Costa Coffee pulls out of Totnes despite planning approval
Costa Coffee pulls out of Totnes despite planning approval
Author
Discussion

Halb

Original Poster:

53,012 posts

214 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all
Winner of the Miss Lovely competition for 2012, Miss (sorry that's gender specific!) Costa!
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-devon-2007909...

turbobloke

117,604 posts

291 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all
Costa's letter was also signed by Dr Sarah Wollaston, MP for Totnes, and Pruw Boswell, Mayor of Totnes. In the letter, Dr Wollaston and Ms Boswell said: "As your MP and Mayor, and speaking on behalf of the people of Totnes, we would like to thank Costa for being prepared to listen to our concerns and showing that they care." Previously, Ms Boswell said: "It's so alien to what the town's about." aka its 'alternative' image, with 'a resident community of artists, writers, therapists, musicians, and herbalists'. You have to ask why they were thinking of opening up at that location in the first place.

Halb

Original Poster:

53,012 posts

214 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all
That bit did make me smile. I'll move there when I finish me book.

Crafty old Costa? Or sweet natured loveliness itself Costa?
biggrin

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all
NIMBYism at it's worst. If the "41 independent coffee shops" in Totnes are any good Costa wouldn't survive, that's what a free market is all about. I'll bet the taxi drivers are right and most of them are anything but. What's independent about 5000 people ganging up to stop one retailer from opening? Presumably they are asking W H Smith, Edinburgh Woolen Mill and Morrisons to close down and leave town?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all
Good PR in the circumstances. It's a good brand & they have their heads screwed on..

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all
Are you local?


m8rky

2,090 posts

190 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all


I went to Totnes once,it was full of fking weirdos.

Somewhatfoolish

5,104 posts

217 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all
unrepentant said:
NIMBYism at it's worst. If the "41 independent coffee shops" in Totnes are any good Costa wouldn't survive, that's what a free market is all about. I'll bet the taxi drivers are right and most of them are anything but. What's independent about 5000 people ganging up to stop one retailer from opening? Presumably they are asking W H Smith, Edinburgh Woolen Mill and Morrisons to close down and leave town?
Exactly, it's pathetic.

You should see the attempts to get a second Tesco in in the Isle of Man. Admittedly, a lot of the opposition is for a reason I can't say because I would be sued (not by Tesco but a very litigious and very rich person), and there are other misc reasons. But much is also pure NIMBYism.

Hackney

7,444 posts

239 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all
unrepentant said:
NIMBYism at it's worst. If the "41 independent coffee shops" in Totnes are any good Costa wouldn't survive, that's what a free market is all about. I'll bet the taxi drivers are right and most of them are anything but. What's independent about 5000 people ganging up to stop one retailer from opening? Presumably they are asking W H Smith, Edinburgh Woolen Mill and Morrisons to close down and leave town?
I think that's democracy.
Presumably if there were already several newsagents there which were doing the job perfectly adequately then there would be a movement to prevent WHSmith opening in the town. Or do you find someone desperately selling you bottled water / chewing gum / chocolate when you buy a newspaper essential to the retail experience?


Jimboka said:
Good PR in the circumstances. It's a good brand & they have their heads screwed on..
It is good PR. Costa now have a reputation for considering the local environment. Whereas previously their strategy (and Tesco, Sainsbury, Starbucks etc etc etc) was simply remove choice by putting a branch wherever you look.

I believe part of the objection was that the location was right by the station, so people arriving in Totnes would go to the first place they saw and recognised by default. Rather than looking around and making a positive choice to go to a particular coffee shop.

Personally I do prefer Costa to some of the other coffee chains, but they are some distance behind the independents that I know both for coffee quality and for the design of the outlet.



martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Thursday 25th October 2012
quotequote all
unrepentant said:
NIMBYism at it's worst. If the "41 independent coffee shops" in Totnes are any good Costa wouldn't survive, that's what a free market is all about.
Except as we've already discussed on here; these massive chains don't operate in the same 'free' market as everybody else. For instance they've got the ability to pay a much lower tax rate than small independents - I know Costa actually do pay some tax here, unlike another well known coffee chain, but the point still stands. It's like when a Tesco takes out independent food retailers, it's not a myth it actually does happen. Tesco can buy in bulk bigger than all the independents combined and can sell at prices independents buy for. I can understand why there is opposition to these big stores 'taking over everywhere' because it does harm small business and it does force towns/cities to lose character and make the country even more uniform. Uniformity is more of a communist ideal than a capitalist one.

