Supermarkets to stop selling tobacco
Discussion
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-bus...
I'm sure the local small shops will be rubbing their hands with glee! I know tobacco sales don't generate much profit, but if you can't get your fags at Sainsburys, you will go elsewhere!
Or will this force more people to buy black market fags?
I understand the health implications and I myself am a non smoker, but I cannot see how this will do any good.
I'm sure the local small shops will be rubbing their hands with glee! I know tobacco sales don't generate much profit, but if you can't get your fags at Sainsburys, you will go elsewhere!
Or will this force more people to buy black market fags?
I understand the health implications and I myself am a non smoker, but I cannot see how this will do any good.
B17NNS said:
Do people still buy smerks from shops?
Surely everyone knows a man?
Odd how some people see that as acceptable, yet this isn't....Surely everyone knows a man?
http://www.pistonheads.com/xforums/topic.asp?h=0&a...
I laughed the other day when I was told Golden Virginia for example is made in Nottingham but you can go to France and get it for less than half the price you can buy it for here. If that's the case then it's hardly surprising people go the black market route. Government is lucky it makes anything, frankly.
Generally though you'd think smoking was completely illegal given the way Government goes out of it's way to attack it. If they really think it's that dangerous then why not ban it outright? Because as prohibition proved with alcohol, it wouldn't work. That's why. Why do Sainsburys have to pay this extra levy for selling tobacco but not for selling beer?
Generally though you'd think smoking was completely illegal given the way Government goes out of it's way to attack it. If they really think it's that dangerous then why not ban it outright? Because as prohibition proved with alcohol, it wouldn't work. That's why. Why do Sainsburys have to pay this extra levy for selling tobacco but not for selling beer?
article said:
Ministers estimated that it would raise £110m during its first four years of operation.
Not if all the big stores stop selling it.Funny isn't it. How the government have our best interests at heart.
Creosote. Considered carcinogenic, no real tax income from it. Government bans it.
Tobacco. Without doubt carcinogenic. Hang on, we make a few quid out of this, plus they seem to die younger.
Lets be seen to be doing something about it by taxing the f
k out of it.
Creosote. Considered carcinogenic, no real tax income from it. Government bans it.
Tobacco. Without doubt carcinogenic. Hang on, we make a few quid out of this, plus they seem to die younger.
Lets be seen to be doing something about it by taxing the f
k out of it.So instead of having it sold by large reputable stores the trade is driven into the corner shops and back-of-a-van merchants who may, or may not, care to whom they sell to or even the provenance of what they are selling.
I'm not a fan of smoking, in fact I'm a non-smoker who has seen plenty of medical reports of the damage done to the human body by heavy smoking, but the more the trade is driven underground the more glamorous it will appear to the impressionable who want to 'defy authority'.
I'm not a fan of smoking, in fact I'm a non-smoker who has seen plenty of medical reports of the damage done to the human body by heavy smoking, but the more the trade is driven underground the more glamorous it will appear to the impressionable who want to 'defy authority'.
B17NNS said:
Funny isn't it. How the government have our best interests at heart.
Creosote. Considered carcinogenic, no real tax income from it. Government bans it.
Tobacco. Without doubt carcinogenic. Hang on, we make a few quid out of this, plus they seem to die younger.
Lets be seen to be doing something about it by taxing the f
k out of it.
It is not uncommon for Govt depts to have conflicing aimsCreosote. Considered carcinogenic, no real tax income from it. Government bans it.
Tobacco. Without doubt carcinogenic. Hang on, we make a few quid out of this, plus they seem to die younger.
Lets be seen to be doing something about it by taxing the f
k out of it.For example. the Dept of Health really will want to cut down on smokers because they have targets to do so and it will save NHS resources. On the other hand the Treasury will want the tax money.
Sometimes a Govt dept will be fighting with itself, I know of one Govt dept that is under orders to remove as much regulation from businesses as possible - but on the other hand it is responsible for fixing gaps in many areas of laws that require more legislation.
