The reporting on the avoidance of corporation tax.
Discussion
Lots of news stories around at the moment ref companies such as starbucks avoiding corporation tax.
Now this really pisses me off, not the avoidance of the tax, because it's legal I in fact applaud the ingenuousness of there accountants.
It's the way it's being reported that is pissing me off, how it's suddenly a big surprise etc, and how immoral it is.
Public spending needs to be reduced, not more taxes collected.
Just me?
Now this really pisses me off, not the avoidance of the tax, because it's legal I in fact applaud the ingenuousness of there accountants.
It's the way it's being reported that is pissing me off, how it's suddenly a big surprise etc, and how immoral it is.
Public spending needs to be reduced, not more taxes collected.
Just me?
martin84 said:
With the Prime Minister describing it as 'morally repugnant' and his Chancellor following suit what do you expect? Osborne sure seemed surprised by the sheer scale of tax avoidance and he's the f
king Chancellor.
I think that says more about the chancellor than the avoidance of tax.
king Chancellor.Bertrum said:
Lots of news stories around at the moment ref companies such as starbucks avoiding corporation tax.
Now this really pisses me off, not the avoidance of the tax, because it's legal I in fact applaud the ingenuousness of there accountants.
It's the way it's being reported that is pissing me off, how it's suddenly a big surprise etc, and how immoral it is.
Public spending needs to be reduced, not more taxes collected.
Just me?
The UK Goverment will spend what it spends, and therefore needs to raise what it raises.Now this really pisses me off, not the avoidance of the tax, because it's legal I in fact applaud the ingenuousness of there accountants.
It's the way it's being reported that is pissing me off, how it's suddenly a big surprise etc, and how immoral it is.
Public spending needs to be reduced, not more taxes collected.
Just me?
Foreign owned companies who avoid or evade UK tax are not doing us (UK taxpayers) any favours by doing so. They're funnelling the money abroad, and it would be better for the rest of us UK taxpayers if they paid their fair share; as it would reduce the tax burden on those of us who play by 'spirit' of the rules.
I am also aware that they have an obligation to their shareholders to pay as little as legally possible, and I'd expect nothing else. However we need to change the tax laws to make them "Fair" (according to my definition of fair, which I've not fully crystallised), and then compliance will follow those and the company ends up paying it's "Fair Share".
However, so long as they're complying with the law then they're paying their legal share, and the law should be changed to bring "Fair" and "Legal" a bit closer together IMO. But I do want to see them paying a "Fair" share ultimately.
Fair is not the same as Legal. I don't blame the companies for paying as little as possible under the Law. But the point is that the Law is not Fair as things stand. So it WILL be better when these companies pay their Fair Share, and they will do this once the Tax Laws are reformed to bring the Legally Required payment up to something which is considered to be Fair.
Fairness is important in a tax system.
The problem is that everyone's definition of Fair is different. A Tory vs. a Lib Dem will have different ideas of what Fair means. (e.g. is it fair that rich people pay a bigger % as they have 'more than enough money'? Or is it fair that both rich and poor pay the same %age of income? Or would it be fair if everyone contributed a set amount each, and earnings above this are tax free?)
In this particular case of Starbucks, my point is that my personal view on what's Fair dictates that a Company should NOT be able to funnel it's profits overseas without paying an amount of tax on them in the UK which is comparable with UK owned companies operating at a similar underlying level of profitability. (I.e. that their ability to use mechanisms to reduce UK profit and increase overseas profit is Not Fair, by my definition.) There are a number of people who share this view with me.
The Company is doing the right thing if we assume it's operating within the law. BUT the point is that the Tax Laws are unfair by my definition. So in calling for Companies to pay a Fair Rate of Tax, I'm actually calling for a change in the Law on Tax which can then be enforced.
I'm not talking about companies paying more than they're legally obliged to - please understand that. I'm asking for the law to be changed to set the amount they are legally obliged to pay to be something I (and others) consider to be Fair in the wider context of the economy.
I totally agree that it isn't fair what they are doing.
My irritation is with ther journalists and there reporting on the matter. The use of the words of immoral and scam paint a scewed picture. As they are within the law.
I think I would feel better if they were targeting the tax system which as you rightly state is unfair.
