E39 528i engine temp
E39 528i engine temp
Author
Discussion

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Tuesday 6th November 2012
quotequote all
Hello chaps.

I'm sure I've seen it mentioned on here somewhere about E39 6's running a bit cool.

Mine did it last winter, and I never got around to doing anything about it, and it is doing it again now the weather has turned cooler, fine around town, just high speed stuff, like the stat is faulty, only it isn't.

Stat is fine, coolant is fine, engine temp sensor is fine, waterpump is fine etc.

I remember seeing it mentioned there is another sensor somewhere, any ideas ?

Gad-Westy

16,668 posts

244 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Strange one. It seems to me that there are only really two possibilities, the engine temp sensor isn't working or the thermostat is stuck open.

What tests have you done to ensure thermostat and sensor are fine?

Does the car seem to warm up slowly? What's the heater temperature like?

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
your thermostat will be stuck open.

4rephill

5,172 posts

209 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
How have you determined that the 'stat is fine?

steve_bmw said:
your thermostat will be stuck open.
This does seem most likely.

I had a similar issue on My 3 series, round town it was fine, but as soon as you got out onto the open road the temp gauge dropped to just above the blue zone. I had the thermostat replaced and all was well again.

alanyboy

23 posts

209 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
I have the same engine in my E36 and had exactly the same, and was cured by simply changing the thermostat. Not a hard job, just make sure its bled properly!

tgr

1,256 posts

202 months

Wednesday 7th November 2012
quotequote all
Buy the BMW thermostat, not OEM or aftermarket. For very little extra dosh it's much more reliable

E38Ross

36,729 posts

243 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
Check the actual temp using the obc hidden menu, should run at 93deg usually.

AJB

856 posts

246 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
Mine did it last winter, and I never got around to doing anything about it, and it is doing it again now the weather has turned cooler, fine around town, just high speed stuff, like the stat is faulty, only it isn't.

Stat is fine, coolant is fine, engine temp sensor is fine, waterpump is fine etc.
Mine (also E39 528i) was exactly the same last winter and this winter. Thought it might not be the thermostat, as previous owner had a receipt for a new one only 2.5 years ago (so 1.5 years ago last winter).

Anyway, finally got fed up with it and fitted a new genuine BMW thermostat a couple of weeks ago, and it's been perfect since. The one I took out was a pattern part (not even exactly the same shape as the genuine replacement) and obviously rubbish...

As others said, are you sure it's not the thermostat?

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
AJB said:
Nigel Worc's said:
Mine did it last winter, and I never got around to doing anything about it, and it is doing it again now the weather has turned cooler, fine around town, just high speed stuff, like the stat is faulty, only it isn't.

Stat is fine, coolant is fine, engine temp sensor is fine, waterpump is fine etc.
Mine (also E39 528i) was exactly the same last winter and this winter. Thought it might not be the thermostat, as previous owner had a receipt for a new one only 2.5 years ago (so 1.5 years ago last winter).

Anyway, finally got fed up with it and fitted a new genuine BMW thermostat a couple of weeks ago, and it's been perfect since. The one I took out was a pattern part (not even exactly the same shape as the genuine replacement) and obviously rubbish...

As others said, are you sure it's not the thermostat?
No I'm not, I do have a reciept for a thermostat, like yours, before I bought it, I do know it is a pattern part, I also know it operated at the correct temp, (according to my mechy mate ..... he boiled it!), but I will be changing it for a genuine one.

I'll let you all know the outcome.

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
Oh and just to add weight to your theories, I spoke to my indie specialist, he said change the thermostat for a genuine one, and come and see me if that doesn't fix it !

AJB

856 posts

246 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
One extra thought - I've just looked at your profile, and yours is a couple of years newer than mine (mine's Jan 1998). Is yours the sort where the thermostat has an electric heater to get it to open when the ECU wants? I think that on those the thermostat and the plastic housing come as one part, and a friend with an E38 728 said that there's a common fault where a bit of plastic breaks, and the thermostat doesn't sit properly in the housing. That means that it behaves as if it's open, even if it's shut, as water can get around the edge of the thermostat.

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

219 months

Sunday 18th November 2012
quotequote all
AJB said:
One extra thought - I've just looked at your profile, and yours is a couple of years newer than mine (mine's Jan 1998). Is yours the sort where the thermostat has an electric heater to get it to open when the ECU wants? I think that on those the thermostat and the plastic housing come as one part, and a friend with an E38 728 said that there's a common fault where a bit of plastic breaks, and the thermostat doesn't sit properly in the housing. That means that it behaves as if it's open, even if it's shut, as water can get around the edge of the thermostat.
Nice thought, but no, mine is just a standard metal thermostat.