Discussion
I heard on the Chris Evans show (I think) that the BBC were busy doing a documentary on this story : http://www.businessinsider.com/one-british-farmer-...
It denotes that the narrator doesn't know an awful lot about the subject matter on which he is talking. I prefer people who host documenatries to be au fait with the topic.
It smacks of the likelhood that he was reading from a script cooked up by some media studies luvvie who knows zip about the history. Anyone with a smidgen of knowledge of WW2 fighter aircraft would have corrected the dumb lines that were obviously written into the script.
Watch Channel 5's "Heroes of the Skies" to see how it should be done.
It smacks of the likelhood that he was reading from a script cooked up by some media studies luvvie who knows zip about the history. Anyone with a smidgen of knowledge of WW2 fighter aircraft would have corrected the dumb lines that were obviously written into the script.
Watch Channel 5's "Heroes of the Skies" to see how it should be done.
wolves_wanderer said:
XCP said:
Pass. How does that matter?
Fockes sounds like Fokkers which is a completely different type of plane. I have the merest hint of a bum fluff moustache compared with Eric's ZZ Top'esque aircraft beard and it annoyed me. Enjoyed the program though."Yes", says the pilot, "well, these fokkers were in their Messerschmidt 109s"...
wolves_wanderer said:
Fockes sounds like Fokkers which is a completely different type of plane. I have the merest hint of a bum fluff moustache compared with Eric's ZZ Top'esque aircraft beard and it annoyed me. Enjoyed the program though.
I know nothing about German pronounciation. It didn't even register for me. I enjoyed the programme though.Yes - those ignorant of the topic wouldn't have noticed any anomalies.
And it's nothing to do with German pronunciations. It's to do with talking about the subject matter in a knowledgeable and authorative way.
Fokker was a Dutch company which supplied aircraft to the Imperial German Air Service in World War 1. Holland was a neutral country in World War 1
In World War 2, Fokker was still Dutch and Holland was invaded by the Germans in 1940. So it is highly unlikely that Fokker would supply aircraft to an enemy nation - which they didn't.
Focke-Wulf, on the the hand, was a German company which built a range of aircraft for the World War 2 Luftwaffe. Their most famous product was the Focke-Wulf Fw190 fighter - which is the aircarft referred to by Sargent in the programme. Allied airmen NEVER referred to Focke-Wulf 190s as "Fockes". They would always have called them "Focke-Wulfs, or "Fw190s". Indeed, if you had looked at the snippets of the combat reports you would have seen them written/typed inthose reports as I have described.
What possessed the programme makers to constantly refer to "Fockes" is beyond me.
And it's nothing to do with German pronunciations. It's to do with talking about the subject matter in a knowledgeable and authorative way.
Fokker was a Dutch company which supplied aircraft to the Imperial German Air Service in World War 1. Holland was a neutral country in World War 1
In World War 2, Fokker was still Dutch and Holland was invaded by the Germans in 1940. So it is highly unlikely that Fokker would supply aircraft to an enemy nation - which they didn't.
Focke-Wulf, on the the hand, was a German company which built a range of aircraft for the World War 2 Luftwaffe. Their most famous product was the Focke-Wulf Fw190 fighter - which is the aircarft referred to by Sargent in the programme. Allied airmen NEVER referred to Focke-Wulf 190s as "Fockes". They would always have called them "Focke-Wulfs, or "Fw190s". Indeed, if you had looked at the snippets of the combat reports you would have seen them written/typed inthose reports as I have described.
What possessed the programme makers to constantly refer to "Fockes" is beyond me.
Gassing Station | TV, Film, Streaming & Radio | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



