What is wrong with E65s?
Discussion
Hi All,
I have been looking for a Lexus LS430/GS430 to replace my aging 530i Touring, but as there seem to be precious few within 150 miles of where I live, I have decided to widen my net to include the E65 7 series. It turns out that these cars are a bit of a bargain at the moment...
This one seems staggeringly good value:
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2012...
Or are they?
With my E39, it was the gearbox going pop at just over 100k - expensive, then there was the cooling system made of chocolate - not too expensive, but annoying, then of course the dreaded 'hedgehog' - cheap to fix but very irritating when you are on a camping holiday and the thing decides to play up. The list goes on.
So what's the big problem with the big 7 that makes them so cheap? I have done a bit of poking around in the usual places but can't see anything obvious, and there are a few examples up for sale with 160K+ on the clock, which is usually a good sign as to their longevity. I'd plan to buy one with about 100K on the clock for £4k or thereabouts and run it for a few years of 25-30k motorway miles until it dies, or I get completely bored with it. I prefer petrol, and am not too fussed about engine size as they all seem to have roughly the same economy figures. As this is my commuting car, it really needs to be reliable (hence the original plan to buy a Lexus)
So what is it that I am missing? Is it really only a result of big engine syndrome?
I have been looking for a Lexus LS430/GS430 to replace my aging 530i Touring, but as there seem to be precious few within 150 miles of where I live, I have decided to widen my net to include the E65 7 series. It turns out that these cars are a bit of a bargain at the moment...
This one seems staggeringly good value:
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2012...
Or are they?
With my E39, it was the gearbox going pop at just over 100k - expensive, then there was the cooling system made of chocolate - not too expensive, but annoying, then of course the dreaded 'hedgehog' - cheap to fix but very irritating when you are on a camping holiday and the thing decides to play up. The list goes on.
So what's the big problem with the big 7 that makes them so cheap? I have done a bit of poking around in the usual places but can't see anything obvious, and there are a few examples up for sale with 160K+ on the clock, which is usually a good sign as to their longevity. I'd plan to buy one with about 100K on the clock for £4k or thereabouts and run it for a few years of 25-30k motorway miles until it dies, or I get completely bored with it. I prefer petrol, and am not too fussed about engine size as they all seem to have roughly the same economy figures. As this is my commuting car, it really needs to be reliable (hence the original plan to buy a Lexus)
So what is it that I am missing? Is it really only a result of big engine syndrome?
I've had two, i ran one from new to 127k miles and the other from new to 112k miles. It never missed a beat and still looked and drove like new. The only thing that gave a problem on one was the soft close doors which if i had my time again i'd not order as it's a daft thing to 'need' on a car.
Get one, they still look very modern in my eyes and drive fantastically!
Get one, they still look very modern in my eyes and drive fantastically!
For such a complex car, they have proven remarkably reliable. The box doesn't go tits-up like the E39 ZF used to but whilst the cooling system is much better than the old E38/E39, they do like to leak oil from the cam cover gaskets and can get a bit smokey with premature bore/ring wear.
But, if you find one for 4-5 grand with a decent history and it all works, probably not a bad thing to own. However - if it does go wrong, it will cost a lot of money to put right. A 160'000 mile example is probably not a good idea.
But, if you find one for 4-5 grand with a decent history and it all works, probably not a bad thing to own. However - if it does go wrong, it will cost a lot of money to put right. A 160'000 mile example is probably not a good idea.
Some interesting and conflicting opinions there. Seems like they are worth a look. If I can get between 2 and 3 years out of one it wouldn't owe me anything. I could even stomach a few big(ish) bills in that time and still be ahead of depreciation on a Roger Rep special.
I'm also happy to tinker with it myself for the smaller / simple stuff. The E39 taught me a lot about tinkering
I'm also happy to tinker with it myself for the smaller / simple stuff. The E39 taught me a lot about tinkering

It's the potential big bills bit I am trying to find out about. One has to accept these cars won't be cheap to maintain, but if they have known faults that cost thousands then I would stay clear.
Anything that's likely to cost north of 1500 would put me off if it was as likely as the gearbox issues on the auto E39.
Anything that's likely to cost north of 1500 would put me off if it was as likely as the gearbox issues on the auto E39.
skoff said:
Anything that's likely to cost north of 1500 would put me off if it was as likely as the gearbox issues on the auto E39.
Best forget an E65 then! Buying anything like this - E65, an older S Class or A8 is a gamble. Buying an E65 is the cheap bit, running it is another thing. Look instead at a manual E60 525i if you want a modernish BMW with less risk.skoff said:
Anything that's likely to cost north of 1500 would put me off if it was as likely as the gearbox issues on the auto E39.
What are the gearbox issues on the E39 auto?I have a 2002 540i sport auto with 65k on the clock - what issues am I looking at and is there anything I can do to avoid them?
- worried!
iSore said:
Best forget an E65 then! Buying anything like this - E65, an older S Class or A8 is a gamble. Buying an E65 is the cheap bit, running it is another thing. Look instead at a manual E60 525i if you want a modernish BMW with less risk.
So what, specifically, are the likely big issues? That's my question. I'm assuming that over £1500 we are looking at gearbox or engine problems, or maybe hard to replace suspension parts? I'm talking stuff that will leave you at the side of the road, not just stuff like broken air-con that's non-essential.I already know what the regular maintenance costs are, they are well published, and are commensurate with the type of car - this car will not be run on a shoestring. However, if the gearbox is more or less guaranteed to go pop with a £2.5K bill, then, no, it's not the car for me, and I will continue to focus on the search for a Lexus, which has far fewer issues than most cars of that ilk.
