Green on Blue.
Author
Discussion

croyde

Original Poster:

26,556 posts

261 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
Nice term for a horrifying situation.

Yet another young man in our armed forces has been murdered by an Afghan that was supposed to be on our side.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-20290934

60 of our guys have died this way now, 60!

WTF! are we doing trying to help these animals. Leave, build a wall around the place and lob a few nukes over it and just let them get on with it.

Murdering scum mad

Let's sort our country out and help ourselves and stop wasting lives and money on a bunch of worthless goat herders.

Galsia

2,266 posts

221 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
Its a war that we have no chance of winning. frown

croyde

Original Poster:

26,556 posts

261 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
Agreed.

Yet it's not a war, it's being an international police force like our boys had to do in Northern Ireland. Walking around in uniform for all the enemy to see and with their hands tied.

They might as well have targets painted on their flak vests.

Digga

48,653 posts

314 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
croyde said:
Yet it's not a war, it's being an international police force like our boys had to do in Northern Ireland.
^Totally this.

We need to stop being little brother to the US's big briother and GTFO of these unneccessary, unwinnable foreign occupations. Far better and easier to polic our own borders (which ironically, we haven't bothered to do much recently) than to police the world.

Papa Hotel

12,760 posts

213 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
croyde said:
Agreed.

Yet it's not a war, it's being an international police force like our boys had to do in Northern Ireland. Walking around in uniform for all the enemy to see and with their hands tied.

They might as well have targets painted on their flak vests.
It's fook-all like Northern Ireland. For a start, in NI the enemy happened to be British citizens living in the UK, the British Army wasn't some foreign invader, it was patrolling its own streets. Can you imagine the outcry there'd have been if we'd gone in as tooled-up as we are in Afghanistan and started killing as many as we have done in Afghanistan? There was no training of local militias in NI either, this is a big part of what we're trying to do in Afghanistan. Unfortunately, the enemy are getting wise to this and are easily infiltrating the Afghan security forces, gaining entry to our camps and killing us.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
Galsia said:
Its a war that we have no chance of winning. frown
Oh its winnable

just to win it we would have to adopt tactics that would make hitler think "Oh thats a bit harsh"

croyde

Original Poster:

26,556 posts

261 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
Papa Hotel said:
croyde said:
Agreed.

Yet it's not a war, it's being an international police force like our boys had to do in Northern Ireland. Walking around in uniform for all the enemy to see and with their hands tied.

They might as well have targets painted on their flak vests.
It's fook-all like Northern Ireland. For a start, in NI the enemy happened to be British citizens living in the UK, the British Army wasn't some foreign invader, it was patrolling its own streets. Can you imagine the outcry there'd have been if we'd gone in as tooled-up as we are in Afghanistan and started killing as many as we have done in Afghanistan? There was no training of local militias in NI either, this is a big part of what we're trying to do in Afghanistan. Unfortunately, the enemy are getting wise to this and are easily infiltrating the Afghan security forces, gaining entry to our camps and killing us.
It is like NI in that you are a permanent target who is seen by a hidden enemy even when you are off duty. I agree that the two situations are different but the risk to the poor soldier seems the same to me.

I'd rather my chances against another soldier in a different uniform than an enemy that hides amongst the local population. Al Queda or IRA, both cowards in my book.

Mr_B

10,480 posts

274 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
There was a clip a day or two ago on the BBC news showing UK troops playing football with the Afghan Army and Police. They had to have several guys standing there at all times ready to react to a Green on Blue. Just a day or two later and the fear becomes all too real again.
Will be a great day when they finally come home. I think they have done enough and paid a big enough price to let Afghan forces police the country.

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
Galsia said:
Its a war that we have no chance of winning. frown
Oh its winnable

just to win it we would have to adopt tactics that would make hitler think "Oh thats a bit harsh"
The Russians couldn't do it, and they don't exactly have a history of 'holding back'.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
TTwiggy said:
The Russians couldn't do it, and they don't exactly have a history of 'holding back'.
It's often been said that the Russians' big problem in Afghanistan was lack of communiucations. They didn't have satellite communication and in the mountainous terrain their "line of sight" radios were useless.

Their other problem was USA, UK and others supporting the "freedom fighters" as they were then known!

"The supplying of billions of dollars in arms to the Afghan mujahideen militants was one of the CIA's longest and most expensive covert operations. At least 3 billion in U.S. dollars were funneled into the country to train and equip troops with weapons." - wikipedia

hesnotthemessiah

2,121 posts

235 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
croyde said:
Papa Hotel said:
croyde said:
Agreed.

Yet it's not a war, it's being an international police force like our boys had to do in Northern Ireland. Walking around in uniform for all the enemy to see and with their hands tied.

They might as well have targets painted on their flak vests.
It's fook-all like Northern Ireland. For a start, in NI the enemy happened to be British citizens living in the UK, the British Army wasn't some foreign invader, it was patrolling its own streets. Can you imagine the outcry there'd have been if we'd gone in as tooled-up as we are in Afghanistan and started killing as many as we have done in Afghanistan? There was no training of local militias in NI either, this is a big part of what we're trying to do in Afghanistan. Unfortunately, the enemy are getting wise to this and are easily infiltrating the Afghan security forces, gaining entry to our camps and killing us.
It is like NI in that you are a permanent target who is seen by a hidden enemy even when you are off duty. I agree that the two situations are different but the risk to the poor soldier seems the same to me.