Of course we shouldn't ignore the fact that despite opposition to every Tesco/Costa et al which gets built, they always make money and the car parks are always full. The public will go to the cheapest places, specifically in terms of supermarkets but I just don't think it's much of a 'free market' if we essentially all end up at the same shop with our money all going to the same place.

unrepentant said:
I'll bet the taxi drivers are right and most of them are anything but. What's independent about 5000 people ganging up to stop one retailer from opening? Presumably they are asking W H Smith, Edinburgh Woolen Mill and Morrisons to close down and leave town?
Well retailers don't have a god given right to open where they please. This is an example of the public saying they don't want something and them actually being listened to. It's good PR for Costa because a) They look all 'caring about heritage' and b) They won't lose any money anyway. They'll still post a few bazillions in profits I'm sure.

turbobloke

117,604 posts

291 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
Well retailers don't have a god given right to open where they please.
In the same way that small player independent outlets have no god given right to stay open where they please, except perhaps in Totnes via protectionism.

fathomfive

11,263 posts

221 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
Hackney said:
unrepentant said:
NIMBYism at it's worst. If the "41 independent coffee shops" in Totnes are any good Costa wouldn't survive, that's what a free market is all about. I'll bet the taxi drivers are right and most of them are anything but. What's independent about 5000 people ganging up to stop one retailer from opening? Presumably they are asking W H Smith, Edinburgh Woolen Mill and Morrisons to close down and leave town?
I think that's democracy.
Presumably if there were already several newsagents there which were doing the job perfectly adequately then there would be a movement to prevent WHSmith opening in the town. Or do you find someone desperately selling you bottled water / chewing gum / chocolate when you buy a newspaper essential to the retail experience?


Jimboka said:
Good PR in the circumstances. It's a good brand & they have their heads screwed on..
It is good PR. Costa now have a reputation for considering the local environment. Whereas previously their strategy (and Tesco, Sainsbury, Starbucks etc etc etc) was simply remove choice by putting a branch wherever you look.

I believe part of the objection was that the location was right by the station, so people arriving in Totnes would go to the first place they saw and recognised by default. Rather than looking around and making a positive choice to go to a particular coffee shop.

Personally I do prefer Costa to some of the other coffee chains, but they are some distance behind the independents that I know both for coffee quality and for the design of the outlet.
Surely democracy is allowing Costa to open but remaining loyal to the existing coffee shops?

Cyder

7,190 posts

251 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
"The town boasts 41 independent coffee outlets and is well-known in the South West for its "alternative" image, with a resident community of artists, writers, therapists, musicians, and herbalists."

It's well known for being full of fecking weirdo's.


Camoradi

4,909 posts

287 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
I presume Costa started by opening 1 coffee shop, at which point they were entrepreneurial, and a GOOD THING. At what number of outlets did Costa become "evil big business". What criteria says Costa are not "independent"? The fact they have more than 1 outlet?

Personally I think they make great coffee, and are a British success story. If it wasn't Costa it would be Starbucks.....

They're probably wise in leaving Totnes alone though. Well done to them

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
Costa made the final decsion - not the town. Don't forget, the town LOST its battle to keep Costa out.

So, it WASN'T democracy in operation - it was clever marketing by Costa to garner some brownie points from a situation that could have worked against them. Tesco et al take note.

fido

18,938 posts

286 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
m8rky said:
I went to Totnes once,it was full of fking weirdos.
Definitely off my list of places to visit .. guessing it would make Straw Dogs look like a documentary.

"eco-group Transition Town Totnes". Haha - these wky groups appear everywhere, not just inbred 'local' towns - there's one down the road from me in Tooting. That's right, F8g Tooting.


Edited by fido on Friday 26th October 09:03

turbobloke

117,604 posts

291 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Costa made the final decision...
In splendid isolation?

They're better off out of it by the look of things, but that's not the point.

As to clever marketing, if all publicity is good publicity then Costa will be OK and so will Totnes as there'll be more tourists wanting to see the UK secular equivalent of an Amish community.

Are there lots of Steiner schools in Totnes by any chance? Uniform is usually kaftans and beads, no IT before the age of consent.

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
Lost interest in the place when the motor museum closed down frown

Podie

46,650 posts

306 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
41 independent coffee shops. 41!

2001 census (via Wikipedia) says 7,444 residents.

The town where I live has 71,838 residents, and the coffee shops don't even break into double figures!



What the fk do Totnes residents do all day, other than drink coffee?



XCP

17,764 posts

259 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
play bongos and make weird things to sell at the market. That was my impression when I visited. A poor imitation of Glastonbury IMO.