Christopher Tappin pleads guilty to selling missile parts
Discussion
After much moaning hoo hah here and elsewhere about this extradition, Mr Tappin has copped a plea.
http://news.sky.com/story/1005807/brit-admits-sell...
http://news.sky.com/story/1005807/brit-admits-sell...
Breadvan72 said:
After much moaning hoo hah here and elsewhere about this extradition, Mr Tappin has copped a plea.
http://news.sky.com/story/1005807/brit-admits-sell...
So he'll serve 33 months in the UK, rather than a bazillion-trillion in the US if he'd pled not guilty. Even you would have had to consider copping a plea there with the consequences... http://news.sky.com/story/1005807/brit-admits-sell...

In all honesty, you'd do the same.
Trials in the US would, for this sort of thing, typically not get to court in less than three years, and then there's a worrying problem that you might actually be found guilty and imprisoned for a decade or more. There's a real possibility that he'd die in prison.
On the other hand, he can cop a plea, spend 12 months (maximum) in a UK open prison.....regardless of guilt, it's a pragmatic decision.
Trials in the US would, for this sort of thing, typically not get to court in less than three years, and then there's a worrying problem that you might actually be found guilty and imprisoned for a decade or more. There's a real possibility that he'd die in prison.
On the other hand, he can cop a plea, spend 12 months (maximum) in a UK open prison.....regardless of guilt, it's a pragmatic decision.
I work in electronics manufacturing, the Americans have so many restricted parts,and keep changing them every five minutes that I could see this happening to lots of people, including me, I’m not talking about leading edge technologies or bits for bombs, and I’m talking trivial components that you wouldn’t think twice about.
Fourtunatly I don't have any customers in the Middle East...............that I know about
Fourtunatly I don't have any customers in the Middle East...............that I know about
s3fella said:
I thinks he's got a blinding deal tbh. It seemed a fairly clear cut case.
Quite. I'd have loved to hear his explanation to the court of "possible alternative uses for these batteries which are completely innocent".Somewhat trickier to slip out of than Forgemasters (Sheffield, UK) selling huge steel pipes for Saddam's long-forgotten supergun!
Personally I think that the US Justice system is now so fundamentally flawed It needs ripping down and rebuilding from the ground up. A system where it is easier to confess to something you haven't done because it takes longer and is more damaging to prove your innocence does not deserve the label of a "Justice" system.
telecat said:
Personally I think that the US Justice system is now so fundamentally flawed It needs ripping down and rebuilding from the ground up. A system where it is easier to confess to something you haven't done because it takes longer and is more damaging to prove your innocence does not deserve the label of a "Justice" system.
Where is your proof that ANY innocent person has EVER made a guilty plea whether in USA or UK?UK prisons are full of convicted criminals who protest their innocence.
Ozzie Osmond said:
Where is your proof that ANY innocent person has EVER made a guilty plea whether in USA or UK?
UK prisons are full of convicted criminals who protest their innocence.
I think the point that was being made was that any system that encourages plea bargaining because of protracted and hugely costly processes needs reassessment.UK prisons are full of convicted criminals who protest their innocence.
Personally I don't see anything wrong with that. I'd rather see people tried fairly and cop an appropriate sentence than plea bargain and take minimal time. I'd rather see that for those who are innocent AND those who are guilty.
Whether any innocent people have ever copped a guilty plea is irrelevant. And in copping the plea it is impossible to say (by virtue of the plea they are guilty after all!).
Adrian W said:
I work in electronics manufacturing, the Americans have so many restricted parts,and keep changing them every five minutes that I could see this happening to lots of people, including me, I’m not talking about leading edge technologies or bits for bombs, and I’m talking trivial components that you wouldn’t think twice about.
Fourtunatly I don't have any customers in the Middle East...............that I know about
You may still have concerns if you bought or sold the goods in US dollars. Apparently the US Govt has it in mind to safeguard the reputation of their beloved dollar by stamping out it's use for trades it disapproves of...anywhere in the world.Fourtunatly I don't have any customers in the Middle East...............that I know about
Ozzie Osmond said:
...
Where is your proof that ANY innocent person has EVER made a guilty plea whether in USA or UK?
...
There are many such cases. One such (Brian Banks) is mentioned above. Wikipedia has many more. Where is your proof that ANY innocent person has EVER made a guilty plea whether in USA or UK?
...
See also many examples of false convictions despite not guilty pleas: Birmingham Six, Guildford Four, Stefan Kiszko, and others.
Edited by anonymous-user on Friday 2nd November 14:43
Ozzie Osmond said:
telecat said:
Personally I think that the US Justice system is now so fundamentally flawed It needs ripping down and rebuilding from the ground up. A system where it is easier to confess to something you haven't done because it takes longer and is more damaging to prove your innocence does not deserve the label of a "Justice" system.
Where is your proof that ANY innocent person has EVER made a guilty plea whether in USA or UK?UK prisons are full of convicted criminals who protest their innocence.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



t.