On that point if you had a tax rate of 20% for all regardless, think of the money it would save in policing/administering. And the revenue it would create as people would pay their fair share. And stop actively avoiding it.
My irritation is with ther journalists and there reporting on the matter. The use of the words of immoral and scam paint a scewed picture. As they are within the law.
I think I would feel better if they were targeting the tax system which as you rightly state is unfair.
On that point if you had a tax rate of 20% for all regardless, think of the money it would save in policing/administering. And the revenue it would create as people would pay their fair share. And stop actively avoiding it.
Daily Mail recently ran an article on a couple of companies, one of which "only" paid £4m IIRC on a £6bn turnover.
Usual journalist phrases were trotted out about how immoral it was.
A quick check on companies house reveals the DM received a tax rebate of several million despite turning almost £2bn.
Usual journalist phrases were trotted out about how immoral it was.
A quick check on companies house reveals the DM received a tax rebate of several million despite turning almost £2bn.

Turnover means nothing. Profits are what CT is charged on. If a company has a turnover of £1 million but a loss of £2 million. it will pay no CT.
However, what big companies are doing is turning a genuinely profitable UK business into a seemingly loss making operation for tax purposes. They do this by having a holding or management company established in a low or no tax jurisdiction. The overseas company charges the UK opperation a management fee thereby creating the loss. Effectively, they are ensuring that the losses occur in the higher tax regime and the profits in the low tax regime.
It is an artificial - but legal - construct.
However, what big companies are doing is turning a genuinely profitable UK business into a seemingly loss making operation for tax purposes. They do this by having a holding or management company established in a low or no tax jurisdiction. The overseas company charges the UK opperation a management fee thereby creating the loss. Effectively, they are ensuring that the losses occur in the higher tax regime and the profits in the low tax regime.
It is an artificial - but legal - construct.
Bertrum said:
I totally agree that it isn't fair what they are doing.
My irritation is with ther journalists and there reporting on the matter. The use of the words of immoral and scam paint a scewed picture. As they are within the law.
I think I would feel better if they were targeting the tax system which as you rightly state is unfair.
On that point if you had a tax rate of 20% for all regardless, think of the money it would save in policing/administering. And the revenue it would create as people would pay their fair share. And stop actively avoiding it.
Cool, glad you understand my point.My irritation is with ther journalists and there reporting on the matter. The use of the words of immoral and scam paint a scewed picture. As they are within the law.
I think I would feel better if they were targeting the tax system which as you rightly state is unfair.
On that point if you had a tax rate of 20% for all regardless, think of the money it would save in policing/administering. And the revenue it would create as people would pay their fair share. And stop actively avoiding it.
Regards the "flat 20% rate". I think it's important to understand that there's two purposes to a tax system, 1 to raise revenue, and 2 to influence behaviour. Whether we think that using the tax system to influence behaviour or not is a related, but separate discussion. So on the basis that it's how it's used around the world, lets assume we continue to encourage good behaviour via the tax system:
For example, if we think that people driving more economical cars is a good idea, then we give them lower VED than less economical cars. If we think that investment in R&D is a good think, then we accelerate the tax relief, etc. However, it's the poor drafting of such rules which gets us into a mess.
For example, we might decide that if there's an idea that if someone with spare cash we'd like to encourage them to invest in small businesses. To help them get off the ground, provide jobs and invent products which can one day can be exported and bring wealth into the country. Sounds like a "good thing"? Ok, so we provide tax relief on investments in shares and if those shares rise in value then we tax the gain lower than something like normal salary income, after all there has to be an incentive for the investor. However, those same rules which encourage investment in small businesses can also be used by exec's at big companies to have their remuneration in shares or options, and hence legally sidestep (avoid) income tax.
So the question is how to we encourage "good" and desirable behaviour via the tax system, but without leaving it open to abuse? It's a hard one, because I personally believe that the idea of using the tax system to influence behaviour is not entirely a bad one, we just need those who make the rules to be a bit better at drafting them so that "what the rules say" is precisely the same as "what they intended the rules to say"... because clever interpretations by lawyers is where many of these "loopholes" come from.