otolith said:
Who cares, it's being caused by an extra tax levied by the Scottish government. Purely local Scottish issue.
Good on Sainsbury's I say.Scottish Government Berks: "Let's put a tax on big companies selling tobacco! We'll make £110m from it!"
Sainsbury's: <removes cigarette sales from stores> "F*ck off."
Why should Sainsbury's (or any other large store) effectively be penalised/taxed more just for selling a product?
I hope it LOSES the Scottish Government money.
I am sure it was a pure financial decision on the side of Sainsburys
All it means of course is that people will buy fags from elsehwere - though it may lead to a small drop off if people cannot be bothered to go out of their way and they are not hardcore smokers.
Its no loss for the Govt as presumably they still get tax from the small shops.
All it means of course is that people will buy fags from elsehwere - though it may lead to a small drop off if people cannot be bothered to go out of their way and they are not hardcore smokers.
Its no loss for the Govt as presumably they still get tax from the small shops.
Funk said:
otolith said:
Who cares, it's being caused by an extra tax levied by the Scottish government. Purely local Scottish issue.
Good on Sainsbury's I say.Scottish Government Berks: "Let's put a tax on big companies selling tobacco! We'll make £110m from it!"
Sainsbury's: <removes cigarette sales from stores> "F*ck off."
Why should Sainsbury's (or any other large store) effectively be penalised/taxed more just for selling a product?
I hope it LOSES the Scottish Government money.
B17NNS said:
Funny isn't it. How the government have our best interests at heart.
Creosote. Considered carcinogenic, no real tax income from it. Government bans it.
Nope, still available to buy and use.Creosote. Considered carcinogenic, no real tax income from it. Government bans it.
My name is rs1952 and I am a smoker. Right, that's got the admission out of the way 
It matters not one toss to me whether supermarkets sell tobacco products or not, because I have been buying mine in France, Spain or Belgium for the last 20+ years. The Single Market is handy for smokers
I was in Ypres a few weeks ago buying 30 packets of Old Holborn, that will last me 6 months or so. Each packet cost me 6 euros in Belgium (worked out at exactly £5.00 per packet when my Barclaycard bill came in), the same thing would cost me £15.69 in my local Sainsburys.
Do the sums yourself if you like, but saving £10.69 per packet on 30 packets gives a total saving of well over £300 - more than enough to pay for the diesel and the hotel in Folkestone for one night and the ferry fare. Oh - and I also got a tankful of diesel whilst I was over there at Belgian prices which gave a little extra saving on the UK price
Its a bit more difficult for the Jocks to do this sort of thing given the mileage involved to the ports on the south coast, but might I suggest they look at the Easyjet timetable and start doing the calculations?
I've been having fun with my MP lately asking the question why, if the 50% tax rate is counter productive and we needed to reduce it to increase exchequer revenue, why don't we do the same for tobacco? You can guess the sort of reply I got ...

It matters not one toss to me whether supermarkets sell tobacco products or not, because I have been buying mine in France, Spain or Belgium for the last 20+ years. The Single Market is handy for smokers

I was in Ypres a few weeks ago buying 30 packets of Old Holborn, that will last me 6 months or so. Each packet cost me 6 euros in Belgium (worked out at exactly £5.00 per packet when my Barclaycard bill came in), the same thing would cost me £15.69 in my local Sainsburys.
Do the sums yourself if you like, but saving £10.69 per packet on 30 packets gives a total saving of well over £300 - more than enough to pay for the diesel and the hotel in Folkestone for one night and the ferry fare. Oh - and I also got a tankful of diesel whilst I was over there at Belgian prices which gave a little extra saving on the UK price

Its a bit more difficult for the Jocks to do this sort of thing given the mileage involved to the ports on the south coast, but might I suggest they look at the Easyjet timetable and start doing the calculations?

I've been having fun with my MP lately asking the question why, if the 50% tax rate is counter productive and we needed to reduce it to increase exchequer revenue, why don't we do the same for tobacco? You can guess the sort of reply I got ...

Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


