USA active in currency manipulation
Discussion
Ben Bunanke in Tokyo this week let it slip to the world that the USA is currently engaged in actively manipulating its own currency. Something that in the past the USA has vigorously ridiculed other countries for (namely China).
Currency manipulation under the international Omnibus Trade and Competitiveness Act of 1988 is something that countries are not allowed to do in the name of trading fairness and of the capitalist model that the USA have been so proud to advertise and implement around the globe.
It seems that the USA’s current stance is that it is standing on a stage announcing to the world that we intend to cause the dollar to fall and we can print as much money as we want in order to achieve that goal. The USA is demanding that other countries follow the rules of capitalism and the so called ‘free market’ so that the USA can prosper, whilst at the same time the USA breaks the ‘rules’ in order that the dollar can fall and its national debt and deficit can be reduced.
The message being given out by Washington is that other countries can either print money too and see interest rates rise or accept that your currency is going to rise against the dollar.
Very aggressive stance by the USA, are they right to do this?
The UK is not going to be in a stronger position as a result, what do you guys think?
Links:
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/books/reviews...
http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/14/us-usa-f...
http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2012/...
Main story from Russia Today's Max Keiser :
http://rt.com/programs/keiser-report/episode-355-m...
Currency manipulation under the international Omnibus Trade and Competitiveness Act of 1988 is something that countries are not allowed to do in the name of trading fairness and of the capitalist model that the USA have been so proud to advertise and implement around the globe.
It seems that the USA’s current stance is that it is standing on a stage announcing to the world that we intend to cause the dollar to fall and we can print as much money as we want in order to achieve that goal. The USA is demanding that other countries follow the rules of capitalism and the so called ‘free market’ so that the USA can prosper, whilst at the same time the USA breaks the ‘rules’ in order that the dollar can fall and its national debt and deficit can be reduced.
The message being given out by Washington is that other countries can either print money too and see interest rates rise or accept that your currency is going to rise against the dollar.
Very aggressive stance by the USA, are they right to do this?
The UK is not going to be in a stronger position as a result, what do you guys think?
Links:
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/books/reviews...
http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/14/us-usa-f...
http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2012/...
Main story from Russia Today's Max Keiser :
http://rt.com/programs/keiser-report/episode-355-m...
ewenm said:
I'd always expect a country to act in its own best interests, especially when juggling numbers in financial systems.
ETA: It's in the USA's interests to manipulate their currency AND to discourage others from doing the same.
Even when they ridicule other countries of doing the same?ETA: It's in the USA's interests to manipulate their currency AND to discourage others from doing the same.
Edited by ewenm on Friday 19th October 10:09
AJI said:
Even when they ridicule other countries of doing the same?
It's in their interests to do so. Why would you expect anything else?If currency manipulation can offer a competitive advantage, it is in the USA's interest to do it and it is also in their interest to try to prevent other countries from doing it.
Ideological integrity falls far behind (as evidenced daily in the press about politicians the world over).
ewenm said:
It's in their interests to do so. Why would you expect anything else?
If currency manipulation can offer a competitive advantage, it is in the USA's interest to do it and it is also in their interest to try to prevent other countries from doing it.
Ideological integrity falls far behind (as evidenced daily in the press about politicians the world over).
But then if thats true would this end the so called 'free market', creating an openly government/state controlled market.If currency manipulation can offer a competitive advantage, it is in the USA's interest to do it and it is also in their interest to try to prevent other countries from doing it.
Ideological integrity falls far behind (as evidenced daily in the press about politicians the world over).
AJI said:
Just another issue, this being the term 'USA interests'. Seems to be an ever widening broader term applied to more and more of the globe and including many other countries 'intersts' too.
(But this, I guess, belongs in another topic).
I expect other countries to do what is in their interests too.(But this, I guess, belongs in another topic).
ewenm said:
I expect other countries to do what is in their interests too.
But taking that simple line of approach it is in Isreal's best interests to nuke Iran. So the international cummunity should just sit back and allow it to happen?(Playing devil's advocate of course)
My point simply being that as the USA brought about the world recession from allowing illegal activities on Wall Street(arguable point I agree), but should they not be placing themselves more accountable? Instead it seems they choose to break the 'rules' of their 'free market' model and force inflation on to other struggling economies.
I'm no economic expert I will be the first to admit. I'm just posting this to create a discussion.
Would nuking Iran really be in Israel's best interests?
I'm not suggesting the rest of the world sits back and lets the USA (or any other country) do what it likes, merely that I expect most countries to push as hard as they can in their own interest. Obviously this will come up against international resistance, the strength of which will help define the limits of the action.
If international outrage was strong enough to make currency manipulation not worth while for the USA, then they wouldn't do it. The outrage doesn't appear to be all that strong though.
I'm not suggesting the rest of the world sits back and lets the USA (or any other country) do what it likes, merely that I expect most countries to push as hard as they can in their own interest. Obviously this will come up against international resistance, the strength of which will help define the limits of the action.
If international outrage was strong enough to make currency manipulation not worth while for the USA, then they wouldn't do it. The outrage doesn't appear to be all that strong though.
One would not expect crit on the US devaluing it's currency in a UK forum
Check our history. (Brit in US so don't start yelling at me)
The USA has been in a race to bottom for quite a few years, arguing Chinese currency is unfairly cheap and causing a growing trade deficit.
China ignores, problem persists.
I'm not saying QE is good, for me it certainly isn't.
Bernake will be gone soon if we get the right result in November. We might see a more business like solution to the economic problems here. Current gov view is "stock market is up" "all must be ok" and of course it isn't. We're in the toilet.
Emerging Markets, especially Brazil ain't happy with us, like we need more enemies

Check our history. (Brit in US so don't start yelling at me)
The USA has been in a race to bottom for quite a few years, arguing Chinese currency is unfairly cheap and causing a growing trade deficit.
China ignores, problem persists.
I'm not saying QE is good, for me it certainly isn't.
Bernake will be gone soon if we get the right result in November. We might see a more business like solution to the economic problems here. Current gov view is "stock market is up" "all must be ok" and of course it isn't. We're in the toilet.
Emerging Markets, especially Brazil ain't happy with us, like we need more enemies

Don't really see how it's in their interests myself. It might provide a short term boost to exports (temporary anyway as prices will rise) but with their massive oil consumption and inflation creeping up it seems a bit short sighted. The sort of thing one might do to get better numbers in the run up to an election perhaps.
AJS- said:
Don't really see how it's in their interests myself. It might provide a short term boost to exports (temporary anyway as prices will rise) but with their massive oil consumption and inflation creeping up it seems a bit short sighted. The sort of thing one might do to get better numbers in the run up to an election perhaps.
Is there an election due in the US soon? 
OP - every country does this one way or another. As AJS notes, how effective or long term it is will be debatable. And I suspect could easily backfire if enough foreign powers own enough US dollars...
Hypocrisy is something all countries engage in too.
Non-stories really.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