The A8 is already ruled out due to weak gearbox, the S-Class due to corrosion, electrical issues, and expensive suspension, but these are issues you are pretty much guaranteed to have at some point, in much the same way as the auto box on an E39 is going to give up at some point round abouts 100k miles. I've already ruled out an E60 as I have covered over 80K miles in an E39 and I need a change from a 5 series.
Any second hand car has a certain amount of risk attached, but one needs to balance that against the initial cost of the car, the likelihood of really big issues occurring, and of course what it would cost to fix them. If I wasn't prepared to accept any risk, then I'd be buying a boring white-goods type car from new with a warranty, and taking the hit on depreciation.
counterofbeans said:
What are the gearbox issues on the E39 auto?
I have a 2002 540i sport auto with 65k on the clock - what issues am I looking at and is there anything I can do to avoid them?
The problem I had was a failure of reverse at around 110K miles - it's pretty common I'm afraid, head over to http://forum.bmw5.co.uk and do a search, or here is an example thread from a few days ago http://bit.ly/VodWPdI have a 2002 540i sport auto with 65k on the clock - what issues am I looking at and is there anything I can do to avoid them?
- worried!
Of course I am sure not every car has the problem, but when mine failed I found a plethora of threads with similar problems.
I don't know if an oil change would help or not, some say yes, some say no. I got a good deal on a rebuild for about £1500, and the car has been superb ever since. Considering I didn't pay that much for the car, and considering the miles I have put on it it's actually not too big a bill to swallow, still cheaper than depreciation. The E39 is such a good car you can forgive it for it's foibles - this is just an expensive one unfortunately!
Your car could be absolutely fine, and I'm not sure if the V8 cars are as badly affected as the 6 cyl cars (if at all), plus you are lots of miles away from the danger zone anyway. I wouldn't worry, but always good practice to have a bit of money stashed for such eventualities.
skoff said:
counterofbeans said:
What are the gearbox issues on the E39 auto?
I have a 2002 540i sport auto with 65k on the clock - what issues am I looking at and is there anything I can do to avoid them?
The problem I had was a failure of reverse at around 110K miles - it's pretty common I'm afraid, head over to http://forum.bmw5.co.uk and do a search, or here is an example thread from a few days ago http://bit.ly/VodWPdI have a 2002 540i sport auto with 65k on the clock - what issues am I looking at and is there anything I can do to avoid them?
- worried!
Of course I am sure not every car has the problem, but when mine failed I found a plethora of threads with similar problems.
I don't know if an oil change would help or not, some say yes, some say no. I got a good deal on a rebuild for about £1500, and the car has been superb ever since. Considering I didn't pay that much for the car, and considering the miles I have put on it it's actually not too big a bill to swallow, still cheaper than depreciation. The E39 is such a good car you can forgive it for it's foibles - this is just an expensive one unfortunately!
Your car could be absolutely fine, and I'm not sure if the V8 cars are as badly affected as the 6 cyl cars (if at all), plus you are lots of miles away from the danger zone anyway. I wouldn't worry, but always good practice to have a bit of money stashed for such eventualities.
As above though if I had to spend £1500 on a box rebuild for my 540 (125K miles) it wouldn't be a big deal. I love the car and don't know what I'd replace it with...
For a start, the E65 suffers from the same problem as all the 7 series:
It's a bigger car than most people want, replacement parts are expensive, servicing can be expensive, insurance is high, it likes a drink and a lot of them get neglected by later owners who try to run them on the cheap by skipping services or ignoring required repairs.
The last one tends to be a big part of their reputation for having mechanical/electrical issues.
Another problem with the E65 is that it's not the prettiest of cars. It lacks the svelte lines and elegance of the E38 and looks a bit bulky.
However, if you've got the space to park a 7 series, and the money to run one, then you can get a lot of car for comparatively little money!
It's a bigger car than most people want, replacement parts are expensive, servicing can be expensive, insurance is high, it likes a drink and a lot of them get neglected by later owners who try to run them on the cheap by skipping services or ignoring required repairs.
The last one tends to be a big part of their reputation for having mechanical/electrical issues.
Another problem with the E65 is that it's not the prettiest of cars. It lacks the svelte lines and elegance of the E38 and looks a bit bulky.
However, if you've got the space to park a 7 series, and the money to run one, then you can get a lot of car for comparatively little money!
There is no pattern to E39 gearbox failures. They're all old cars now. Most of them are still working, some have over 200'000 miles and only a tiny fraction have ever had an oil change. Reverse failure is the end of the cast metal reverse drum breaking off and releasing the spring ring holding the clutch rings in place. The same thing can happen to the forward clutch pack as well. That's nothing to do with the oil, just a cheap and cheerful part breaking because it's only just strong enough.
The 6 speed Mechatronic box in the E65 is strong mechanically but can suffer valve block issues - that's a £1500 quid job to fix.
The E65 is one of those cars that you run until it starts to develop a problem - harsh shifting, coolant loos - and then p/x it sharpish.
As a car, they're absolutely magnificent. It will, in many years to come, be one of their classics. I still have the 2001 brochure I picked up from a German dealership whilst buying some parts.
The 6 speed Mechatronic box in the E65 is strong mechanically but can suffer valve block issues - that's a £1500 quid job to fix.
The E65 is one of those cars that you run until it starts to develop a problem - harsh shifting, coolant loos - and then p/x it sharpish.
As a car, they're absolutely magnificent. It will, in many years to come, be one of their classics. I still have the 2001 brochure I picked up from a German dealership whilst buying some parts.
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


