Milibands United on Living Wage Proposal - Good or Bad Idea?
Milibands United on Living Wage Proposal - Good or Bad Idea?

Poll: Milibands United on Living Wage Proposal - Good or Bad Idea?

Total Members Polled: 132

Good: 32%
Bad: 55%
Don't know/no opinion: 14%
Author
Discussion

turbobloke

Original Poster:

117,610 posts

291 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2012/nov/03/mil...

http://www.croner-i.croner.co.uk/croner-i/gateway....

It's not new but it's news at the moment.

Supporters say it's affordable and user-frienfly because it's encouraged not imposed.

Opponents say in spite of the spin it's not affordable now, and will policy creep make it compulsory eventually?

powerstroke

10,283 posts

191 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Its good on paper but not going to happen while we have thousands of migrants coming and willing to work for the minimum wage or less!!! In an ideal world we would have a decent minimum wage and no tax credits but while we are swamped with cheap labour ?????.

GTO Scott

3,816 posts

255 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Surely market forces are what controls the wage rate?

Most private sector employers won't pay any more than they have to.

Maybe it's better to look at improving conditions rather than the hourly rate. Sick pay for starters - most sub-£10 p/h jobs do not include sick pay at anything above SSP, regardless of the safety implications - truck/bus/coach drivers for example rarely get sick pay but many turn in for work when ill because they can't afford to stay at home and rest. That said, how would one go about preventing abuse of the system?

turbobloke

Original Poster:

117,610 posts

291 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all

Getragdogleg

10,332 posts

214 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
If the government would get its house in order and stop wasting trillions of pounds of tax payers money each year on poor value PFis and donations to other countries then they could lower taxes which would benefit the working man directly.

This will push up wage bills for employers and tip many employees into a higher rate of tax.

If my Tax bill was lower I would have more money, its simple, making employers pay a living wage would just force them to either see their already slim margins reduce or rais the prices to cover the extra costs.

fking daft idea, how about these two clueless idiots fk off and die.

cwis

1,249 posts

210 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Instead of taxing everyone (including businesses don't forget) to top up the wages of people on less than a living wage, surely it's more efficient to just pay them enough in the first place?

Tax bills lower for all, including companies, and easily understandable up front visible costs for companies if they want to take on more people.

Implementation is the issue - you can make the living wage compulsory as the minimum wage was, with various unpredictable effects on the labour market and whining from business leaders..

Or just simply remove the top up benefits and let market forces correct - which would again have various unpredictable effects on the labour market and this time whining from the receivers of said benefits..

My own personal view on low wages is this: If businesses want to take advantage of the advanced infrastructure of the UK (including well educated literate potential employees that can travel to and from work on nice reliable tarmacced roads etc) then they can jolly well pay for the privilege.

These things cost money. They cost the employee money in the form of taxes on everything they buy with the wages they get. If the wages are not high enough for basic survival and the employee needs them topped up by the state then the company in question is taking the piss frankly.

The grown of stty part time and low wage jobs in this country (I'm looking at you Tesco, and you, Starbucks) is at a NET COST to the economy.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
I think it is a good idea to know and publicise the living wage, but even more importance should be placed on Tax Freedom Day.

RYH64E

7,960 posts

275 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
GTO Scott said:
Surely market forces are what controls the wage rate?

Most private sector employers won't pay any more than they have to.

Maybe it's better to look at improving conditions rather than the hourly rate. Sick pay for starters - most sub-£10 p/h jobs do not include sick pay at anything above SSP, regardless of the safety implications - truck/bus/coach drivers for example rarely get sick pay but many turn in for work when ill because they can't afford to stay at home and rest. That said, how would one go about preventing abuse of the system?
I don't have a problem with paying a living wage, even the lowest paid of my staff is paid £7.50 per hour, but there's no way I'm paying sick pay again. When I paid sick pay my shop floor staff averaged 2 days off per month, since I've stopped it they take a more reasonable 2 days/year. For reference, I don't think I've had more than half a dozen days sick in 25 years of work.

