The UK deficit
Discussion
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/financialcrisis...
Any apologists for Libour care to comment?
Make no mistake this is obviously the fault of those blasted bankers.
Any apologists for Libour care to comment?
Make no mistake this is obviously the fault of those blasted bankers.
Edited by ellroy on Thursday 18th October 20:18
AFAIK the method for calculating the deficit has changed rather than it's been discovered Gordon Brown was running a multi billion pound barclaycard account and hiding the bills from the rest of us.
In recent years I've become a 'floating voter' but if the Tories want to have my vote next time around they had better stop blaming the last guy 2.5 years down the road, stop banging on about reducing a deficit that's still growing and work on stimulating the economy, and I don't just mean freeing up credit to get everyone back to buying imported consumer crap on the never-never.
In recent years I've become a 'floating voter' but if the Tories want to have my vote next time around they had better stop blaming the last guy 2.5 years down the road, stop banging on about reducing a deficit that's still growing and work on stimulating the economy, and I don't just mean freeing up credit to get everyone back to buying imported consumer crap on the never-never.
AJS- said:
If you can't sort out a deficit in 5 years you can't sort it out at all.
Not entirely sure I agree with that. This country has run a deficit in most years since 1945 and it exploded beyond all reasonable measure over the last few years. You might be able to undo 13 years of Gordon Brown running the economy in 5 years if you didn't have non-existant growth, the Eurozone crisis and Brussells bureaucrats thinking they can solve it all. p-jay - the first few years of a governments spending is more or less set in stone by the previous government. labour ran a budget surplus from 98 to 01!
ajs - exactly. 2015's deficit will be their doing. quite amazing how the tories have allowed themselves to be painted as the party of massive cuts, austerity and misery, when they have done 1/3 of fvck all so far
ajs - exactly. 2015's deficit will be their doing. quite amazing how the tories have allowed themselves to be painted as the party of massive cuts, austerity and misery, when they have done 1/3 of fvck all so far
Martin
You're not entirely wrong, but if you're a party that truly believes government spending is not the answer to economic stagnation then it shouldn't be too hard to balance the books over a period of half a decade. What this means to me is that despite their sound words and noble promises, the Tories believe, as do Labour and the Lib Dems that government spending will solve our problems and cutting it will make them worse. Obviously a very popular view with the political establishment butt one i feel is wearing thin with the tax paying portion of the electorate.
You're not entirely wrong, but if you're a party that truly believes government spending is not the answer to economic stagnation then it shouldn't be too hard to balance the books over a period of half a decade. What this means to me is that despite their sound words and noble promises, the Tories believe, as do Labour and the Lib Dems that government spending will solve our problems and cutting it will make them worse. Obviously a very popular view with the political establishment butt one i feel is wearing thin with the tax paying portion of the electorate.
AJS- said:
Martin
You're not entirely wrong, but if you're a party that truly believes government spending is not the answer to economic stagnation then it shouldn't be too hard to balance the books over a period of half a decade. What this means to me is that despite their sound words and noble promises, the Tories believe, as do Labour and the Lib Dems that government spending will solve our problems and cutting it will make them worse. Obviously a very popular view with the political establishment butt one i feel is wearing thin with the tax paying portion of the electorate.
Way too simplistic.You're not entirely wrong, but if you're a party that truly believes government spending is not the answer to economic stagnation then it shouldn't be too hard to balance the books over a period of half a decade. What this means to me is that despite their sound words and noble promises, the Tories believe, as do Labour and the Lib Dems that government spending will solve our problems and cutting it will make them worse. Obviously a very popular view with the political establishment butt one i feel is wearing thin with the tax paying portion of the electorate.
As noted, some spending was already set in stone from the last muppets.
Also, they're a coalition. They cannot railroad cuts through so every policy gets watered down to nothingness.
Lastly, even if they had a majority the last lot of muppets got so many people hooked on handouts that if they cut as they needed to in order to clear the deficit and then clear our national debt, I would guess there would be rioting to make the Poll Tax riots look like a mere 3.14key jaunt to That London.
The country's finances and it's inhabitants are screwed. The likely outcome IMO will be a couple of different coalitions exchanging power, doing nothing material with the budget until we get downgraded to the point we have to default. At which point we will all be equally poor and the lentil weavers will have got just what they want.
I suspect the Tories would dearly love to be able to cut expenditure. Won't though.
