Crisis at the BBC
Author
Discussion

daz3210

Original Poster:

5,000 posts

271 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
Excuse me if I am not understanding this but....

The BBC had accusations about Sir Jimmy Savile what were unproven, and are being criticised for not voicing them.

Then they had accusations about a senior politician that were unproven but are now being criticised for voicing them.

Am I missing something, but is it a case of they cannot win?

castex

5,188 posts

304 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
The rest of the media hate the BBC because they cannot compete.

daz3210

Original Poster:

5,000 posts

271 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
That is probably true, but does it mean they cannot win?

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
The Jimmy Saville story was true and cancelled because it would clash with their christmas special, the "senior tory politician from the thatcher era [spit]" story was based on ttter gossip and despite their lawyers declaring it was a load of bks they decided to just broadcast everything except the bloke's name.

Then they solved the crisis by giving the general manager (or whatever his title was) half a million quid - twice as much as his contract entitled him to - because fk it.

daz3210

Original Poster:

5,000 posts

271 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
EDLT said:
The Jimmy Saville story was true and cancelled because it would clash with their christmas special, the "senior tory politician from the thatcher era [spit]" story was based on ttter gossip and despite their lawyers declaring it was a load of bks they decided to just broadcast everything except the bloke's name.

Then they solved the crisis by giving the general manager (or whatever his title was) half a million quid - twice as much as his contract entitled him to - because fk it.
What proof is there that the Jimmy Saville story was true?

And the fact that a man has admitted he was wrong with the accusations about the Tory suggests there could have been no truth.

So potentially both stories are utter twaddle.


martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
We don't need another feet-stamping BBC-hating thread.

I do think the BBC would've had a very hard time at least initially if they'd broadcasted the Savile item. It's easy to say now it was true so it should've gone out but everything is easy to say after the fact.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
daz3210 said:
What proof is there that the Jimmy Saville story was true?

And the fact that a man has admitted he was wrong with the accusations about the Tory suggests there could have been no truth.

So potentially both stories are utter twaddle.
Potentially. But if they were happy there was enough evidence to run "McAlpine", how the fk was there not enough evidence to run "Savile"?

daz3210

Original Poster:

5,000 posts

271 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
We don't need another feet-stamping BBC-hating thread.

I do think the BBC would've had a very hard time at least initially if they'd broadcasted the Savile item. It's easy to say now it was true so it should've gone out but everything is easy to say after the fact.
TBH I am not a BBC hater.

Exactly the opposite in fact.

OK, there MAY have been evidence that the Saville storey was vaild, but I have yet to see it, but to be honest if someone said well we HAD to run the tory story as a result I would say fair play to them.


martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
I don't think they'd have run McAlpine if it weren't for the cover-up accusations around the Savile non-broadcast. After the Savile thing broke the Newsnight editor 'stepped aside' or whatever it is they say. It does look to me like Newsnight were lacking authority in it's staff and they were desperate to turn the news cycle round to something else and say 'look we've uncovered something and we had the balls to show it!!'

Unfortunately that ended up false.

daz3210

Original Poster:

5,000 posts

271 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
and before anyone say it, several folks saying it happened does not equate to evidence tbh

daz3210

Original Poster:

5,000 posts

271 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
martin84 said:
I don't think they'd have run McAlpine if it weren't for the cover-up accusations around the Savile non-broadcast. After the Savile thing broke the Newsnight editor 'stepped aside' or whatever it is they say. It does look to me like Newsnight were lacking authority in it's staff and they were desperate to turn the news cycle round to something else and say 'look we've uncovered something and we had the balls to show it!!'

Unfortunately that ended up false.
So its damned if you do and damned if you don't?


martin84

5,366 posts

184 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
Well I think Newsnight should've been taken off air until it had a proper editor in charge. Their own report says basic journalistic checks were not made prior to the McAlpine broadcast and it feels like monkeys taking over the zoo. Usually when Newsnight say something which causes much embarassment to someone they say 'nobody from so and so was available for comment tonight.' They didn't do that with the McAlpine thing, they didn't even ask him to respond to the allegation which is 101 stuff really.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

188 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
daz3210 said:
Excuse me if I am not understanding this but....

The BBC had accusations about Sir Jimmy Savile what were unproven, and are being criticised for not voicing them.

Then they had accusations about a senior politician that were unproven but are now being criticised for voicing them.

Am I missing something, but is it a case of they cannot win?
Or alternatively, they knew exactly what was going on with Savile because he didn't hide it and BBC employees facilitated him and in a desperate attempt to deflect some of the fallout they allowed an unresearched piece defaming a tory to be shown which has since backfired badly on them.

eharding

14,648 posts

315 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
daz3210 said:
martin84 said:
I don't think they'd have run McAlpine if it weren't for the cover-up accusations around the Savile non-broadcast. After the Savile thing broke the Newsnight editor 'stepped aside' or whatever it is they say. It does look to me like Newsnight were lacking authority in it's staff and they were desperate to turn the news cycle round to something else and say 'look we've uncovered something and we had the balls to show it!!'

Unfortunately that ended up false.
So its damned if you do and damned if you don't?
No, you're damned if you screw up, which is what is happening to the BBC.

