UK productivity connundrum
Author
Discussion

Digga

Original Poster:

48,650 posts

314 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Interesting piece on BBC website: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-19981498

BBC said:
How can it be that more people are getting jobs when the economy is contracting? It means output per worker, or productivity, has fallen...
It is an issue that has many economists scratching their heads...


Normally, I'm not backward at coming forward with, err, backward pet theories, but this time I'm stumped. Anyone?

London424

12,946 posts

206 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
All statistics have been fiddled with so much that none of them make sense anymore?

Digga

Original Poster:

48,650 posts

314 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
London424 said:
All statistics have been fiddled with so much that none of them make sense anymore?
Essentially we're looking at two stats here; GDP and numbers in employment.

Not saying either are un-friggable, but how and why?

jdw1234

6,021 posts

246 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Part time McJobs and internships are being included as employed?

Digga

Original Poster:

48,650 posts

314 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
jdw1234 said:
Part time McJobs and internships are being included as employed?
I'm pondering that too.

Also wondering if a post-GFC, top-heavy skew of employment - far more jobs gone in private than public perhaps - might also see GDP dropping disproporionately?

London424

12,946 posts

206 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Digga said:
London424 said:
All statistics have been fiddled with so much that none of them make sense anymore?
Essentially we're looking at two stats here; GDP and numbers in employment.

Not saying either are un-friggable, but how and why?
No idea on either. Just a random guess on why stats don't seem to be telling the expected outcome.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
How about;

Just what is being measured as 'output'? If its market value then the downward pressure on prices caused by greater competition (from China etc) means that firms cant charge as much as they used to when the UK was known as 'treasure Island'. So we could be producing more but getting less for the output.

fido

18,938 posts

286 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
^That.

Think about it from a company perspective i.e. McDonalds - selling more burgers at a lower cost (to compete with Burger King etc.) - but need more staff (Employment) to sell those extra burgers. Of course they could pay more to attract a higher calibre of burger-flipper but then they would be competing for higher skilled workers - from a business point of view, it's cheaper to just hire staff as required.

Edited by fido on Thursday 18th October 15:54

mattnunn

14,041 posts

192 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
A lot of people waste a lot of time on Piston Heads when they should be working!

Digga

Original Poster:

48,650 posts

314 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
mattnunn said:
A lot of people waste a lot of time on Piston Heads when they should be working!
Well, my PH/work balance hasn't altered too much since 2000. biggrin

I guess the competition both between businesses and employees is agood explanation. With regard to the latter, (good) brickies were getting about £300 /day in the boom and are now working for half that or less in some cases.


DanDanDaan

22 posts

172 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Part time?

1 person working full day does x units of work

2 people on half days do x/2 units of work. Same productivity, less unemployment.

Although 2 people part time probably don't produce x between them more like 95% of x

Odie

4,187 posts

213 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Of course productivity per worker is going down, its obvious if you look for it. Im see far more disengagement from workers in the last few months. I believe the cost of live and the lack of increase in wages to match is probably the biggest cause of worker dissatisfaction and disengagement.

But the government are probably counting the figures 'differently' aswell.

Pwig

12,005 posts

301 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Interesting article from the BBC yesterday, pointing out instead of job losses, it seems that peoples wages have gone down instead. Might have something to do with it?

Tartan Pixie

2,216 posts

178 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
s2art said:
How about;

Just what is being measured as 'output'? If its market value then the downward pressure on prices caused by greater competition (from China etc) means that firms cant charge as much as they used to when the UK was known as 'treasure Island'. So we could be producing more but getting less for the output.
To add to that, a lot of the jobs created are self employment in often hellishly competitive markets. If you go on freelancer or people per hour it's possible to get branding work, writing, photography, web design and loads more for pennies.

Even ten years ago these were skills that commanded reasonable money, however jobs are now tendered globally over the net so those at the bottom of the IT/media pile have to compete globally on price.

I daresay that a lot of these new self employed are taking time to learn about business and work up to something bigger, there will also be a lot of pressure to work cash in hand if money is tight.

Digga

Original Poster:

48,650 posts

314 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
As far as SME's go, with the wholesale loss/reduction of bank funding that happened in 2009, I also guess that those who remain are simply having to work with less of everything - stock, plant, machinery, IT - and so cannot hope to hit the sort of figures they did pre-GFC.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
Too many of the extra jobs are only part time which means plenty of them will still be entitled to and in need of state benefits of some sort, so 20 hours a week jobs in Mothercare isn't going to get us out of this mess.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Thursday 18th October 2012
quotequote all
EU financial immigrants who often work cash in hand finding it difficult here and going home combined with more UK nationals being 'encouraged' off the dole and sick into jobs where they do pay tax and thus show up on the figures?