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
If they want to make low wages more liveable, try taxing them less.


GTO Scott

3,816 posts

255 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
RYH64E said:
I don't have a problem with paying a living wage, even the lowest paid of my staff is paid £7.50 per hour, but there's no way I'm paying sick pay again. When I paid sick pay my shop floor staff averaged 2 days off per month, since I've stopped it they take a more reasonable 2 days/year. For reference, I don't think I've had more than half a dozen days sick in 25 years of work.
There lies the problem with sick pay - people being too inclined to just take odd days off. Any sick pay scheme needs to be properly controlled and strict conditions set for qualifying.

I do agree with scrapping all the tax credits and benefits for anyone in full time employment, using the savings to simply drop the tax rate and possibly leave employees better off - sadly the government have their hands tied on that one because all the people needed to administer the system would be added to the unemployed total and the media would go into a feeding frenzy over it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Getragdogleg said:
If the government would get its house in order and stop wasting trillions of pounds of tax payers money each year on poor value PFis and donations to other countries then they could lower taxes which would benefit the working man directly.

This will push up wage bills for employers and tip many employees into a higher rate of tax.

If my Tax bill was lower I would have more money, its simple, making employers pay a living wage would just force them to either see their already slim margins reduce or rais the prices to cover the extra costs.

fking daft idea, how about these two clueless idiots fk off and die.
This.

The market will set wages at a fair level, but the government need to reduce spending and therefore taxes to make those wages enough to live on.

We all know it but it just doesn't happen. Perhaps when there's no more to borrow?

Getragdogleg

10,332 posts

214 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
Getragdogleg said:
If the government would get its house in order and stop wasting trillions of pounds of tax payers money each year on poor value PFis and donations to other countries then they could lower taxes which would benefit the working man directly.

This will push up wage bills for employers and tip many employees into a higher rate of tax.

If my Tax bill was lower I would have more money, its simple, making employers pay a living wage would just force them to either see their already slim margins reduce or rais the prices to cover the extra costs.

fking daft idea, how about these two clueless idiots fk off and die.
This.

The market will set wages at a fair level, but the government need to reduce spending and therefore taxes to make those wages enough to live on.

We all know it but it just doesn't happen. Perhaps when there's no more to borrow?
There is no more money which is what this is all about. Couple this with the new pensions scheme and you can see that the politicians are trying to get more out of us while telling us they care.

98elise

32,902 posts

192 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
RYH64E said:
GTO Scott said:
Surely market forces are what controls the wage rate?

Most private sector employers won't pay any more than they have to.

Maybe it's better to look at improving conditions rather than the hourly rate. Sick pay for starters - most sub-£10 p/h jobs do not include sick pay at anything above SSP, regardless of the safety implications - truck/bus/coach drivers for example rarely get sick pay but many turn in for work when ill because they can't afford to stay at home and rest. That said, how would one go about preventing abuse of the system?
I don't have a problem with paying a living wage, even the lowest paid of my staff is paid £7.50 per hour, but there's no way I'm paying sick pay again. When I paid sick pay my shop floor staff averaged 2 days off per month, since I've stopped it they take a more reasonable 2 days/year. For reference, I don't think I've had more than half a dozen days sick in 25 years of work.
Agreed, I'm a contractor working in a team thats mixed contractors and permie. I don't remember the last time any of the contractors took time off sick. Even when I was permie I never threw "sickies". 30 years of employment and I can count the sick days on one hand.

JagLover

46,849 posts

266 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
It is government policy that has made a 'living' wage so much higer than the minimum wage.

Salaries for public sector employees are higher than that of private sector employees in every region outside the south-east, driving up local prices for the rest.

Housing benefit policy has driven up both house prices and rents.

A 'living wage' new minimum would simply drive out some economic activity in areas that desperatly need private sector employment.

RedTrident

8,290 posts

266 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
RYH64E said:
I don't have a problem with paying a living wage, even the lowest paid of my staff is paid £7.50 per hour, but there's no way I'm paying sick pay again. When I paid sick pay my shop floor staff averaged 2 days off per month, since I've stopped it they take a more reasonable 2 days/year. For reference, I don't think I've had more than half a dozen days sick in 25 years of work.
I remember when I pulled sIck pay. Complete transformation in staff turnout. The hardworking individuals loved it as they hated carrying the abusers.