(A note on "loopholes". Someone once told me that there's no such think as a "loophole" it's just "the rules". Same as that F1 engineer who denied the existance of "the spirit of the rules" since there's "only the rules". To an extent I agree, because those companies/people and in F1, engineers, who have to work within the rules don't really give a damn what the spirit was. Since they are acting for themselves, as one would naturally expect, they are only concerned with legal vs. illegal. They don't care what the original intention was and as a result they see no such thing as loopholes. However, I'd personally define a loophole to be an area of the rules where the intention is different from the implementation. And I believe the onus should be on the rule makers to draft their rules 'properly' in the first place. The onus is NOT upon the companies (and engineers) who optimise their own position within the letter of the rules - because that is their right to do so, legally. As a wise man once said, "Don't hate the player, hate the game." Or in this case, "hate the rule makers of the game".)
Goodnight!
What is routinely ignored in the bow-wave of righteous indignation on this topic is that multi-national businesses (with obligations to shareholders) see tax regimes as just another part of their supply chain - they will go for the one that delivers them greatest shareholder value. If therefore, as an economy, you want Starbucks paying rent to landlords, purchasing energy, employing staff etc, etc, you have to pitch to them a tax regime that is appealing to them. CT is a commercial balancing act, pure and simple.
Personally I think if you make money in the UK then you should pay tax in the UK and any loopholes preventing that happening should be closed. My problem is with the Government and tax code rather than the companies in question - although I don't like companies who project a perfect ethical image and then engage in tax dodging, legal or otherwise.
What I don't buy though is the argument that our tax rate is too high and if it were lower the likes of Starbucks would happily pay it. Right now they're able to pay £0 to the UK Government in Corperation Tax, so what tax rate would encourage them to give that up?
What I don't buy though is the argument that our tax rate is too high and if it were lower the likes of Starbucks would happily pay it. Right now they're able to pay £0 to the UK Government in Corperation Tax, so what tax rate would encourage them to give that up?
The story isn't really that these companies aren't paying any tax, but rather that HMRC is at best acquiescent and at worst complicit.
AIUI they regularly come to "settlements" with companies whereby they agree to accept substantially lower levels of tax from those companies to avoid the effort of an audit. That's not how it's supposed to work; the gamekeeper shouldn't become a poacher.
Companies aren't doing their jobs properly if they don't minimise their tax liabilities frankly. But our tax collectors should be making sure that what tax these companies are liable for is actually being paid.
AIUI they regularly come to "settlements" with companies whereby they agree to accept substantially lower levels of tax from those companies to avoid the effort of an audit. That's not how it's supposed to work; the gamekeeper shouldn't become a poacher.
Companies aren't doing their jobs properly if they don't minimise their tax liabilities frankly. But our tax collectors should be making sure that what tax these companies are liable for is actually being paid.
Well that's another example of the big boys playing by different rules to the little guys. The stories of large companies getting 'deals' and paying lower tax bills should be reported IMO.
If the local gardener cooks his books even slightly, HMRC come down like a tonne of bricks. In the case of big corperates, HMRC are happy to write off millions in some cases.
If the local gardener cooks his books even slightly, HMRC come down like a tonne of bricks. In the case of big corperates, HMRC are happy to write off millions in some cases.
martin84 said:
Well that's another example of the big boys playing by different rules to the little guys. The stories of large companies getting 'deals' and paying lower tax bills should be reported IMO.
If the local gardener cooks his books even slightly, HMRC come down like a tonne of bricks. In the case of big corperates, HMRC are happy to write off millions in some cases.
There is an industry around helping smaller companies optimising their tax position. A common one (of many) is claiming for R&D. The rules are quite specific but some of the solutions I have seen from professional 'advisors' are little more than blatent fabrications of the truth. If the local gardener cooks his books even slightly, HMRC come down like a tonne of bricks. In the case of big corperates, HMRC are happy to write off millions in some cases.
Edited by bga on Thursday 1st November 01:01
bga said:
There is an industry around helping smaller companies optimising their tax position.
