I think my thermostats are getting lazy?????
I think my thermostats are getting lazy?????
Author
Discussion

dave_s13

Original Poster:

14,032 posts

300 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
Car is an LCI (2008) 525d msport manual, 83k miles.

I loaded up the hidden OBC menu last night for the drive home which was 11.5 miles of mainly motorway, but it's all roadwork’s at the moment so restricted to 50mph. Peaked at 83deg C.

On the way in this morning it was all round the houses and after 13miles it also peaked at 83deg C but hovered around the 80 mark.

It was pretty chilly out (5deg) but I would still expect it to get up to nearer 90 - is that correct?

Car is returning a reasonable 38mpg OBD average which isn't bad by any means but I just wanted to ask if people think that maybe the stats are getting a bit lazy.

The question is

1. Do I even need to bother about it
2. If changing the stat is a good idea do you just do the EGR first, suck it and see, or do the main one at the same time.

I'd rather not spend any money unnecessarily but I'm definitely up for maintaining the DPF and al that shizzle.

Neil.D

2,878 posts

237 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
If they haven't been done before then it would seem they are becoming less efficient.

Mine were new just over a year ago and runs about 87/88C in temps u describe.

Start with the EGR one, its easy and cheap to replace as a starting point.

If it is sticking open it messes up the system as it causes the cooling system to remain open, bypassing the main 'stat that could be closed trying to raise engine temp.

Once the ambient temps drop with the onset of winter the problem will only be exacerbated.

If the EGR stat makes little or no difference then the main stat is likely to be on its way out. I had my coolant done at the same time as this is another 'lifetime fluid'.

dave_s13

Original Poster:

14,032 posts

300 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
Thanks.

Is the EGR stat best sourced from BMW only or do the likes of ECP sell the same thing in a different box, for less?

Neil.D

2,878 posts

237 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
I've only got mine from BMW as I'm a parts nerd but it had BEHR written on it so its probably easily sourced for cheaper.
I only live 1/4 mile from a main dealer so I just popped in.

dave_s13

Original Poster:

14,032 posts

300 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
Cheers Neil.

Seems they can both be had for around the 80 quid mark from BMW so it's not going to break the bank.

Job for next weekend sorted then!

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Easy way to check the EGR stat is too take it off,rinse it off and then blow through it.
If you can easily blow through it it's duff.
I recently had mine done.Egr I did myself,main stat I took to the garage as I couldn't be arsed with the faff of getting parts out of the way to access it.

CarsOrBikes

1,158 posts

215 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
For what its worth, if I was changing a thermostat on a BMW then it would be genuine only

We have had some annoying problems with so called OE stuff, which generally is good, but I don't trust them any more, no exception, not with stats.

only my2p

dave_s13

Original Poster:

14,032 posts

300 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
CarsOrBikes said:
For what its worth, if I was changing a thermostat on a BMW then it would be genuine only

We have had some annoying problems with so called OE stuff, which generally is good, but I don't trust them any more, no exception, not with stats.

only my2p
Noted.

Picking up stats and coolant from BMW on Monday morning thumbup

dave_s13

Original Poster:

14,032 posts

300 months

Saturday 3rd November 2012
quotequote all
Well I just changed them both and the car now sits at 90-95 degrees after about 5-6 miles on the motorway. Result!

Quite an easy job really, some of the online guides make it sound harder than it actually is.