One in 10 of the over-sixties is a millionaire
Discussion
"Two million Britons aged 60 and over are getting free bus passes and winter fuel allowance at the expense of taxpayers, despite being millionaires, a landmark study revealed today.
The report by the Intergenerational Foundation comes amid signs that David Cameron is unlikely to repeat his 2010 pledge to protect wealthy
pensioner “perks” at the next general election in 2015.
It found there were many more older millionaires in Britain than previously assumed — and that the number of retired people with independent wealth was rising rapidly.
There are now about 988,000 over-65s living in households with assets of more than £1 million. If widened to include the 60-65 age group, which includes many people who retired from public sector jobs at 60, the number rises to almost two million.
One in 10 of the over-sixties is a millionaire, once assets such as the family home are taken into account, the study claims."
http://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/millionaire-pens...
Time to look at the amount of benefits that are going to pensioners. They are already taking 60% of the welfare budget.
The report by the Intergenerational Foundation comes amid signs that David Cameron is unlikely to repeat his 2010 pledge to protect wealthy
pensioner “perks” at the next general election in 2015.
It found there were many more older millionaires in Britain than previously assumed — and that the number of retired people with independent wealth was rising rapidly.
There are now about 988,000 over-65s living in households with assets of more than £1 million. If widened to include the 60-65 age group, which includes many people who retired from public sector jobs at 60, the number rises to almost two million.
One in 10 of the over-sixties is a millionaire, once assets such as the family home are taken into account, the study claims."
http://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/millionaire-pens...
Time to look at the amount of benefits that are going to pensioners. They are already taking 60% of the welfare budget.
Not a very sensible idea.
For the last few hundred years the idea through life for the more sensible people in life has been to defer gratification to provide for a comfortable retirement.
You now want to give people the impression that they should spend it all while they can and have the state support them in their dotage, because that would be more money efficient.
Asset rich and money poor is the state of most pensioners. Force them all to go to equity release schemes and most of the money will go to the equity release and not to their offspring. Government won't see any of it either.
The one in ten over sixties who is a millionaire, is just a misleading headline to suggest that one in ten own ther own house. The headline is designed to pander to the small brained younger set who are working hard to get a foot on the housing ladder and can't see far enough to realise that their parents had to do the same.
For the last few hundred years the idea through life for the more sensible people in life has been to defer gratification to provide for a comfortable retirement.
You now want to give people the impression that they should spend it all while they can and have the state support them in their dotage, because that would be more money efficient.
Asset rich and money poor is the state of most pensioners. Force them all to go to equity release schemes and most of the money will go to the equity release and not to their offspring. Government won't see any of it either.
The one in ten over sixties who is a millionaire, is just a misleading headline to suggest that one in ten own ther own house. The headline is designed to pander to the small brained younger set who are working hard to get a foot on the housing ladder and can't see far enough to realise that their parents had to do the same.
Not having a go at your Grandad but if it encouraged him to downsize a bit and support himself then it would be a good thing all round.
Free up a large family house, save him money on bills and stop his need for a winter heating allowance and a bus pass.
I agree though £1m in total assets is not really living the high life that "millionaire" conjours up in the popular imagination.
Free up a large family house, save him money on bills and stop his need for a winter heating allowance and a bus pass.
I agree though £1m in total assets is not really living the high life that "millionaire" conjours up in the popular imagination.
julian64 said:
Not a very sensible idea.
For the last few hundred years the idea through life for the more sensible people in life has been to defer gratification to provide for a comfortable retirement.
You now want to give people the impression that they should spend it all while they can and have the state support them in their dotage, because that would be more money efficient.
Asset rich and money poor is the state of most pensioners. Force them all to go to equity release schemes and most of the money will go to the equity release and not to their offspring. Government won't see any of it either.
The one in ten over sixties who is a millionaire, is just a misleading headline to suggest that one in ten own ther own house. The headline is designed to pander to the small brained younger set who are working hard to get a foot on the housing ladder and can't see far enough to realise that their parents had to do the same.
I agree,For the last few hundred years the idea through life for the more sensible people in life has been to defer gratification to provide for a comfortable retirement.
You now want to give people the impression that they should spend it all while they can and have the state support them in their dotage, because that would be more money efficient.
