good?
Her views could go down well with the average PH, she a director of Barclays, so most around here wouldn't denouce her as a nutter.

From the Guardian review:

"The rosy scenario that most economists would suggest (if they dared to tackle such a large issue) would be that the convergence of the emerging market economies on the west is mutually beneficial: we can all prosper together. Dambisa Moyo, author of the bestselling Dead Aid, is having none of this. She argues that the west has become mired in complacency: each of the drivers of growth – capital accumulation, skill accumulation, and technical innovation – have stalled, and there is no political will to salvage the situation. The market for capital has failed in its core task of finding investment opportunities that offer good returns at acceptable risk.

Above all, in the west, both households and governments got into debt to finance consumption at levels that will prove unsustainable: in contrast, China, both people and government, has been saving at rates without historical precedent. As to skills, Moyo sees complacency in government in the face of declining schooling standards relative to those in the emerging societies.

Among parents she sees folly as they collude in their children's fantasies of becoming sporting or entertainment celebrities rather than getting down to the hard grind of learning how to be productive: in east Asia children spend many more hours doing schoolwork than they do in the west. In the face of these daunting challenges, she sees public policy in the west hamstrung by an obsession with individual rights and a reluctance to face reality.

The other emerging economies see that this is successful. They have no love for the west, and so will follow China both as a model and as a political leader. Meanwhile, the west, and in particular the US, is stuck with an excessive faith in market mechanisms, combined with a political system that will push it increasingly into the most dysfunctional aspects of social welfare: dependency of the poor on government handouts, financed by public debt.

Her proposed solution for the US is as radical as is her diagnosis: trade protectionism and debt default.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/jan/16/west-l...

AJS-

Original Poster:

15,366 posts

267 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
Sounds like someone with the germ of a good idea and none of the capability to develop it, but I will read the book at some point.

markcoznottz

7,155 posts

255 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
Fittster said:
Her views could go down well with the average PH, she a director of Barclays, so most around here wouldn't denouce her as a nutter.

From the Guardian review:

"The rosy scenario that most economists would suggest (if they dared to tackle such a large issue) would be that the convergence of the emerging market economies on the west is mutually beneficial: we can all prosper together. Dambisa Moyo, author of the bestselling Dead Aid, is having none of this. She argues that the west has become mired in complacency: each of the drivers of growth – capital accumulation, skill accumulation, and technical innovation – have stalled, and there is no political will to salvage the situation. The market for capital has failed in its core task of finding investment opportunities that offer good returns at acceptable risk.

Above all, in the west, both households and governments got into debt to finance consumption at levels that will prove unsustainable: in contrast, China, both people and government, has been saving at rates without historical precedent. As to skills, Moyo sees complacency in government in the face of declining schooling standards relative to those in the emerging societies.

Among parents she sees folly as they collude in their children's fantasies of becoming sporting or entertainment celebrities rather than getting down to the hard grind of learning how to be productive: in east Asia children spend many more hours doing schoolwork than they do in the west. In the face of these daunting challenges, she sees public policy in the west hamstrung by an obsession with individual rights and a reluctance to face reality.

The other emerging economies see that this is successful. They have no love for the west, and so will follow China both as a model and as a political leader. Meanwhile, the west, and in particular the US, is stuck with an excessive faith in market mechanisms, combined with a political system that will push it increasingly into the most dysfunctional aspects of social welfare: dependency of the poor on government handouts, financed by public debt.

Her proposed solution for the US is as radical as is her diagnosis: trade protectionism and debt default.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/jan/16/west-l...
We are already defaulting, what does she think qe and inflation are?. USA , uk, and eu are all causing distortion a in the gilt market by buying there own debt, tbh the east can do fk all about it, like it was alluded to in other posts, the west 'got there first' so calls the shots. Anybody who thinks otherwise can start a war with America if it wants to, but its not advised. What all that actually means is unknown concerning the man on the street, but I wouldn't go anywhere near a private pension that's for sure!.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
We aren't defaulting. 5 Year gilts are at less than 2%, inflation is at more than 2%.

Do the math. Interest is less than the rate of inflation, the loans are getting smaller in real terms. That's why the deficit is being reduced as slowly as it is - we don't need to do it quicker. Jobless numbers are staying mostly static but are showing a drop in public sector workers and an increase in private sector workers.

