Anyone got a McLaren MP4-12C?
Discussion
There doesn't seem to be a McLaren section so this seemed to be the best spot.
The 12C Spyder seems to be getting rave reviews but one thing caused me to wonder.
When the MP4-12C came out the general response of the journos including Christ Harris of this site was that it was amazing, and pipped only by the 458 for lacking emotional qualities, specifically the NA high rpm exhaust note.
Now I read in the Autocar first drive of the Spyder that the coupe suffers from initial under steer, exacerbated by turbo lag, followed by unexpected aggressive oversteer when the turbos bite. Those are two very serious flaws just to be going on with. Is the Mac then NOT as good as it was cracked up to be?
The 12C Spyder seems to be getting rave reviews but one thing caused me to wonder.
When the MP4-12C came out the general response of the journos including Christ Harris of this site was that it was amazing, and pipped only by the 458 for lacking emotional qualities, specifically the NA high rpm exhaust note.
Now I read in the Autocar first drive of the Spyder that the coupe suffers from initial under steer, exacerbated by turbo lag, followed by unexpected aggressive oversteer when the turbos bite. Those are two very serious flaws just to be going on with. Is the Mac then NOT as good as it was cracked up to be?
I suspect they were talking about on the limit at a track. Virtually every road car will have some sort of under steer dialled in and with 600bhp oversteer will be available on demand.
Journalists also contradict themselves frequently - they are trying to articulate small details that are often a matter of taste and they usually portray their opinions as 'facts'. You can get a general opinion from magazines but you need to drive yourself to compare.
On the road it will likely be different IMHO.
Journalists also contradict themselves frequently - they are trying to articulate small details that are often a matter of taste and they usually portray their opinions as 'facts'. You can get a general opinion from magazines but you need to drive yourself to compare.
On the road it will likely be different IMHO.
I understand what you are saying, the difficulty being I need to know what the issue is and I am unlikely to be given a 12C to find out for myself.
I appreciate that journos do just what you are saying, but if you read the little editorial box in the Autocar test, it would put any prospective buyer off the car completely, I mean, sudden oversteer when the Turbo kicks in? That is why the 911 GT2 is referred to as the Widowmaker. However high the limits of grip are and whether these characteristics are controlled electronically or not, one day you are going to be on a wet roundabout or a frosty corner, or even at higher speed, and you are going to find out the hard way.
I know it isn't a Toyota GT86 but you want to feel that you are in a car which whatever the driver aids is ultimately going to break away in a progressive and predictable manner. If it doesn't, the approach of the small turbocharged engine fundamentally doesn't work, and you have no choice but buy a silk shirt, some Grecian 2000 and large gold medallion and a Ferrari 458.
I appreciate that journos do just what you are saying, but if you read the little editorial box in the Autocar test, it would put any prospective buyer off the car completely, I mean, sudden oversteer when the Turbo kicks in? That is why the 911 GT2 is referred to as the Widowmaker. However high the limits of grip are and whether these characteristics are controlled electronically or not, one day you are going to be on a wet roundabout or a frosty corner, or even at higher speed, and you are going to find out the hard way.
I know it isn't a Toyota GT86 but you want to feel that you are in a car which whatever the driver aids is ultimately going to break away in a progressive and predictable manner. If it doesn't, the approach of the small turbocharged engine fundamentally doesn't work, and you have no choice but buy a silk shirt, some Grecian 2000 and large gold medallion and a Ferrari 458.
The frequency and extent of revisionish history in car reviews is startling, particularly for Ferrari's. Read any recent F12 review (Evo print version for example) and you'd think the 599 was the worst, least stable car Ferrari ever produced.....despite the 599 being an Evo car of the year.
It's about selling magazines, not maintaining and reporting against an accurate baseline from which cars are commonly judged.
It's about selling magazines, not maintaining and reporting against an accurate baseline from which cars are commonly judged.
cardigankid said:
I appreciate that journos do just what you are saying, but if you read the little editorial box in the Autocar test, it would put any prospective buyer off the car completely, I mean, sudden oversteer when the Turbo kicks in? That is why the 911 GT2 is referred to as the Widowmaker. However high the limits of grip are and whether these characteristics are controlled electronically or not, one day you are going to be on a wet roundabout or a frosty corner, or even at higher speed, and you are going to find out the hard way.
.