On the Red side of the house the logic is even more baffling. Ed Balls says he will build 100,000 homes and pay for them with the sale of the 4G thing-me-jig. I'm sorry but the Government can't afford to pay for everything it's funding now, before we even put a shovel in the ground. He has a plan to pay for an extra bit of spending but what about all the rest of it?
What a joke
Firstly do you not recall Labour even today mentioning the 15 % interest rates that only existed for a very few months. And it was all agreed a bi partisan agreement that no matter what we want to stay in the ERM....
So Labour leverage that and distance themselves what 20-25 years after the fact.
Next when a govt change laws fr taxation are already in place it takes time just to make an emergency budget 8-9 months then to drill down to see where you can get the cuts from.
Next tax revenue drastically decreased as companies and individuals earn less so paid less tax and more moved to needing benefits.
Budget changes apart from Tabacco duty and fuel duty etc cannot implement the next day they have to be voted on in parliament then also in the House of Lords. There could be reviews etc all taking time.
Next you have the press killing public support with a non story of the pasty tax who cares its diddly squat
Next you have long term contracts agreed which cannot be changed quickly or without termination fees. Ditto lets say MoD investments for new planes boats etc.
As for who to vote for well you know one party wants to increase debt with the view by doing so it will increase tax revenue in the future and then start to reduce the debt. Or the other party which is cutting and trying to stop the hand out culture so many are now accustomed.
Right wing basically believes in a small state while left wing larger state
Whoever gets in as a country we have to agree what the max % of Tax revenue is to be spent on welfare then that can increase or decrease depending on the tax take.
Firstly do you not recall Labour even today mentioning the 15 % interest rates that only existed for a very few months. And it was all agreed a bi partisan agreement that no matter what we want to stay in the ERM....
So Labour leverage that and distance themselves what 20-25 years after the fact.
Next when a govt change laws fr taxation are already in place it takes time just to make an emergency budget 8-9 months then to drill down to see where you can get the cuts from.
Next tax revenue drastically decreased as companies and individuals earn less so paid less tax and more moved to needing benefits.
Budget changes apart from Tabacco duty and fuel duty etc cannot implement the next day they have to be voted on in parliament then also in the House of Lords. There could be reviews etc all taking time.
Next you have the press killing public support with a non story of the pasty tax who cares its diddly squat
Next you have long term contracts agreed which cannot be changed quickly or without termination fees. Ditto lets say MoD investments for new planes boats etc.
As for who to vote for well you know one party wants to increase debt with the view by doing so it will increase tax revenue in the future and then start to reduce the debt. Or the other party which is cutting and trying to stop the hand out culture so many are now accustomed.
Right wing basically believes in a small state while left wing larger state
Whoever gets in as a country we have to agree what the max % of Tax revenue is to be spent on welfare then that can increase or decrease depending on the tax take.
P-Jay said:
AFAIK the method for calculating the deficit has changed rather than it's been discovered Gordon Brown was running a multi billion pound barclaycard account and hiding the bills from the rest of us.
In recent years I've become a 'floating voter' but if the Tories want to have my vote next time around they had better stop blaming the last guy 2.5 years down the road, stop banging on about reducing a deficit that's still growing and work on stimulating the economy, and I don't just mean freeing up credit to get everyone back to buying imported consumer crap on the never-never.
Anyone who thinks the Tories can fix the problem in one term is living in cloud cuckoo land. It took 10 years to break the economy this badly, and it will be amazing if it takes less than 10 years to fix it. We will be blaming NuLab, correctly, for decades to come.In recent years I've become a 'floating voter' but if the Tories want to have my vote next time around they had better stop blaming the last guy 2.5 years down the road, stop banging on about reducing a deficit that's still growing and work on stimulating the economy, and I don't just mean freeing up credit to get everyone back to buying imported consumer crap on the never-never.
s2art said:
Anyone who thinks the Tories can fix the problem in one term is living in cloud cuckoo land. It took 10 years to break the economy this badly, and it will be amazing if it takes less than 10 years to fix it. We will be blaming NuLab, correctly, for decades to come.
it's all thatchers fault!I do know that if I was in charge of David Cameron's election campaign for 2015 I'd just be carpet bombing every marginal constituency with leaflets bluntly explaining the debt and whose fault it is. From 2014 the Conservatives will need to hammer this message home practically every day, bring every question, every print interview, every media appearence, every QT segment back to this point.
It's things like this which makes the fact politicians spent measurable time today discussing Andrew Mitchell look beyond stupid.