Asset rich and money poor is the state of most pensioners. Force them all to go to equity release schemes and most of the money will go to the equity release and not to their offspring. Government won't see any of it either.
The one in ten over sixties who is a millionaire, is just a misleading headline to suggest that one in ten own ther own house. The headline is designed to pander to the small brained younger set who are working hard to get a foot on the housing ladder and can't see far enough to realise that their parents had to do the same.
Somewhat misleading and sensationalist, isn't it?
Firstly, on a point of pedantry, it seems to be double-counting assets. "988,000 over 60s living in households with assets of more than £1m". It's reasonable to assume that at least some of these are married to each other, and have assets of less than £2m, thus are not all millionaires.
Secondly, and more importantly, it includes the value of property. Does anyone seriously think all of those 988,000 people have a champagne lifestyle because they happen to have assets worth a million???
There are plenty of elderly people in the South East in particular who are rattling around in homes approaching £1m simply because they weren't anything like so ridiculously priced when they bought them to be their family homes 30+ years ago. The government is already going to rape the estate for at least £140k in inheritance tax when they do die, so is anyone seriously suggesting they should sell their homes now if they want a free bus pass???
Having a valuable house isn't the same thing as having a large disposable income. For a report like this to have any sort of credibility, I'd suggest that monthly disposable income is the key metric to consider.
Firstly, on a point of pedantry, it seems to be double-counting assets. "988,000 over 60s living in households with assets of more than £1m". It's reasonable to assume that at least some of these are married to each other, and have assets of less than £2m, thus are not all millionaires.
Secondly, and more importantly, it includes the value of property. Does anyone seriously think all of those 988,000 people have a champagne lifestyle because they happen to have assets worth a million???
There are plenty of elderly people in the South East in particular who are rattling around in homes approaching £1m simply because they weren't anything like so ridiculously priced when they bought them to be their family homes 30+ years ago. The government is already going to rape the estate for at least £140k in inheritance tax when they do die, so is anyone seriously suggesting they should sell their homes now if they want a free bus pass???
Having a valuable house isn't the same thing as having a large disposable income. For a report like this to have any sort of credibility, I'd suggest that monthly disposable income is the key metric to consider.
That's a misleading statistic and only serves to fuel the growing resentment towards the older generation(s) as younger people look at those ahead of them in their careers and realise it's unlikely they'll receive the same pensions, lifestyle, housing etc.
When I left university it was quite possible to walk into a reasonably well paid job and buy a house with a small deposit. Nowadays graduates have little chance to do this. The chance of a final salary pension or job for life are long gone. The people in their 60s living in big old houses with great pensions (and bus passes) haven't worked any harder they've just been born at the right time and rode the property wave.
I'm not as lucky as my parents but was certainly luckier than people leaving university now. Sure people in their 60's struggled when they were younger but they still found it easier to buy a house or have a job for life or secure a guaranteed pension than young people today will. If you have children, it's your responsibility to provide for them and give them every opportunity you can. I wouldn't dream of sitting there with a huge pension in a massive house if my children or grand children were hard working but simply suffered through no fault of their own. The concept of family involves young people looking after old people and old people helping out where they can. I'm certainly spending what I can on my children's future, just as my parents did for me.
When I left university it was quite possible to walk into a reasonably well paid job and buy a house with a small deposit. Nowadays graduates have little chance to do this. The chance of a final salary pension or job for life are long gone. The people in their 60s living in big old houses with great pensions (and bus passes) haven't worked any harder they've just been born at the right time and rode the property wave.
I'm not as lucky as my parents but was certainly luckier than people leaving university now. Sure people in their 60's struggled when they were younger but they still found it easier to buy a house or have a job for life or secure a guaranteed pension than young people today will. If you have children, it's your responsibility to provide for them and give them every opportunity you can. I wouldn't dream of sitting there with a huge pension in a massive house if my children or grand children were hard working but simply suffered through no fault of their own. The concept of family involves young people looking after old people and old people helping out where they can. I'm certainly spending what I can on my children's future, just as my parents did for me.
