Rubbish MPG 330i Msport - Normal??
Rubbish MPG 330i Msport - Normal??
Author
Discussion

R5YUP

Original Poster:

1,187 posts

244 months

Friday 26th October 2012
quotequote all
Evening folks

Thinking of ditching the e91 330i msport...... It's a cracking car, I love it - but the missus drives it 15 miles each way to work and back and only gets 20mpg! She drives like miss bloody daisy too and I'm getting tired of the constant moaning of refill costs.....

Bit of traffic to start but then A and B roads which flow ok'ish. This does seem pretty poor even for an auto. Any ideas?? Fully serviced at BMW, tyre pressures regularly checked - not sure what else I can do/check?

With a very steady constant right foot, I once averaged 29mpg on a straight motorway run - but usually much lower.

Help appreciated folks, before I'm forced buy her an oil burner!!

Cheers
RS

Ps. It's a 2006 tourer with an auto box.

EDIT: The 29mpg is my best ever effort in 20k miles. Average is 22mpg.....

Edited by R5YUP on Saturday 27th October 09:13

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Sounds about right tbh: biggish petrol engine, auto-box, short(ish) journeys: not a good recipe for great mpg.

HarryW

16,086 posts

300 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Seems high to me, all 6 pot BM's 2.5/2.8/3.0 we've had in this household have all managed 26-30 commuting and 32-36 cruising.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

244 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
On a long gentle run it should be doing 35 mpg plus, my old E9 528 Auto will do 37-40 on a run to London and back.

Huff

3,453 posts

222 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
No, looks about right for a large-ish engine, autobox, short journey starting with a crawl from cold x 2. Not shockingly-low anyway - I reckon the best you might expect for such a use is only 1-3mpg better from that cycle. It is the slow/cold/crawl element that utterly kills fuel economy.

My old 540 treated when like that (occasional commute Bath-Bristol-rtn) is about 18-20mpg. Give it a sniff of open road and it performs much, much better - 28-32 on long runs easy to attain. (24.5mpg o/a over 45Kmiles)


dace

202 posts

241 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Get the diesel version. I have just been to London and back in my 330D and averaged 51mpg!

laingy

676 posts

272 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
i get about 22mpg on a 330 auto cabriolet. That is a lot of short journeys - not really much traffic either. I think you only get high mpg on these cars if you do long motoroway journeys then you can see 30+ mpg. I have had 2 of them and a 530 - all about the same

R5YUP

Original Poster:

1,187 posts

244 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Thanks guys - and bugger!!

What I find amazing is that it's worse than my old C2S and M3 on exactly the same journeys, which frankly I find highly irritating given the relative lack of performance on offer.

I'm keeping an eye on 335d's but my guess is there won't be a huge amount in it on these short'ish trips?? Anybody done the comparison??

Drek

609 posts

196 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Plenty will tell you that short runs are not good for diesels, they'll clog up the DPF sooner than if you were on constantly long runs. Fuel consumption is likely to be no better around town on short trips than the i, you'd be better off doing what I did, buy a shed for the short local trips and save the 335i/d for the long ones.

Edited by Drek on Saturday 27th October 14:21

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
My friend has two 330i's and they both get between 19 and 21 mpg in Normal day to day use.
I don't think there is anything to worry about your mpg sounds about right.

B10BRW

360 posts

252 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Your MPG seems very high to me, I have averaged over 30 MPG in my E92 Alpina B3S BT since new, and that includes some serious Autobahn crunching smile
Last long trip to Cornwall and back averaged 32 yes

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
dace said:
Get the diesel version. I have just been to London and back in my 330D and averaged 51mpg!
This is really daft logic given the OP's post. If his wife had also just been to London and back she wouldnt be getting only 20mpg so really the fact your car does 50mpg on a long trip does not make it the answer to a question about short trips. Your car certainly wont be doing 50mpg on a short trip from cold, thats for sure!

Infact diesels are comparatively even worse from cold as they take longer to warm up.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
R5YUP said:
Evening folks

Thinking of ditching the e91 330i msport...... It's a cracking car, I love it - but the missus drives it 15 miles each way to work and back and only gets 20mpg! She drives like miss bloody daisy too and I'm getting tired of the constant moaning of refill costs.....

