Speedmaster… Sapphire vs Hesalite…
Speedmaster… Sapphire vs Hesalite…
Author
Discussion

Bacardi

Original Poster:

2,235 posts

307 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
I have an itch to get a Speedmaster Pro 'Moonwatch', have had one for years, but having watched two films back to back with leading characters wearing one has increased my desire, it just goes to prove that product placement works!

But now I find myself confronted by the choice of Sapphire or classic Hesalite. Have done a quick search and it seems that the 'dome' is slightly different? I understand the Hesalite scratches and scuffs more easily, but easy to polish out, so no problem. There seems to be much talk of sapphire shattering compared to plexi and I quite often, in the course of a day, work etc, will knock my watch, but have a large Planet Ocean with sapphire and haven't had any problems. Maybe the design of the Speed is different and more prone to breaking?

Things which may influence my decision are things like contrast, I like the black face to look black as possible, if that has any baring on whether I should go for sapphire or hesalite and any anti reflectance coatings etc. I quite like the transparent back and being able to see the movement, but not as important as the front.

Thanks in advance for any pearls of wisdom....

HD Adam

5,155 posts

215 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Sapphire could potentially shatter and Hesalite will not but unless your middle name is "Buzz" and you are in a weightless environment, this shouldn't be an issue biggrin

I looked at both and chose the Hesalite. Polishes up very nice if you need to.

Chicane-UK

3,861 posts

216 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
It really is only down to your personal preference at the end of the day. I've found the Hesalite on my Speedmaster Professional to be surprisingly durable - I'm certainly not whacking it into things on a regular basis but I have scuffed it a number of times, and then dared to have a look and found it's fine and still totally unmolested still.

Funnily enough I have both a normal Speedmaster Pro and a Sapphire Sandwich in my watch drawer at the moment and whilst it is a real novelty looking at the inner workings of the SS version, I do still prefer the regular Professional.

daveenty

2,385 posts

241 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
I have the standard 3570.50 with plastic (OK, Hesalite) and to me it sort of looks "warmer".

Nice to see the Omega logo centred there under certain light as well, and I know that I can polish any minor scratches out.

I wouldn't have thought sapphire would shatter under normal, albeit heavy, wear though to be honest it's down to personal taste, as is the case back. Mine is solid, though I was thinking of swapping it out, then thought what's the point...

pikeyboy

2,349 posts

245 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Get a hesalite one and some polywatch will be your friend to keep it looking tip top! Even quite deep marks can be removed given enough time and effort.

Arun_D

2,340 posts

226 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
For a Pro, I would have to for the Hesalite. Saying that, I really quite like the domed sapphire glass on my Speedmaster Racing Chronometer, but the Hesalite moonwatch I had previously was perfectly fine (incidentally, it had the sapphire caseback, which I wouldn't bother going for again). The Hesalite acquired a few marks, but nothing something like Polywatch couldn't have sorted, if I had bothered before trading it in.

In terms of clarity, the sapphire is top notch, it appears to be extremely resilient to marks and reflections compared to other sapphire crystals in my collection, I don't know if that's the shape or not. I can't remember how the Hesalite stacks up in comparison.





Edited by Arun_D on Thursday 11th October 11:05

Miguel Alvarez

5,193 posts

201 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Hesalite watches have a certain look about them so I'd opt for that unless you're prone to clanging your watch hand into things.

R.P.M

1,982 posts

252 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
OK I had this very same debate with myself a few months ago.

To keep it brief I chose the Hesalite for the following reasons.

1. More in keeping with the overall history of the watch.
2. Better clarity of the dial, the sapphire tends to produced a outer ring of distortion.
3. As the glass sits proud on both models and I intend to wear the watch everyday the cheaper cost of a replacement hesalite was more attractive.
4. Initially wanted a display back but when I really thought about it, as on some of my other watches, the novelty wears off VERY quickley, and it was simply not worth it.

I have had the watch since June and have worn it everyday. Currently I am enjoying it on a leather strap. Although the hesaltie does scuff very easily, as others have said a drop of polywatch & a little elbow grease gets it looking like new again, and I find the process even more therapeutic than winding the movement every morning.



Edited by R.P.M on Thursday 11th October 11:25

RicksAlfas

14,602 posts

275 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
That looks great. Do you mind me asking where you got your curved end leather strap from?

Caruso

7,559 posts

287 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
RicksAlfas said:
That looks great. Do you mind me asking where you got your curved end leather strap from?
Or does it go under the watch Nato style?

andy tims

5,606 posts

277 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
RicksAlfas said:
That looks great. Do you mind me asking where you got your curved end leather strap from?
Looks like a Hirsch Medici

Available from

http://www.watchobsession.co.uk/HIRSCH-Watch-Strap...


R.P.M

1,982 posts

252 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
^^ as Andy says above.

I don't know of any other watch that suites so many different types of straps. Part of the appeal for me I suppose.
My next strap will be a gasgasbones NATO smile

R.P.M

1,982 posts

252 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
How much?
Unfortunately not enough to put me off!
Depending on where you source under 3 and if your lucky a little over 2 wink


HD Adam

5,155 posts

215 months

Thursday 11th October 2012
quotequote all
Paddy_N_Murphy said:
Hate this forum smile
Now I want a Moonwatch................




(how much?)
Speak to Dom H. Seriously.

Bacardi

Original Poster:

2,235 posts

307 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
Thanks guys, very interesting!

I think the see through back will be just a novelty, so not really bothered. I'm not really bothered about authenticity re the moon etc. I just like it for its classic looks. Paddy, don't speak to Dom as he will seriously tempt you as he is tempting me!!

R.P.M You are not helping me!! I swore to myself the next watch I'd get would be a white faced Breitling with a brown strap and here I am looking (dribbling) at another black faced watch, and I want it on a croc black leather strap (but may order on SS for an option), so have Seiko, Rolex sub, Omega Planet Ocean with black faces.... arrrgh... is there no end to this madness? smile

Edited by Bacardi on Friday 12th October 01:52

RicksAlfas

14,602 posts

275 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
andy tims said:
Looks like a Hirsch Medici

Available from

http://www.watchobsession.co.uk/HIRSCH-Watch-Strap...
Thank you!
thumbup

Chicane-UK

3,861 posts

216 months

Friday 12th October 2012
quotequote all
Paddy_N_Murphy said:
Daren't !
tongue out

Trying to convince myself to spend on a 996 Targa.
or iwas that a 997 Targa...... getmecoat


Oh, and a conservatory/extension.

and another Stove

and......


(you get the point I am sure !)

unless he can for less than a Bag, I'm oooout.
You can find a Speedmaster Reduced Automatic, second hand, for around the £800-£1000 mark... smile Not quite a moon watch but close enough :P