This.^^^^. it could almost have been written by the Chancellor himself...typical Tory divide and rule propaganda bull to evoke a 'that's not right' feeling about the groups targeted prior to attacking them. At least they've moved on from teachers though! However, can't help but note the OP includes the usual side swipe at the public sector via 'many of whom have retired from the public sector', as though million pound payouts are received by all public sector workers at 60!
Interestingly the police, that bastion of the Tory right wing since Thatcher, are never attacked, yet they have the best deal of everyone...retiring on 50% of final salary, a huge lump sum and after only 25 years 'service'!
Interestingly the police, that bastion of the Tory right wing since Thatcher, are never attacked, yet they have the best deal of everyone...retiring on 50% of final salary, a huge lump sum and after only 25 years 'service'!
Kermit power said:
Having a valuable house isn't the same thing as having a large disposable income. For a report like this to have any sort of credibility, I'd suggest that monthly disposable income is the key metric to consider.
So people with very large assets should receive state benefits while those with neither income or assets should have their benefits cut?The elderly already receive the lions share of the welfare budget. It seems logical to see if all pensioners need state subsidies.
AJS- said:
Not having a go at your Grandad but if it encouraged him to downsize a bit and support himself then it would be a good thing all round.
Free up a large family house, save him money on bills and stop his need for a winter heating allowance and a bus pass.
I agree though £1m in total assets is not really living the high life that "millionaire" conjours up in the popular imagination.
The snag is that housing tends not to be very mixed in the UK, so to downsize he'd likely have to move away from where he lives now.Free up a large family house, save him money on bills and stop his need for a winter heating allowance and a bus pass.
I agree though £1m in total assets is not really living the high life that "millionaire" conjours up in the popular imagination.
I've said this before, but I do think it's a crying shame that so many good sized family houses are lived in by single older occupants.
As for older people not having much cash, I'm sure it's a mixed picture, but I've looked after the finances for a couple of older people and I'm aware of the position of several others and it's frankly astonishing how much money they can have. My own mother had a 6 figure sum in various deposit accounts - I expected her to have had a few bob and wouldn't have been surprised at £10-15K, but I never dreamed she's have £100K+.
As for the public sector - the big thing there is they don't need to save, they can rely on a decent income coming in until they die. If you get a couple who are both on such a pension, and were in reasonable level jobs, they have a very nice combined income.
AJS- said:
Not having a go at your Grandad but if it encouraged him to downsize a bit and support himself then it would be a good thing all round.
You mean that by buying private property and paying off a mortgage, probably through periods of higher interest rates, and paying into a pension plan through the working life isn't supporting himself? With a heavy inheritance tax bill in the future.Views like this is why we're going to end up in a lot more mess that we're in now.
Myths and more myths.
The report is devisive and was intended to be so.
But where did this 'had it all easy' belief come from? When I bought my house in 1970 I needed to put down two years' gross wages as a deposit and then could only borrow 2.5 times annual income. I had to sell my TV and car, walk into town, a distance of around 3 miles, to shop. Socialising consisted of going out for a walk and going rounds a friend's house with a bottle. We did not have it easy. I worked all but three days a month and did as much overtime as I could manage and manufacture. If people think that's easy, then their definition varies from mine.
My parents used to provide us with food parcels in the final two weeks of the month.
The reason houses were cheaper in real terms in those days was the lack of buyers. The regs limited the number. But the free market proved inviting and banks would lend on joint income and then well over 2.5 times. The answer, to me, seems easy enough. Increase the number of houses or decrease the number of buyers.
For the two years I was engaged to, but not living with, my now wife, I put every spare penny away. Remember, it took us two years to save the deposit, which meant no iPad, no iPhone, no clubbing. I went to ballroom dancing lessons as they were free. We had all second hand furniture apart from that which was bought us. Honeymoon in Devon.
Living standards should improve as the years go by but give those of us who made sacrifices to get what we have a break. I paid >12% gross in real terms into my pension and now it seems I don't deserve it. I also invested in a bigger house than I needed with the intention, now realised, of downsizing.
I'm not suggesting that free bus passes are an essential. Indeed, although I have a pass I haven't used it for months. I walk into town three times a week. But talk to those who provide buses. If the consessions go then so will many routes. It is a form of subsidy. The town centre round my way is packed with the older generation during the day. They don't spend much but they do buy coffees and go into Waitrose for bits. They are keeping the high street open down my way.
