WW1 and WW2 Photos of the dead Now banned?
WW1 and WW2 Photos of the dead Now banned?
Author
Discussion

telecat

Original Poster:

8,528 posts

272 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
I'm sorry but this is very much too late and to be honest counter productive.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-20223626

And I'm afraid the reasoning does not wash either.


Nuclearsquash

1,329 posts

293 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
It does seem a little after the fact doesn't it.

THe picture being held up in the article, is sad, thought provoking and in some ways beautiful, but it is in no way demeaning to the soldier or his family. It is capturing a moment in time that we must be reminded of, not hidden away from.

I have a family member (killed in WW1) buried out in Belgium, and i don't think i would be offended had his remains been found for his picture to be taken and displayed. It would give me a link to a time and place where someone paid the ultimate price.

Edit for spelling.

Jasandjules

72,709 posts

260 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
Go to Flanders - many pictures in the museums etc. Lest we forget, and the best way to remember is to see the true horror of it.


GadgeS3C

4,727 posts

195 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
I think I have a little sympathy for this for WW2 victims as it's possible that their partners' could still be alive.

But it seems odd to decide now to worry about.

I've been fortunate to not have to discover the horror of war firsthand. Hiding that horror is not a good way to avoid it in future.



Edited by GadgeS3C on Thursday 8th November 18:27

Piglet

6,250 posts

286 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Go to Flanders - many pictures in the museums etc. Lest we forget, and the best way to remember is to see the true horror of it.
Very much this - we already see a very sanitised version of war in our history books. We visited the photographic exhibition in Stavelot when we were visiting Spa one summer. It was hugely shocking - photographs of piles of bodies, including children - stacked in ditches. We then went to the Abbey to read the memorial which includes lists of families with ages - whole families slaughtered, grandparents, mothers and children - some only months old - the fathers were missing, presumably absent fighting.

Those who fail to learn from history are condemned to repeat it....

Edited by Piglet on Thursday 8th November 18:50

Blib

48,417 posts

228 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
GadgeS3C said:




Edited by GadgeS3C on Thursday 8th November 18:27
nono

The populace must be protected from anything that could possibly disturb them. Unless it is necessary to do so in order to drive them in the direction needed.

GadgeS3C

4,727 posts

195 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
Blib said:
GadgeS3C said:




Edited by GadgeS3C on Thursday 8th November 18:27
nono

The populace must be protected from anything that could possibly disturb them. Unless it is necessary to do so in order to drive them in the direction needed.
I'm quite disturbed by that waving finger - who do I sue? wink

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
If people saw a few more pictures they might not be so eager to send young kids off to die abroad.

glazbagun

15,383 posts

228 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
Well we can't have the public being shown the true cost of war, can we?

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
Heaven forbid the realities of war be shown.

neilr

1,588 posts

294 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
God forbid anyone should see the true result of warfare of course. This has nothing to do with protecting dead solidiers relatives and everything to do with making sure that the masses don't easily see the horror of modern warfare at its most obscene. I'm aware thats perhaps a little on the side of the tin foil hat manufactures guild, but it seems reasonable to me in this case.

Everyone should visit the battlefields and cemeteries in France of both wars.

Carfiend

3,186 posts

240 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
So we won't be able to watch 12 Monkeys anymore?

Jasandjules

72,709 posts

260 months

Thursday 8th November 2012
quotequote all
neilr said:
Everyone should visit the battlefields and cemeteries in France of both wars.
Indeed. EVERY School should run that trip.

telecat

Original Poster:

8,528 posts

272 months

Friday 9th November 2012
quotequote all
Too many Wars have been fought where the Soldiers have been recruited by "glorifying" the fighting. The Great War being the worst example. Personally I am all for showing the reality while acknowledging those who despite all the horrors kept themselves together and helped others survive the worst of those wars.

Hugo a Gogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Friday 9th November 2012
quotequote all
there is a sort of fair point though, you can't just going digging up bodies and taking pictures, try it down at your local churchyard and see what happens

or how about taking a few snaps of a fatal accident as you drive past?

I don't think anyone is suggesting all past pictures should be banned, just that there should be a bit of respect for the dead

Digga

48,653 posts

314 months

Friday 9th November 2012
quotequote all
Piglet said:
Jasandjules said:
Go to Flanders - many pictures in the museums etc. Lest we forget, and the best way to remember is to see the true horror of it.
Very much this - we already see a very sanitised version of war in our history books. We visited the photographic exhibition in Stavelot when we were visiting Spa one summer. It was hugely shocking - photographs of piles of bodies, including children - stacked in ditches. We then went to the Abbey to read the memorial which includes lists of families with ages - whole families slaughtered, grandparents, mothers and children - some only months old - the fathers were missing, presumably absent fighting.

Those who fail to learn from history are condemned to repeat it....
Totally this.

FWIW, I'd say it better to ban bang-bang-drop-dead films about war (not that I subscribe to such regulation) which tend to glorify the violence whilst totally under-playing the human suffering and mess - not so much the dead as the many and various mutilitations and slow, agonising fates that befell so many. Surely to cover-up the horror of war is to risk forgetting it altogether?