That's not what's happening with the big companies though. HMRC and the CFOs of publicly listed firms have a "cosy chat" over coffee, a number is written on a napkin, hands are shaken, a cheque is sent in the post, and that's the end of things for that year.We need to massively simplify the tax system. I've no problem with companies paying no more than they are legally obliged to - in fact I would rather they paid that and no more. What I can see as a big problem is that if I start an independent coffee shop in the UK I'm competing with the likes of Starbucks who straight away have a massive cost advantage over me.
Would we be better off if they were forced to pay more? If they paid it then yes, but if we just ended up with more expensive coffee and less choice due to companies choosing not to be located here, would we still be better off? No.
Simplify it. I would like to see corporation tax scrapped altogether as it leads to such complex shenanigans to avoid it, and with the far more collectable VAT, payroll and local taxes it seems to be a tax that disproportionately hits small businesses.
Quite apart from the inequity, the amount of time intelligent accountants must spend on moving things around the place to lower tax jurisdictions represents a massive inefficiency.
Would we be better off if they were forced to pay more? If they paid it then yes, but if we just ended up with more expensive coffee and less choice due to companies choosing not to be located here, would we still be better off? No.
Simplify it. I would like to see corporation tax scrapped altogether as it leads to such complex shenanigans to avoid it, and with the far more collectable VAT, payroll and local taxes it seems to be a tax that disproportionately hits small businesses.
Quite apart from the inequity, the amount of time intelligent accountants must spend on moving things around the place to lower tax jurisdictions represents a massive inefficiency.
mrmr96 said:
... a Company should NOT be able to funnel it's profits overseas without paying an amount of tax on them in the UK which is comparable with UK owned companies operating at a similar underlying level of profitability....
i agree with this but imo the best way to level the playing field is to lower corporation tax rates to that of the competition, ie 12.5%, or such a level where the costs of such accounting wheezes make them not worth the hassle. you end transfer pricing and reinsurance and you can kiss goodbye to future industrial FDI and hundreds of thousands of jobs. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-01-25/made-in-b...fbrs said:
i agree with this but imo the best way to level the playing field is to lower corporation tax rates to that of the competition, ie 12.5%, or such a level where the costs of such accounting wheezes make them not worth the hassle. you end transfer pricing and reinsurance and you can kiss goodbye to future industrial FDI and hundreds of thousands of jobs. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-01-25/made-in-b...
That's exactly what the corporations want - a race to the bottom.Keep the rates where they are, and make everything else about doing business in the UK a good reason for getting taxed here.
Eric Mc said:
Turnover means nothing. Profits are what CT is charged on. If a company has a turnover of £1 million but a loss of £2 million. it will pay no CT.
However, what big companies are doing is turning a genuinely profitable UK business into a seemingly loss making operation for tax purposes. They do this by having a holding or management company established in a low or no tax jurisdiction. The overseas company charges the UK opperation a management fee thereby creating the loss. Effectively, they are ensuring that the losses occur in the higher tax regime and the profits in the low tax regime.
It is an artificial - but legal - construct.
You know that and I know that, but it doesn't stop the likes of the DM reporting in the way that they do (i.e. reference of tax paid vs. turnover). However, what big companies are doing is turning a genuinely profitable UK business into a seemingly loss making operation for tax purposes. They do this by having a holding or management company established in a low or no tax jurisdiction. The overseas company charges the UK opperation a management fee thereby creating the loss. Effectively, they are ensuring that the losses occur in the higher tax regime and the profits in the low tax regime.
It is an artificial - but legal - construct.
It makes for more sensational headlines and unfortunately there's a large swathe of the population who haven't got the first clue regarding how tax calculated, corporation or otherwise.
Pints said:
You know that and I know that, but it doesn't stop the likes of the DM reporting in the way that they do (i.e. reference of tax paid vs. turnover).
It makes for more sensational headlines and unfortunately there's a large swathe of the population who haven't got the first clue regarding how tax calculated, corporation or otherwise.
There are a worrying number of the people on this thread, let alone the general population, who seem to have very little idea about Corporation Tax, and how it works.It makes for more sensational headlines and unfortunately there's a large swathe of the population who haven't got the first clue regarding how tax calculated, corporation or otherwise.
If the Government are prepared to put easily malleable rules in place, they really shouldn't be surprised that companies take advantage of them. Change the rules if you like, make it more stringent, but don't blame people for playing by the rules that you set!
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