I remember the local authority being upset because the company had a contract with them. I also remember the meeting with them where my HR lead produced a report showing how a survey within the local authority had found that something like 90% of their staff thought sick pay was a 'holiday entitlement'. That was 10 days a year that needed to be used up regardless of illness.

Would be really intetesting to see the before and after results of companies that had adjusted their sick pay policies.

Fatboy

8,272 posts

303 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
JagLover said:
It is government policy that has made a 'living' wage so much higer than the minimum wage.

Salaries for public sector employees are higher than that of private sector employees in every region outside the south-east, driving up local prices for the rest.

Housing benefit policy has driven up both house prices and rents.

A 'living wage' new minimum would simply drive out some economic activity in areas that desperatly need private sector employment.
Also making us less competitive internationally - the government needs to looks at how to drive down the cost of living, not drive up the wages...

Puggit

49,832 posts

279 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
Good idea in principle, horrific idea in practise.

Just more Labour attempts at bribing their voters, and making UK plc even less competitive.

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

292 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
cwis said:
If the wages are not high enough for basic survival and the employee needs them topped up by the state then the company in question is taking the piss frankly.

The grown of stty part time and low wage jobs in this country (I'm looking at you Tesco, and you, Starbucks) is at a NET COST to the economy.
If someone through no fault of their own can't currently provide more than £5 an hour of benefit to an employer, surely it's better for them to have the chance of working for <£5 an hour than having to sit to live entirely on benefits until they've retrained or the job market has improved.

GTO Scott

3,816 posts

255 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
RedTrident said:
RYH64E said:
I don't have a problem with paying a living wage, even the lowest paid of my staff is paid £7.50 per hour, but there's no way I'm paying sick pay again. When I paid sick pay my shop floor staff averaged 2 days off per month, since I've stopped it they take a more reasonable 2 days/year. For reference, I don't think I've had more than half a dozen days sick in 25 years of work.
I remember when I pulled sIck pay. Complete transformation in staff turnout. The hardworking individuals loved it as they hated carrying the abusers.

I remember the local authority being upset because the company had a contract with them. I also remember the meeting with them where my HR lead produced a report showing how a survey within the local authority had found that something like 90% of their staff thought sick pay was a 'holiday entitlement'. That was 10 days a year that needed to be used up regardless of illness.

Would be really intetesting to see the before and after results of companies that had adjusted their sick pay policies.
This is the problem - sick pay is open to abuse, hence why any sick pay must have tight regulation. People who throw a sickie deserve fk-all, but in September I was off for three weeks. I couldn't work as I was on crutches - I drive for a living, and work had no non-driving duties for me to do. Dropping from £400 net per week to £85.85 was a real pain, and I ended up going back to work against medical advice because I could not afford it any longer. Given that the average person needs £230 p/w to survive, I don't understand how as a full time worker (since leaving school, never claimed benefits) I'm not entitled to be taken care of properly when I'm ill. I think unconditional sick pay is a very bad idea, but equally employees with good employment records and a history of hard work should be treated better.

JagLover

46,849 posts

266 months

Sunday 4th November 2012
quotequote all
GTO Scott said:
Given that the average person needs £230 p/w to survive, I don't understand how as a full time worker (since leaving school, never claimed benefits) I'm not entitled to be taken care of properly when I'm ill. I think unconditional sick pay is a very bad idea, but equally employees with good employment records and a history of hard work should be treated better.
Because of the end of the contributory principle.

Before the welfare state was setup workers would often have insurance, whether through their union or otherwise, to cover loss of earnings when sick etc. When the welfare state was setup it replaced this function and at first it did.

Now the people who actually pay for the system receive virtually b*gger all in spells of unemployment or sickness. Given the way the state pension and state second pension are going the last traces of the contributory priniple will be gone soon.