And having owned a 996 GT2 for 8 years I can tell you that it can be very controllable and it can be drifted beautifully once you get to know the car and setup the suspension to whatever your driving style and expectations are. We aren't talking much here, half a degree of caster and camber etc. there is a reason why ALL supercars have fully adjustable suspension, default settings are what they are as a compromise. I'd bet you can make a 12C do anything you want and I'm sure knowing McLaren they'd help you out if you talk to them..
Oh and having driven 458's, if you jump too hard on the power it snaps to oversteer without stability on, with a turbo car you just have to make allowance for the extra torque it's going to produce but all modern turbo cars can be driven with finesse, this isn't old school lag and bang anymore but there is still more torque available on request than most people are used to.
It's all about learning how to drive the car rather than taking a magazine test as gospel.
London John said:
The frequency and extent of revisionish history in car reviews is startling, particularly for Ferrari's. Read any recent F12 review (Evo print version for example) and you'd think the 599 was the worst, least stable car Ferrari ever produced.....despite the 599 being an Evo car of the year.
It's about selling magazines, not maintaining and reporting against an accurate baseline from which cars are commonly judged.
Very much this ^ It's about selling magazines, not maintaining and reporting against an accurate baseline from which cars are commonly judged.
In the piece in EVO they beat up on the 599 so much I thought they must have had an axe to grind against Mr Harris (as he had just bought one at the time).
Lately I've been thinking about cancelling my sub to EVO, it all just seems very 'boys club' at the moment.
ETA a link to the Autocar video review of the 12C Spyder, in which he extols the virtues of it's chassis:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ftsbLZyMrjw&fea...
Edited by Lione1 Richie on Monday 22 October 13:07
I agree with you guys. Evo have been outrageous.
As someone who is trying to buy a 599 and has driven one I could not believe Evo's review of their own history. It suddenly went from the 599 being the best GT / Super Car in the world to being hard to keep on the road...
Also thought the review of the MP4-12C was odd in Autocar re handling as I understand they are very good...
GusB
As someone who is trying to buy a 599 and has driven one I could not believe Evo's review of their own history. It suddenly went from the 599 being the best GT / Super Car in the world to being hard to keep on the road...
Also thought the review of the MP4-12C was odd in Autocar re handling as I understand they are very good...
GusB
I've got a 12C and it's great to drive as fast as you dare on a track. Don't know what you've heard but it breaks away and slides progressively - inspires huge confidence. You can adjust the handling to suit your mood, I find that the track setting allows 30% slip and so let's you feel the car moving while still giving some reassurance that help is at hand if you need it (not having track insurance tends to dampen over enthusiasm...)
These journos must kiss manufacturer a55 (especially Ferrari) otherwise they won't get a car to test. Fancy lending them your Enzo? No? Well neither would I.
Which means they've got to take it off the manufacturer and are at the manufacturers mercy.
Knowing that, the manufacturers lend them cars which, certainly in my experience, can have radically different handling/performance characteristics to the cars which are eventually delivered. Chris Harris butchered Ferrari about this. Good on him. One of few journos I respect actually.
From experience Porsche don't (or at lease didn't) manipulate their test cars.
And finally, these guys drive them for a day or two and are blown away. Ownership is different.
I'm a crap driver and when it comes to what I say you can take it or leave it I suppose.
The 599 in it's base form is NOT an especially great handling car. It's outstanding initial turn-in (almost exagerrated by sharpish and very light detached steering) gives way to a chassis that is understeery and lacking in real mechanical front-end grip. Balance doesn't change unless you switch off all the electronics and boot it (at which point it could do with a bit more traction) - worse, the whole car is just too soft and lacking in real body-control when you throw it around. It really does pitch around.
And I'm cocky enough to say that I think I was right from the start - why? I've been shown to be right by Ferrari themselves - cue HGTE handling pack and finally a 599GTO which sits on 285 section fronts (!!!) and a load of other mods to quell the inherent understeer in previous models and which is awesomely flat through the corners (only now it need computers to stop you spinning off).
TBH - none of this matters on the road anyway. Ignore my musings. Totally irrelevant really on the jaunt down to the Village coffee shop..
Which means they've got to take it off the manufacturer and are at the manufacturers mercy.
Knowing that, the manufacturers lend them cars which, certainly in my experience, can have radically different handling/performance characteristics to the cars which are eventually delivered. Chris Harris butchered Ferrari about this. Good on him. One of few journos I respect actually.
From experience Porsche don't (or at lease didn't) manipulate their test cars.