It's things like this which makes the fact politicians spent measurable time today discussing Andrew Mitchell look beyond stupid.
Murph7355 said:
AJS- said:
Martin
You're not entirely wrong, but if you're a party that truly believes government spending is not the answer to economic stagnation then it shouldn't be too hard to balance the books over a period of half a decade. What this means to me is that despite their sound words and noble promises, the Tories believe, as do Labour and the Lib Dems that government spending will solve our problems and cutting it will make them worse. Obviously a very popular view with the political establishment butt one i feel is wearing thin with the tax paying portion of the electorate.
Way too simplistic.You're not entirely wrong, but if you're a party that truly believes government spending is not the answer to economic stagnation then it shouldn't be too hard to balance the books over a period of half a decade. What this means to me is that despite their sound words and noble promises, the Tories believe, as do Labour and the Lib Dems that government spending will solve our problems and cutting it will make them worse. Obviously a very popular view with the political establishment butt one i feel is wearing thin with the tax paying portion of the electorate.
As noted, some spending was already set in stone from the last muppets.
Also, they're a coalition. They cannot railroad cuts through so every policy gets watered down to nothingness.
Lastly, even if they had a majority the last lot of muppets got so many people hooked on handouts that if they cut as they needed to in order to clear the deficit and then clear our national debt, I would guess there would be rioting to make the Poll Tax riots look like a mere 3.14key jaunt to That London.
The country's finances and it's inhabitants are screwed. The likely outcome IMO will be a couple of different coalitions exchanging power, doing nothing material with the budget until we get downgraded to the point we have to default. At which point we will all be equally poor and the lentil weavers will have got just what they want.
I suspect the Tories would dearly love to be able to cut expenditure. Won't though.
I realise it's very difficult politically, but I don't believe the Tories are even really convinced about making the cuts to start with.
P-Jay said:
AFAIK the method for calculating the deficit has changed rather than it's been discovered Gordon Brown was running a multi billion pound barclaycard account and hiding the bills from the rest of us.
In recent years I've become a 'floating voter' but if the Tories want to have my vote next time around they had better stop blaming the last guy 2.5 years down the road, stop banging on about reducing a deficit that's still growing and work on stimulating the economy, and I don't just mean freeing up credit to get everyone back to buying imported consumer crap on the never-never.
Labour were still blaming thatcher nearly 20 years after she left officeIn recent years I've become a 'floating voter' but if the Tories want to have my vote next time around they had better stop blaming the last guy 2.5 years down the road, stop banging on about reducing a deficit that's still growing and work on stimulating the economy, and I don't just mean freeing up credit to get everyone back to buying imported consumer crap on the never-never.

The deficit and debt will take at leats a generation to sort out and that's if somebody with the political will to do it gets into office.
AJS- said:
Martin
You're not entirely wrong, but if you're a party that truly believes government spending is not the answer to economic stagnation then it shouldn't be too hard to balance the books over a period of half a decade. What this means to me is that despite their sound words and noble promises, the Tories believe, as do Labour and the Lib Dems that government spending will solve our problems and cutting it will make them worse. Obviously a very popular view with the political establishment butt one i feel is wearing thin with the tax paying portion of the electorate.
It might be possible to clear the structural deficit over 5 years (and I think the Tories may achieve this), but the cyclical deficit is less in their control.You're not entirely wrong, but if you're a party that truly believes government spending is not the answer to economic stagnation then it shouldn't be too hard to balance the books over a period of half a decade. What this means to me is that despite their sound words and noble promises, the Tories believe, as do Labour and the Lib Dems that government spending will solve our problems and cutting it will make them worse. Obviously a very popular view with the political establishment butt one i feel is wearing thin with the tax paying portion of the electorate.
oyster said:
It might be possible to clear the structural deficit over 5 years (and I think the Tories may achieve this), but the cyclical deficit is less in their control.
I would say the objective of clearing the entire Debt should be a 15-20 year objective. Next following that would be to actually create state pension funds no sorry it should be Pay off the PFI costs we have coming. They won't get 15-20 years though. The last time Labour went into opposition they stayed there for 18 years but it's not going to be like that this time. The Conservatives have a halfway realistic hope of a majority in 2015 on the basis that Ed Miliband is useless, but they can't count on poor opposition leaders forever.
Labour will be back in within the decade with the cutting job half finished. What happens then?
Labour will be back in within the decade with the cutting job half finished. What happens then?
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




ked.