The economy is rebalancing, just the way the Tories said it would. This is what the plurality wanted. wink

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
Another fking poll, I expect.

turbobloke

117,594 posts

291 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
Justayellowbadge said:
Another fking poll, I expect.
hehe

We can always vote on it.

paperbag

perdu

4,885 posts

230 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
Justayellowbadge said:
Another fking poll, I expect.
hehe

We can always vote on it.

paperbag
That won't be compulsory will it?


(shudders and buggers off stage left, pursued by a bore)

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 10th October 2012
quotequote all
AJS- said:
So here we are, UK, 2012 drawing to a close and the numbers are roughly thus

£1.5 Trillion GDP
£900bn debt
£120bn net borrowing requirement
51% of GDP spen t by the state
Predicted -0.4% of GDP GDP growth, I.e a contraction of this economy

What do you reckon? Some magic answer coming soon? Or are we up st creek without a paddle?

Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 10th October 17:44
We've always had the nuclear option of doing an Ireland. Write to public sector employees (all of them) and say "Thanks for your work - but we can't afford you all, so we're cutting pay by XX% starting tommorrow". Do the same with welfare payments and XX could be as low as 25%. Obviously, that won't be popular, but the deficit would evapourate overnight and we could start paying down the debt.

Instead we're trying to make 'cuts' be increasing spending by about half of the inflation rate. It'll take about 10 more years to achieve without global growth, which we won't get while everyone else is doing the same as we are. Then we'll have 30 years to pay back the debt accured during our deficit binge.

I think growth will pick up some, reducing the deficit to about 7 more years. Provided we then maintain a surplus of receipts over spending, and higher inflation (5% say) we might repay Gordons debts in as little as 20 years.

Things aren't great, but they could be so much worse. Greece is already several years into recession and has lost nigh on half its economy. Hopefully we'll escape the worst of that by debassing our currency and reducing our living standards compared to the rest of the world.

AJS-

Original Poster:

15,366 posts

267 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
10 years is optimistic - against a background of inflation, pensioners, welfare recipients and public sector workers are going to start asking for pay rises soon, and if the Tories or coalition won't give it to them, then nice guy Eddie will. These people are already enough to swing an election, never mind one where the Tories are in and unpopular in the middle of an economic slump. Even without a change of government chipping away at spending for the next 10 years to try and get some traction is not going to be enough. The debt interest alone by then will be crippling us.

Anyway, if there was anything in this government spending led growth idea then we'd be roaring ahead, as the government is currently borrowing 10% of GDP and injecting this into the economy. This is absolutely insane!

markcoznottz

7,155 posts

255 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
davepoth said:
We aren't defaulting. 5 Year gilts are at less than 2%, inflation is at more than 2%.

Do the math. Interest is less than the rate of inflation, the loans are getting smaller in real terms. That's why the deficit is being reduced as slowly as it is - we don't need to do it quicker. Jobless numbers are staying mostly static but are showing a drop in public sector workers and an increase in private sector workers.

The economy is rebalancing, just the way the Tories said it would. This is what the plurality wanted. wink
You don't understand what inflation is then. It is the government increasing its grab, whilst at the same time reducing the size of its financial obligations. Inflation is whatever you want it to be, not many people believe the governments figures. The markets have been kind to us so far, we haven't ever defaulted on any gilt payments, but if we continue to qe, which make no mistake is a default, then eventually the markets will force higher interest repayments onto us, or quite simply leave us out the loop. In fact are we borrowing at all if we are doing qe?. That proves no one wants to keep buying our debt does it not?. Sticking two fingers up at your creditors is a form of default for sure.

Megaflow

11,668 posts

256 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
The problem is the people in charge of fixing the problem, are the people creating the problem. No politician is going to propose the solution to the problem, a massive cut in public spending, starting with the welfare state, because they will never get elected.

They are only interested in keeping themselves in a job, not fixing the long term problem. That will be somebody else's problem after they have retired on the huge public funded pension plan.

If I knew how to fix that, I'd be a very rich man...

ralphrj

4,135 posts

222 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
jurbie said:
AJS- said:
we are still no where near reducing the deficit, and in fact likely to increase it substantially over the next few years.
I thought Cameron said today that it has been cut by 25% over the past 2 years?
Correct.

2009 deficit c.£160bn

2011 deficit c.£120bn - a reduction of 25%.

I'm not sure where the expectation that the deficit will increase comes from unless AJS is confusing deficit and debt.