It really is like the Thick of It.
It really is like the Thick of It.
Author
Discussion

FiF

Original Poster:

49,060 posts

282 months

Digga

48,650 posts

314 months

Monday 22nd October 2012
quotequote all
Aside from Malcom Tucker's, rapier dipped in st mode of cutting humour, my outstanding quote was from Chris Langham's character IIRC in a car journey on the way back from another ststorm, being pursued by MT on his mobile 'phone and langham says - to no one in particular - "I just want to be able to get on with my job!"

hehe

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Monday 22nd October 2012
quotequote all
This is a Government which last month awarded Atos a contract worth £400million to save the Government £600million in disability benefits.

You couldn't make it up.

carinaman

25,301 posts

203 months

Monday 22nd October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
This is a Government which last month awarded Atos a contract worth £400million to save the Government £600million in disability benefits.

You couldn't make it up.
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/soldier-sacked-by-army-72-hours-1389909

frown

I seem to remember Cameron saying 'military convenant' a few times before they got it.

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Monday 22nd October 2012
quotequote all
Causing themselves the maximum political loss, maximum public anger and all for the minimum financial saving. That's my new definition of Governmental incompetence.

The Atos example is just a joke though, they're essentially taking £400million away from disabled people and giving it straight to Atos. No wonder disabled groups are outraged at this Government. They can't even claim it's saving them money.

ralphrj

4,135 posts

222 months

Monday 22nd October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Causing themselves the maximum political loss, maximum public anger and all for the minimum financial saving. That's my new definition of Governmental incompetence.

The Atos example is just a joke though, they're essentially taking £400million away from disabled people and giving it straight to Atos. No wonder disabled groups are outraged at this Government. They can't even claim it's saving them money.
Do you have a link to the figures you quoted earlier? I'm not saying you are wrong but I would like to know more.

I suspect that it may be a misleading figure a bit like saying that the number of people claiming DLA has tripled since it was introduced (there are genuine reasons why it has increased) at an increased cost to the taxpayer of £8bn per year. All parties think that DLA may be subject to fraudulent claims as a result of people being able to claim in indefinitely. When it was introduced indefinite recipients were supposed to be reviewed but until Atos were brought it there was no procedure for doing so.


Randy Winkman

22,833 posts

220 months

Monday 22nd October 2012
quotequote all
The previous Government might have had hopeless policies, but this one is downright amateurish. (Not suggesting the latter is worse, btw.)

martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2012
quotequote all
ralphrj said:
Do you have a link to the figures you quoted earlier? I'm not saying you are wrong but I would like to know more.
Actually I was being kind to the Government with those figures. Maria Miller - when she was disability minister - stated on Newsnight £600m is paid out in DLA every year to people who don't qualify. To combat this Dave and Co have given Atos a contract - according to most news outlets - worth £400m a year to assess whether people should receive it or not.

ralphrj said:
I suspect that it may be a misleading figure a bit like saying that the number of people claiming DLA has tripled since it was introduced (there are genuine reasons why it has increased) at an increased cost to the taxpayer of £8bn per year.
The reason I said I'm being kind is because the Government don't just want to eliminate the £600m supposedly overpaid, their real aim is to cut DLA spending by 20% over the next three years. DLA cost just under £11bn in 2009 and the Guardian claims it was £13bn last year. 20% of 13 is 2.6, so even if the .6 is wrongly paid they still want to take £2bn away from disabled people who are legitimately claiming.

ralphrj said:
All parties think that DLA may be subject to fraudulent claims as a result of people being able to claim in indefinitely.
The Department of Work and Pensions in 2009 stated the fraud rate for DLA to be 0.5%, see page 10 of this DWP report http://campaigns.dwp.gov.uk/asd/asd2/fem/fem_apr08...

I don't know about you but I think £50 million is rather less than £600 million.

The only thing harder to claim dishonestly than DLA is the State Pension. It's not means tested, it's based exclusively on physical capability and it's not something you just wander into the Job Centre and fill out a form for. Receiving DLA is a long complicated process involving forms and reports longer than the Lord of the Rings.

ralphrj said:
When it was introduced indefinite recipients were supposed to be reviewed but until Atos were brought it there was no procedure for doing so.
bks. My mother gets DLA and is assessed every three years to determine if she keeps it - and has been since 2004. It's based on reports made by her GP who concludes she is no better now than she was 8 years ago. Why do we pay for the NHS doctor to do these reports and then pay out more money for some Atos box-ticker to do the same thing?

The obvious conclusion is we are not paying Atos £400m a year to cut down the second smallest rate of benefit fraud in the UK, but rather paying them because they'll happily judge disabled people against standards real doctors wouldn't - and whose pay does not depend on kicking a million people off disability benefits, which Cameron has told Atos to do. When Maria Miller speaks about £600m being 'fradulently claimed' she doesn't mean they're not entitled to receive it now. She means she doesn't think they should be.

We need to be very wary of the language used by Ministers around this stuff. The Paralympians didn't all hide all of their Atos sponsored gear for no reason.

c7xlg

930 posts

263 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2012
quotequote all
Taking the emotion out of it, isn't spending £400 million to save £600 million a good thing? Net saving of £200 million? Not chump change.

The debate is then about IF the £600m savings are due to fraudulent claims being stopped, in which case that is a good thing surely, or the savings will be due to stopping paying claims that are 'fair and resonable' which would be bad.


JagLover

46,849 posts

266 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2012
quotequote all
c7xlg said:
Taking the emotion out of it, isn't spending £400 million to save £600 million a good thing? Net saving of £200 million? Not chump change.

The debate is then about IF the £600m savings are due to fraudulent claims being stopped, in which case that is a good thing surely, or the savings will be due to stopping paying claims that are 'fair and resonable' which would be bad.
I'm not sure the term fraudalent is that useful

I'm sure most of the recipients have some form of disability, the change in focus is what work can't they do to what work they can.