Room for a small one?
Room for a small one?
Author
Discussion

fatboy b

Original Poster:

9,665 posts

242 months

Saturday 27th October 2012
quotequote all
Thanks to PHer Ashley1111, I'm defecting from an Audi A5 to a Jag XFS Portfolio on wednesday. woohoo

Includes 1200w B&W woohoo


[/quote]

V12 Migaloo

1,116 posts

172 months

Monday 29th October 2012
quotequote all
Wise Choice....

Six Fiend

6,067 posts

241 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
Mmmmm smile

jith

2,752 posts

241 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
V12 Migaloo said:
Wise Choice....
We'll see.

J

V12 Migaloo

1,116 posts

172 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
The only advantage the A5 has over this is the MMI system which is far superior to the Jag touch screen, the A5 whilst a good car is still a front driven stretched passat or a shortened Skoda Superb, this is by far a superior stead in nearly every single way, drive, handling, ride, refinement, interior ambiance etc.
Why look like a photocopier toner salesman, when you can look like the chairman of the board (bit Mike Brewer, but I think you catch my drift)

fatboy b

Original Poster:

9,665 posts

242 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
V12 Migaloo said:
The only advantage the A5 has over this is the MMI system which is far superior to the Jag touch screen, the A5 whilst a good car is still a front driven stretched passat or a shortened Skoda Superb, this is by far a superior stead in nearly every single way, drive, handling, ride, refinement, interior ambiance etc.
Why look like a photocopier toner salesman, when you can look like the chairman of the board (bit Mike Brewer, but I think you catch my drift)
Well it's home a day early. And I agree with the above. The touchscreen is a little cumbersome, and getting off the mark isn't as good as the A5, but oh such a better car for ride & handling than the A5. 130 miles on the clock and cloud9

fatboy b

Original Poster:

9,665 posts

242 months

Tuesday 30th October 2012
quotequote all
jith said:
V12 Migaloo said:
Wise Choice....
We'll see.

J
Something you'd like to share?

V12 Migaloo

1,116 posts

172 months

Wednesday 31st October 2012
quotequote all
Congratulation, Post a few pictures, lets see it! What your view on compating both interiors, we all know Audi's ergonomics and cabin quality are top notch, be good to have an unbiased view point.

fatboy b

Original Poster:

9,665 posts

242 months

Wednesday 31st October 2012
quotequote all
As said the interface to music could be better - the Audi is great at this. Just the action of changing to a specific artist on the USB stick I have is a tad cumbersome, but I may be able to program a short cut once I have my head around it. The dashboard is a piece of sculpture, there's no comparison, the Jag is way better. Just a lovely place to be. After I played around in it at the dealer at the weekend, I got back in the Audi, and the mass of black really hit me. Don't get me wrong, it's nice, but the Jag is great.I also feel the Audi materials seem cheaper now I have spent time with the Jag.

I also prefer the Jag seats. Never thought I'd say that about a Jag, but all the electric gismos you can play with on them really sets it apart from the Audi - but the Audi was 4 1/2 years old though.

Bit stuck for pics as I leave for work & get homne in the dark, so will post a few up on Friday.

Edited by fatboy b on Wednesday 31st October 18:17

dbdb

5,032 posts

199 months

Wednesday 31st October 2012
quotequote all
I look forward to the pictures - the XF is a good looking car.

Lostprophet

2,549 posts

195 months

Thursday 1st November 2012
quotequote all
V12 Migaloo said:
Why look like a photocopier toner salesman, when you can look like the chairman of the board (bit Mike Brewer, but I think you catch my drift)
Middle management and their aspirations...

Chairman of the board.. XJ with a driver!

Lostprophet

2,549 posts

195 months

Thursday 1st November 2012
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
As said the interface to music could be better - the Audi is great at this. Just the action of changing to a specific artist on the USB stick I have is a tad cumbersome, but I may be able to program a short cut once I have my head around it. The dashboard is a piece of sculpture, there's no comparison, the Jag is way better. Just a lovely place to be. After I played around in it at the dealer at the weekend, I got back in the Audi, and the mass of black really hit me. Don't get me wrong, it's nice, but the Jag is great.I also feel the Audi materials seem cheaper now I have spent time with the Jag.

I also prefer the Jag seats. Never thought I'd say that about a Jag, but all the electric gismos you can play with on them really sets it apart from the Audi - but the Audi was 4 1/2 years old though.

Bit stuck for pics as I leave for work & get homne in the dark, so will post a few up on Friday.

Edited by fatboy b on Wednesday 31st October 18:17
Congrats!

I bought a S5 about 7 months ago... It is likely my next car will be a Jag! Love them!

V12 Migaloo

1,116 posts

172 months

Friday 2nd November 2012
quotequote all
Lostprophet said:
V12 Migaloo said:
Why look like a photocopier toner salesman, when you can look like the chairman of the board (bit Mike Brewer, but I think you catch my drift)
Middle management and their aspirations...

Chairman of the board.. XJ with a driver!
As I said Lostprophet it was a tad Mike Brewer.... Oh and when you have an XJ the last thing you want is someone else driving it!!

mph

2,373 posts

308 months

Friday 2nd November 2012
quotequote all
Nice one.

I changed from an A5 3.0TDi to an XF S Portfolio. Both new cars.

No comparison the XF was in a different league.

I should add that I haven't driven the facelifted A5.

GhostyDog

464 posts

233 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Which would be the better car

Old shape A5 or an old shape XF?

fatboy b

Original Poster:

9,665 posts

242 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Depends how old on the XF. If it were the 2.7 Jag, then I may choose the 3.0 tdi A5. But with the 3.0, I think the Jag pips the Audi at the post. The inside of course, there is no comparison.

V12 Migaloo

1,116 posts

172 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
My bro has a recent A6, albeit a 2.0. I have a 2.7 D XJ. whenever we go far away on business he would rather that we go in the jag. I suspect that even if i had the Xf the story would be the same. The ultra firm suspension and identity-kit interior of the audi just does not impress anymore.

mph

2,373 posts

308 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
GhostyDog said:
Which would be the better car

Old shape A5 or an old shape XF?
I owned both new, the Jag immediately after the Audi. Mine were an A5 3.0D sport and a Jag 3.0 diesel S portfolio.

The Jag was substantially better in every respect except fuel consumption.


fatboy b

Original Poster:

9,665 posts

242 months

Saturday 26th October 2013
quotequote all
Well a year in now. Sum-total of problems:
- The known door rattle
- A small rattle around in the dash around the steering column.

Both these fixed by Sturgess.

Other than that, it's been the best car i've owned with 21k on the clock. Simply head & shoulders above the Audis and beemers I've had. The interior still looks prestigne, and it's had a set of rear tyres at 17k ( they would have gone on longer, but i took it to Austria, so opted for a new pair).

The way this car handles is just sublime, and shows how far Jag have come in recent times. I'd say the build quality is slightly better than the German cars I've had, and the styling still miles ahead. I still sneak a crafty glance back whenever I park it anywhere.

However, it may be up for sale soon, as due to change of circumstances, I've now got a daily snotter, the the XF isn's really used for work now. I have an extended test drive in an R in a few weeks, so all being well with the massive discounts, that'll be replacing the S. biggrin

Edited by fatboy b on Saturday 26th October 08:19

Benbay001

5,861 posts

183 months

Saturday 26th October 2013
quotequote all
Thats good to hear! thumbup
Is the XFS the higher tune of the 3.0 diesel? Or the Non R 5.0?