BMW 320D Y reg - No Swirl Flaps
BMW 320D Y reg - No Swirl Flaps
Author
Discussion

AndrewJB

Original Poster:

16,021 posts

202 months

Saturday 10th November 2012
quotequote all
Was at a mate's garage yesterday and he had got a customer in with a Y 320D, its got running problems basically not boosting properly and it had previously been diagnosed as sticky vein's on turbo, Anyway turbo was taken off and the turbo is fine, we next wondered if the swirl flaps where on way out, anyway removed manifold to have a look and we where shocked to see No swirl flaps at all, they havent been removed they where just never there

Anybody heard of this before? i dont know much about BMW's (im a VAG man) but i thought they all had them

Edited by AndrewJB on Saturday 10th November 10:43

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Saturday 10th November 2012
quotequote all
No, they don't all have them - some versions of the engine did, some did not. In some cases it was even down to the transmission type fitted (ie an auto 530d had them a manual did not).

Who is paying for all this misdiagnosis? hehe

iSore

4,011 posts

175 months

Sunday 11th November 2012
quotequote all
A Y plate 320d will be the original 136 bhp model that did not have swirl flaps - they were used on the 2001 facelift 150 bhp versions with both manual and auto transmissions.

Not going properly - could be a blocked catalyst, split vacuum pipe, sticky actuator, faulty pressure sensor, lazy fuel delivery pump or one of a million things. At least the 136 bhp engine was a good one and far better than the 150 bhp version.

Ritchie335is

2,162 posts

233 months

Sunday 11th November 2012
quotequote all
iSore said:
A Y plate 320d will be the original 136 bhp model that did not have swirl flaps - they were used on the 2001 facelift 150 bhp versions with both manual and auto transmissions.

Not going properly - could be a blocked catalyst, split vacuum pipe, sticky actuator, faulty pressure sensor, lazy fuel delivery pump or one of a million things. At least the 136 bhp engine was a good one and far better than the 150 bhp version.
Why is the earlier engine better? I have a 150bhp Sport Touring and you have me wondering now!
I have ripped the swirl flaps out of mine and can easily see how they can drop in, horrible flimsy little things with tiny screws retaining them.
They don't have any other problems as far as I know, they have the updated engine breather already.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Sunday 11th November 2012
quotequote all
It's only better from a reliability point of view. It's less likely to go wrong.

Ritchie335is

2,162 posts

233 months

Sunday 11th November 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
It's only better from a reliability point of view. It's less likely to go wrong.
Why though?
Are you referring to the swirl flap issues, which both engines have or do you know of other problems?
I always thought that the earlier engines were more likely to wreck turbos because of the crappy breathers and this was addressed on the facelift model.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
As explained above, the 136bhp variant does not have swirl flaps.