Bit of traffic to start but then A and B roads which flow ok'ish. This does seem pretty poor even for an auto. Any ideas?? Fully serviced at BMW, tyre pressures regularly checked - not sure what else I can do/check?

With a very steady constant right foot, I once averaged 29mpg on a straight motorway run - but usually much lower.
I have to say something sounds a bit wrong here. Short trips from cold will ruin your mpg but 15 miles and free flowing A and B roads should see you creeping towards mid 20's at least. And no more than 29mpg on a gentle Motorway run? Should be mid 30s.

pattyg

1,385 posts

258 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
steve_bmw said:
My friend has two 330i's and they both get between 19 and 21 mpg in Normal day to day use.
I don't think there is anything to worry about your mpg sounds about right.
So much for the 330i having very similar economy to the 325i. Mine averages 28mpg on an urban, short school run.

BullyB

2,344 posts

278 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
My 2004 E46 330i does about 29mpg usually. On a long trip I can get about 32mpg.
Short trips are the killer, 5 minute runs to the woods to walk the dog cost a fortune.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
pattyg said:
So much for the 330i having very similar economy to the 325i. Mine averages 28mpg on an urban, short school run.
It does have similar economy to the 325i - its certainly nothing like 7mpg better. Were you to borrow a 330i for the week you'd notice little difference. The difference between your economy and his economy is down to how you drive, what roads you drive on etc and not because he has a 330i and you have a 325i.

28mpg on urban short school runs is particularly good, mind. On urban short runs I barely got more than 30mpg from a 530d and get about 22mpg from my 530i.

Dblue

3,288 posts

231 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Have always found BM 6 cyl diesels to be a little disappointing economy wise. Whereas a 320d genuinely gives 50mpg in real world use a 335d will struggle to get 32mpg
But when I had a 330i as a temporary replacement for my 330d a couple of years ago I couldn't wait to get the diesel back. Real world mpg about 10mpg better, miles more torque and IMHO a better growly sound track.

liller

1,151 posts

200 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
sounds about right - mine never seems to go up from 22/23 mpg unless on a long run of course.

Drek

609 posts

196 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Dblue said:
Have always found BM 6 cyl diesels to be a little disappointing economy wise. Whereas a 320d genuinely gives 50mpg in real world use a 335d will struggle to get 32mpg
But when I had a 330i as a temporary replacement for my 330d a couple of years ago I couldn't wait to get the diesel back. Real world mpg about 10mpg better, miles more torque and IMHO a better growly sound track.
Not quite right, my real world is a shedload of European trips where I average 35mpg easily, probably 40 if I took it easier and more if I took it really, really easy but that would defeat the object of having a reasonably powerful car. I suspect you mean local trips to the store, taking the dog to the woods, collecting fish and chips on a Fri, that sort of thing. If you do that all the time you'll be lucky to get out of the 20s.

Dblue

3,288 posts

231 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Drek said:
Dblue said:
Have always found BM 6 cyl diesels to be a little disappointing economy wise. Whereas a 320d genuinely gives 50mpg in real world use a 335d will struggle to get 32mpg
But when I had a 330i as a temporary replacement for my 330d a couple of years ago I couldn't wait to get the diesel back. Real world mpg about 10mpg better, miles more torque and IMHO a better growly sound track.
Not quite right, my real world is a shedload of European trips where I average 35mpg easily, probably 40 if I took it easier and more if I took it really, really easy but that would defeat the object of having a reasonably powerful car. I suspect you mean local trips to the store, taking the dog to the woods, collecting fish and chips on a Fri, that sort of thing. If you do that all the time you'll be lucky to get out of the 20s.
Well yes and no. My experience is pretty extensive with both (50k miles in each case)
Mostly a 30 mile each way commute, mainly motorway and urban then often the B road route back. Good mix. 37mpg in a 330d, 32 in a 335d. They are fast , smooth, nice sounding but when you drive them with a degree of enthusiasm it hurts the consumption. A 320d is not as smooth but in real world conditions it is a lot more economical.