I'm not a millionaire by any reckoning. But I can't see how someone asset rich/cash poor could be seen as one by anyone sensible. I remember reading recently that many OAPs have interest only mortgages and these will end at the age of 70(?). This gives rise to lots of hope for the future.
And please, on the subject of myths:
Police never attacked? Is this some kind of joke. 50% pay after 25 years. Oh, dear.
The report is devisive and was intended to be so.
But where did this 'had it all easy' belief come from? When I bought my house in 1970 I needed to put down two years' gross wages as a deposit and then could only borrow 2.5 times annual income. I had to sell my TV and car, walk into town, a distance of around 3 miles, to shop. Socialising consisted of going out for a walk and going rounds a friend's house with a bottle. We did not have it easy. I worked all but three days a month and did as much overtime as I could manage and manufacture. If people think that's easy, then their definition varies from mine.
My parents used to provide us with food parcels in the final two weeks of the month.
The reason houses were cheaper in real terms in those days was the lack of buyers. The regs limited the number. But the free market proved inviting and banks would lend on joint income and then well over 2.5 times. The answer, to me, seems easy enough. Increase the number of houses or decrease the number of buyers.
For the two years I was engaged to, but not living with, my now wife, I put every spare penny away. Remember, it took us two years to save the deposit, which meant no iPad, no iPhone, no clubbing. I went to ballroom dancing lessons as they were free. We had all second hand furniture apart from that which was bought us. Honeymoon in Devon.
Living standards should improve as the years go by but give those of us who made sacrifices to get what we have a break. I paid >12% gross in real terms into my pension and now it seems I don't deserve it. I also invested in a bigger house than I needed with the intention, now realised, of downsizing.
I'm not suggesting that free bus passes are an essential. Indeed, although I have a pass I haven't used it for months. I walk into town three times a week. But talk to those who provide buses. If the consessions go then so will many routes. It is a form of subsidy. The town centre round my way is packed with the older generation during the day. They don't spend much but they do buy coffees and go into Waitrose for bits. They are keeping the high street open down my way.
I'm not a millionaire by any reckoning. But I can't see how someone asset rich/cash poor could be seen as one by anyone sensible. I remember reading recently that many OAPs have interest only mortgages and these will end at the age of 70(?). This gives rise to lots of hope for the future.
And please, on the subject of myths:
Lotusevoraboy said:
Interestingly the police, that bastion of the Tory right wing since Thatcher, are never attacked, yet they have the best deal of everyone...retiring on 50% of final salary, a huge lump sum and after only 25 years 'service'!
Get a grip. Do you enjoy being manipulated?Police never attacked? Is this some kind of joke. 50% pay after 25 years. Oh, dear.
Fittster said:
Time to look at the amount of benefits that are going to pensioners. They are already taking 60% of the welfare budget.
You conveniently overlook the fact that most of them, especially those who have ended up as millionaires, have more than paid for the 'benefits' they get, and are still paying.Unlike the scrounging, non contributing shysters we have soaking up the taxpayers hard earned.
Fittster said:
Kermit power said:
Having a valuable house isn't the same thing as having a large disposable income. For a report like this to have any sort of credibility, I'd suggest that monthly disposable income is the key metric to consider.
So people with very large assets should receive state benefits while those with neither income or assets should have their benefits cut?The elderly already receive the lions share of the welfare budget. It seems logical to see if all pensioners need state subsidies.
If you make them sell it now, you'll lose out on a lot of that, especially if they move in to rented accommodation.
Last time I looked, free bus passes and winter fuel allowances cost rather less than that.
REALIST123 said:
Fittster said:
Time to look at the amount of benefits that are going to pensioners. They are already taking 60% of the welfare budget.
You conveniently overlook the fact that most of them, especially those who have ended up as millionaires, have more than paid for the 'benefits' they get, and are still paying.Unlike the scrounging, non contributing shysters we have soaking up the taxpayers hard earned.
Kermit power said:
Fittster said:
Kermit power said:
Having a valuable house isn't the same thing as having a large disposable income. For a report like this to have any sort of credibility, I'd suggest that monthly disposable income is the key metric to consider.