I'd rather my chances against another soldier in a different uniform than an enemy that hides amongst the local population. Al Queda or IRA, both cowards in my book.
Every time there is mention of British soldiers getting killed by insurgents or whatever....Northern Ireland comes up? It's totally different. If it wasn't for the British...there wouldn't be a Northern Ireland to fight over, no IRA, UDA etc etc..

croyde

Original Poster:

26,556 posts

261 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
hesnotthemessiah said:
Every time there is mention of British soldiers getting killed by insurgents or whatever....Northern Ireland comes up? It's totally different. If it wasn't for the British...there wouldn't be a Northern Ireland to fight over, no IRA, UDA etc etc..
Like I said before, I'm not questioning the motives, I'm merely pointing out a similar situation where our lads are 'legitimate' targets for an enemy that hides amongst the civilian population.

As far as the Catholics, Protestants and Muslims are concerned, they can all go fek themselves. Any human in the 21st century that persists in believing in a sky god is a moron, especially when they use these beliefs as an excuse to kill one another.

Fekin' barbarians!!

Edited by croyde on Monday 12th November 11:32


Edited by croyde on Monday 12th November 11:37

shouldbworking

4,801 posts

243 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
For the circumstances where its not infiltration, does anyone know any examples of the sort of 'cultural differences' arguments that somehow result in an afghan shooting? is calling someone a mong grounds for a battle to the death over there?

croyde

Original Poster:

26,556 posts

261 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
shouldbworking said:
For the circumstances where its not infiltration, does anyone know any examples of the sort of 'cultural differences' arguments that somehow result in an afghan shooting? is calling someone a mong grounds for a battle to the death over there?
Within my own knowledge gained from working with Arabs, I know not Persians, and working in their countries, the cultural difference thing is a minefield in itself and I would imagine that out in the hinterlands and with the locals carrying weapons in addition to their low value on life that a 'mishap' and an itchy trigger finger could result in a fatality.

Another reason why our lads and lasses should not be in this alien environment.

P-Jay

11,434 posts

222 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
TTwiggy said:
thinfourth2 said:
Galsia said:
Its a war that we have no chance of winning. frown
Oh its winnable

just to win it we would have to adopt tactics that would make hitler think "Oh thats a bit harsh"
The Russians couldn't do it, and they don't exactly have a history of 'holding back'.
As above it 'could' be won, but post the second-world war it is no longer politically possible to declare war on an entire country, the Western World still has as terrifying number of proper, big WMD's we could turn the entire country into a toxic wasteland without a single living organism right down to the molecular level within a few hours - but that would cause a lot more problems with global terrorism.

Speaking of 'oh that's a bit harsh' or 'going a bit far' - The US are still the only country in History to use not one, but two weapons of mass destruction in anger.

croyde

Original Poster:

26,556 posts

261 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
P-Jay said:
As above it 'could' be won, but post the second-world war it is no longer politically possible to declare war on an entire country, the Western World still has as terrifying number of proper, big WMD's we could turn the entire country into a toxic wasteland without a single living organism right down to the molecular level within a few hours - but that would cause a lot more problems with global terrorism.

Speaking of 'oh that's a bit harsh' or 'going a bit far' - The US are still the only country in History to use not one, but two weapons of mass destruction in anger.
I agree but were we not 'at war' with Argentina 20 years ago?

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
croyde said:
I agree but were we not 'at war' with Argentina 20 years ago?
War was not formally declared by either combatant nation.

croyde

Original Poster:

26,556 posts

261 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
I see, thanks for that.

knk

1,346 posts

302 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
The majority of our "Green on Blue" casualties have been a result of culture, rather than the actions of the insurgency. The cultural sleights are most usually due to the treatment of the Afghan soldiers and police officers by their own commanders, but they transfer these grievances onto the ISAF troops, knowing that if they act against them they will have a welcome place amongst the insurgents.

Kam

MrMagoo

3,208 posts

193 months

Monday 12th November 2012
quotequote all
This 'war on terrorism' has created more terrorists then there were at the start of the campaign. Ironic that. Are the Afghans better of now then they were? Has Iraq turned into a safe and peacefull country? Has it fk. What is a terrorist? Id wager a guess that many Taliban fighters aren't interested in bringing death and destruction to the Western world. Most are farmers who want us out of their country. And who can blame them? If the roles were reversed and England was invaded by powerfull Islamic countries who want to kick out our government how many people would pick up a gun and fight back. Plant IED's and try and kill as many of them as possible. I know I would. Its a fking shame that our military is having to risk their lives for such a worthless cause. In a a few decades the world will look upon this 'war' with the same way we look upon Germany with regards to WW2.

Being from a military family and a brother who has recently just got back from his 3rd tour this is a subject that makes me so fking angry. I can't begin to imagine the pain the family of that soldier are going through. Not knowing what he gave up his life for. 2014 can't come quick enough.