Can someone answer a lifelong question?
Discussion
Rufus said:
I know I should know the answer to this at my grand old age and having owned an automatic watch since I was 16 (40+ years now!!) but why, when you sleep with one on, do they run so much faster than when you wear it when you are awake?
When you are awake, your watch is moved into lots of different positions, but as you sleep, it remains in one place for long periods of time, similar to how a pocket watch sits in a pocket. Being in one position sets the balance off against gravity, and can cause accuracy problems. This very reason is why the tourbillon was invented.AndrewWF said:
Rufus said:
I know I should know the answer to this at my grand old age and having owned an automatic watch since I was 16 (40+ years now!!) but why, when you sleep with one on, do they run so much faster than when you wear it when you are awake?
When you are awake, your watch is moved into lots of different positions, but as you sleep, it remains in one place for long periods of time, similar to how a pocket watch sits in a pocket. Being in one position sets the balance off against gravity, and can cause accuracy problems. This very reason is why the tourbillon was invented.Tanguero said:
The other factor and one that may have much more effect is thermal isochronisim. If the watch is under the duvet with a 250 BTU heater (your sleeping body) it will be a lot hotter than it is during the day. This can make it run significantly faster.
Modern hairsprings are temperature compensated (and COSC watches tested at different temperatures), and in any case, heat would cause the watch run to run slow, not fastAndrewWF said:
Tanguero said:
The other factor and one that may have much more effect is thermal isochronisim. If the watch is under the duvet with a 250 BTU heater (your sleeping body) it will be a lot hotter than it is during the day. This can make it run significantly faster.
Modern hairsprings are temperature compensated (and COSC watches tested at different temperatures), and in any case, heat would cause the watch run to run slow, not fastIf the watch has a bi-metallic temperature compensated balance, whether it advances or retards with increasing temperature will depend on there on the balance wheel the weighting screws are.
On a modern plain balance where that isn't a factor the change in viscosity of the oil on the balance pivot can result in an increase in amplitude, occasionally to such an extent in a high amplitude movement that it will suffer from "knocking the banking" where the roller jewel makes contact with the outside of the palette fork, which can result in a considerable gain. I have a watch that will knock and gain about 6 minutes per hour at 40 degrees! Mind you, if the OP is getting that hot in bed at night then his watch gaining a few minutes is probably the least of his worries!
It's true that the position at night will affect the time keeping, but assuming the watch is correctly adjusted for average position, the only positions that will make it gain will be dial up or dial down, where only the ends of the pivots are bearing on the cap jewels, hence less friction. In any other position there is more friction on the pivots from the side of the jewel hole so will be slower. I would have thought that the chances of a watch worn in bed being still enough in a dial up or down position to make a noticeable difference would be slim, but that is just a guess.
Rufus, how much do you find your watch gaining when its worn at night and what watch is it?
Tanguero said:
Rufus, how much do you find your watch gaining when its worn at night and what watch is it?
All very interesting. The watch I have in mind is a 1960s Rolex Oyster which tends to gain about 5 or 6 minutes. My daughters LadyDate does the same when she wears it in bed; haven't tried my Milgauss in bed yet but might tonight just out of curiosity...Rufus said:
Tanguero said:
Rufus, how much do you find your watch gaining when its worn at night and what watch is it?
All very interesting. The watch I have in mind is a 1960s Rolex Oyster which tends to gain about 5 or 6 minutes. My daughters LadyDate does the same when she wears it in bed; haven't tried my Milgauss in bed yet but might tonight just out of curiosity...The dial up position means that the balance wheel is turning on the tip of it's lower pivot end on against the cap jewel and the top pivot simply floating in the jewel hole. This has the least possible friction for the balance wheel and means that it should run faster in that position than in any other.
Rufus said:
All very interesting. The watch I have in mind is a 1960s Rolex Oyster which tends to gain about 5 or 6 minutes. My daughters LadyDate does the same when she wears it in bed; haven't tried my Milgauss in bed yet but might tonight just out of curiosity...
5 or 6 minutes seems an awfully large amount...According to my tame watchmaker in an email regarding one of my early (1955) watches: "Gaining loads points to a very feeble amplitude, and, with a bit of luck, cleaning and a new mainspring will do the trick."
5 or 6 seconds would be acceptable (even under COSC) but minutes suggests that a look by an expert may be prudent.
Either a very low amplitude, so that the hairspring is barely operating at all and the roller jewel is not clearing the palette fork, or a very large amplitude so that the roller jewel is knocking the back of the fork. Both effectively mean that the balance ceases to operate as if it is freely sprung and will result in large gains.
Waking up in the middle of the night and putting the watch on a timing machine would tell you which for certain, but my guess would be too large an amplitude if the watch keeps good time otherwise.
Waking up in the middle of the night and putting the watch on a timing machine would tell you which for certain, but my guess would be too large an amplitude if the watch keeps good time otherwise.
Thinking about it, if you are a very restless sleeper this could possibly explain it.
There is an old watchmakers trick to set a non-hacking watch to the exact second which involves giving it a twisting shake to force it to knock on the banking by giving the balance wheel a little extra momentum. Apparently when done properly it can make any watch run at quite a bit faster while it is being shaken. Certainly swinging your arm at just the right speed while walking can make a watch gain significantly if it already has a fairly large amplitude.
There is an old watchmakers trick to set a non-hacking watch to the exact second which involves giving it a twisting shake to force it to knock on the banking by giving the balance wheel a little extra momentum. Apparently when done properly it can make any watch run at quite a bit faster while it is being shaken. Certainly swinging your arm at just the right speed while walking can make a watch gain significantly if it already has a fairly large amplitude.
Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