They screwed up by suppressing the original Savile investigation for reasons which are not yet entirely clear. You could argue that they erred on the side of caution, not wishing to slander a dead man, but the circumstances surrounding the cancellation of the investigation now look very, very dodgy indeed.

They then went completely off the reservation by slandering a perfectly innocent man, in one of the most shocking examples of shoddy journalism and outright mendacity that most of us can remember.

Damn right there is a crisis at the BBC, and nothing I've seen or read over the past 48 hours gives me any encouragement that there is anyone in a position of responsibility in that organisation who has the first clue about how to remedy the situation, nor indeed really grasps the magnitude of how poisoned the institution has become.




daz3210

Original Poster:

5,000 posts

271 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
Caulkhead said:
daz3210 said:
Excuse me if I am not understanding this but....

The BBC had accusations about Sir Jimmy Savile what were unproven, and are being criticised for not voicing them.

Then they had accusations about a senior politician that were unproven but are now being criticised for voicing them.

Am I missing something, but is it a case of they cannot win?
Or alternatively, they knew exactly what was going on with Savile because he didn't hide it and BBC employees facilitated him and in a desperate attempt to deflect some of the fallout they allowed an unresearched piece defaming a tory to be shown which has since backfired badly on them.
So where is the proof re Saville?

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
eharding said:
No, you're damned if you screw up, which is what is happening to the BBC.

They screwed up by suppressing the original Savile investigation for reasons which are not yet entirely clear. You could argue that they erred on the side of caution, not wishing to slander a dead man, but the circumstances surrounding the cancellation of the investigation now look very, very dodgy indeed.
I don't think we'll ever get an official explanation, but the story being cancelled because it would interfere with the christmas schedule has been mentioned more than once on BBC programmes and they haven't put a stop to it. If they had a better reason it would have come out by now.

AJS-

15,366 posts

267 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
Slight difference in the cases though.

Savile had persistent rumours from various sources for decades which the BBC ignored. They turned out to be true. They surpressed their own investigation into it.

McAlpine had one accusation, from someone who it seems they knew to be an unreliable witness. They made it the lead story on their flagship news programme.

I'm sure I don't need to remind you that one of these people was a former BBC employee, and the other one was a right wing Tory. One would make the BBC look bad, one would make the Conservative party look bad.

I'm actually going to do something I very rarely do, and stick up for the BBC at this point. I don't really blame the organisation as a whole for the Savile affair. Celebrities like Jimmy Savile are weird people when measured against nearly anything that you or I would deem normal. Yet he was an icon who was successful over many decades, and also a massive fundraiser for charity. The 1970s were a very different age and topics like child molestation didn't have the headline grabbing power it has today, and there was no internet on which victims could connect with each other, and know that they were not over reacting or jumping at shadows. In fact it seems like the NHS, many care homes and I'm quite sure a few other institutions besides suffered similar problems, even if not to the same lurid degree as Savile at the BBC.

I can even understand why, in 2011 a few months after his death, they chose not to air these historic allegations. Child abuse is big news now, and child abuse against a dead celebrity with the possibility of a financial pay out is likely to be a crowded gravy train.

I could forgive them all that, on the sound principle that people are innocent until proven guilty, and the bar for publicly naming someone as a paedophile is rightly set extremely high. They probably made a strategic error in allowing ITV shine the light on the whole saga in the first place, but fortunately the BBC don't completely control the media, and the soap selling down dumbers at ITV managed to get the documentary out.

The real problem is the reaction to it. In particular the decision to deliberately attempt to label a Conservative politician as a child molester, on the strength of Steve Messham's allegations. They abused their position as a widely trusted news organisation to attempt the worst possible slur against an innocent man. It really doesn't get much worse than that, to my mind.

They can't win now, because they have done something extremely wrong. They quite easily could have won, with a simple, mature acknowledgement that mistakes were made, and some sound, sensible measures to ensure they didn't happen again.

Dixie68

3,091 posts

218 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
daz3210 said:
and before anyone say it, several folks saying it happened does not equate to evidence tbh
It's in the hundreds with JS now, not exactly 'several', plus there are the people who worked with him saying how it was well known. The McAlpine accusation came from one person.

daz3210

Original Poster:

5,000 posts

271 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
Dixie68 said:
daz3210 said:
and before anyone say it, several folks saying it happened does not equate to evidence tbh
It's in the hundreds with JS now, not exactly 'several', plus there are the people who worked with him saying how it was well known. The McAlpine accusation came from one person.
It may be in the several hundreds now, but go back to say December last year. How many was it then? Lets not forget that some previous accusations against Savile had been investigated and found to not have sufficient evidence.

IroningMan

10,598 posts

277 months

Tuesday 13th November 2012
quotequote all
daz3210 said:
It may be in the several hundreds now, but go back to say December last year. How many was it then? Lets not forget that some previous accusations against Savile had been investigated and found to not have sufficient evidence.
When the story broke there was debate about the speed with which he was deemed to be guilty by the Police and others - turns out you have no defence when you're dead.

I think, though, that the original BBC programme was pulled because it was inconvenient, and didn't suit the agenda of the day, not because there was any nervousness about its veracity.