So people with very large assets should receive state benefits while those with neither income or assets should have their benefits cut?The elderly already receive the lions share of the welfare budget. It seems logical to see if all pensioners need state subsidies.
If you make them sell it now, you'll lose out on a lot of that, especially if they move in to rented accommodation.
Last time I looked, free bus passes and winter fuel allowances cost rather less than that.
Do you think the state should give out money to people regardless of their need for it?
Deva Link
Really? Depending how you define the same area, most places I lived have pretty decent spread of homes within say a 10 mile radius.
Captain Slow
By support themselves I mean not requiring money from the state. Yes they paid into pensions and I don't begrudge them that, but I don't see why they need all these other allowances as well if they're able to pay their own way.
Really? Depending how you define the same area, most places I lived have pretty decent spread of homes within say a 10 mile radius.
Captain Slow
By support themselves I mean not requiring money from the state. Yes they paid into pensions and I don't begrudge them that, but I don't see why they need all these other allowances as well if they're able to pay their own way.
Fittster said:
"Two million Britons aged 60 and over are getting free bus passes and winter fuel allowance at the expense of taxpayers, despite being millionaires, a landmark study revealed today.
The report by the Intergenerational Foundation comes amid signs that David Cameron is unlikely to repeat his 2010 pledge to protect wealthy
pensioner “perks” at the next general election in 2015.
It found there were many more older millionaires in Britain than previously assumed — and that the number of retired people with independent wealth was rising rapidly.
There are now about 988,000 over-65s living in households with assets of more than £1 million. If widened to include the 60-65 age group, which includes many people who retired from public sector jobs at 60, the number rises to almost two million.
One in 10 of the over-sixties is a millionaire, once assets such as the family home are taken into account, the study claims."
http://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/millionaire-pens...
Time to look at the amount of benefits that are going to pensioners. They are already taking 60% of the welfare budget.
Your last para is very ill considered, have you overlooked the fact that it is 'our generation' that have paid into the system over a lifetime. All that would be achieved by increasing taxes and removing benefits (or one /other) is drive this group abroad, taking their wealth with them.The report by the Intergenerational Foundation comes amid signs that David Cameron is unlikely to repeat his 2010 pledge to protect wealthy
pensioner “perks” at the next general election in 2015.
It found there were many more older millionaires in Britain than previously assumed — and that the number of retired people with independent wealth was rising rapidly.
There are now about 988,000 over-65s living in households with assets of more than £1 million. If widened to include the 60-65 age group, which includes many people who retired from public sector jobs at 60, the number rises to almost two million.
One in 10 of the over-sixties is a millionaire, once assets such as the family home are taken into account, the study claims."
http://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/millionaire-pens...
Time to look at the amount of benefits that are going to pensioners. They are already taking 60% of the welfare budget.
These statistical reports are just that.
Imagine the political fallout if the Government went into full attack on the pensioners! how many voters would go for that Party in the next election - bribery? without a doubt.
The neighbour across the street is selling his house for £925,000. Plenty of old people around here 'rattling' around in their tiny 3 bedroomed Victorian cottages with a tiny garden. I'd love to end my days in this house as a pensioner after working all my life since I was 17. Unfortunately I won't as my private pension is bu66ered so the house will have to go eventually and I will have to move to another part of the country where housing is a lot cheaper.
Shame as I grew up around here
This is like that 'Mansion' tax that the fool Clegg has been barking on about. Just because your house happens to be worth £1,000,000 doesn't mean you have much money.
Governments! if you want to tax people fairly, RAISE THE INCOME TAX and forget all these other silly and unfair taxes.
Aye! but for some reason no government wants to be seen to do this.
Shame as I grew up around here

This is like that 'Mansion' tax that the fool Clegg has been barking on about. Just because your house happens to be worth £1,000,000 doesn't mean you have much money.
Governments! if you want to tax people fairly, RAISE THE INCOME TAX and forget all these other silly and unfair taxes.
Aye! but for some reason no government wants to be seen to do this.
Fittster said:
Do you think the state should give out money to people regardless of their need for it?
In the thread which talked about Child Benefit it is a form of tax refund, apparently.The issue illustrates the split personality of the benefits system. Is it a return for your contribution, (insurance) or just welfare for based on need?
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