And finally, these guys drive them for a day or two and are blown away. Ownership is different.
I'm a crap driver and when it comes to what I say you can take it or leave it I suppose.
The 599 in it's base form is NOT an especially great handling car. It's outstanding initial turn-in (almost exagerrated by sharpish and very light detached steering) gives way to a chassis that is understeery and lacking in real mechanical front-end grip. Balance doesn't change unless you switch off all the electronics and boot it (at which point it could do with a bit more traction) - worse, the whole car is just too soft and lacking in real body-control when you throw it around. It really does pitch around.
And I'm cocky enough to say that I think I was right from the start - why? I've been shown to be right by Ferrari themselves - cue HGTE handling pack and finally a 599GTO which sits on 285 section fronts (!!!) and a load of other mods to quell the inherent understeer in previous models and which is awesomely flat through the corners (only now it need computers to stop you spinning off).
TBH - none of this matters on the road anyway. Ignore my musings. Totally irrelevant really on the jaunt down to the Village coffee shop..
Edited by Murcielago_Boy on Monday 22 October 13:43
cardigankid said:
I know it isn't a Toyota GT86 but you want to feel that you are in a car which whatever the driver aids is ultimately going to break away in a progressive and predictable manner. If it doesn't, the approach of the small turbocharged engine fundamentally doesn't work, and you have no choice but buy a silk shirt, some Grecian 2000 and large gold medallion and a Ferrari 458.
....or a cardigan and an Aston Martin Best all round road car I have ever owned. 5000 miles in mine since march and can't see me ever selling it. Soft cruiser that will return over 25mpg when you in lazy mode and killer track car when needed. Sounds fantastic with the sports exhaust.
Looking forward to sat Nav and Bluetooth working in next couple of months...
Looking forward to sat Nav and Bluetooth working in next couple of months...
Despite the 12c being near the top top top of my dream list, how can they not have sorted the nav (or radio?!) yet?
Have the owners above had any excuses/reasons given to them which are even acceptable for a £170k car?
I don't think it would ever put me off, but it's taken a hell of a long time!
Have the owners above had any excuses/reasons given to them which are even acceptable for a £170k car?
I don't think it would ever put me off, but it's taken a hell of a long time!
GusB said:
I agree with you guys. Evo have been outrageous.
As someone who is trying to buy a 599 and has driven one I could not believe Evo's review of their own history. It suddenly went from the 599 being the best GT / Super Car in the world to being hard to keep on the road...
Also thought the review of the MP4-12C was odd in Autocar re handling as I understand they are very good...
GusB
Interesting they say that about the 599, as I couldn't disagree more. One of the things that had actually put me off a 599 before I bought mine was that I was concerned it would just be all over the road and impossible to control, quite the opposite really.As someone who is trying to buy a 599 and has driven one I could not believe Evo's review of their own history. It suddenly went from the 599 being the best GT / Super Car in the world to being hard to keep on the road...
Also thought the review of the MP4-12C was odd in Autocar re handling as I understand they are very good...
GusB
Don't get me wrong it’s a rear wheel drive car with 600BHP so if you are driving like a hooligan in the wet, then the back end can wiggle, but I personally find it is far better than my old 430. As good as the 430 was I thought it was a bit of a nightmare in the wet, whereas the 599 actually feels more planted and in the dry is incredible! Brilliant car!
GusB Hurry up and buy one!

Lione1 Richie said:
London John said:
The frequency and extent of revisionish history in car reviews is startling, particularly for Ferrari's. Read any recent F12 review (Evo print version for example) and you'd think the 599 was the worst, least stable car Ferrari ever produced.....despite the 599 being an Evo car of the year.
It's about selling magazines, not maintaining and reporting against an accurate baseline from which cars are commonly judged.
Very much this ^ It's about selling magazines, not maintaining and reporting against an accurate baseline from which cars are commonly judged.
In the piece in EVO they beat up on the 599 so much I thought they must have had an axe to grind against Mr Harris (as he had just bought one at the time).
Lately I've been thinking about cancelling my sub to EVO, it all just seems very 'boys club' at the moment.
ETA a link to the Autocar video review of the 12C Spyder, in which he extols the virtues of it's chassis:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ftsbLZyMrjw&fea...
As I said car reviews are simply someone else's opinion, although I would take their opinion onboard (depends very much who they are) it certainly wouldn't stop me buying a car. The reality is you need to drive the car yourself before you can really comment on what it's like to drive.
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



