BMW Hybrids - thoughts?
BMW Hybrids - thoughts?
Author
Discussion

peteA

Original Poster:

2,762 posts

265 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
Apologies if this has been discussed before...just wondering what the general consensus us? Has anybody been in one (at the olympics maybe..?)? Any thoughts / comments?

Reason I ask is I've just spent a day with a 5 Series Hybrid - 3 litre turbo petrol with an electric motor & batteries and loved it!

Used to have a BMW 320D SE and now have a Merc C250 CDi sport auto and whilst they are very good cars I have never got used to the diesel clatter in the morning and the 'thrum' under acceleration.

The hybrid on the other hand...when in Eco-pro mode returned just over 50 mpg and is whisper quiet - the engine cuts in and out and you just cant tell...only the rev counter gives the game away. You even find yourself trying to stay in electric only mode for as long as possible. Put it in sport mode and the the steering, suspension and throttle all 'beef up' and when you put your foot down the engine and electric motor work together and blast you up the road with a glorious turbine like shove...right up to 7500 rpm! Very un Diesel like! When ragged it was averaging about 25 mpg...? Its proper jekyll and hyde stuff.

Only downside is the list price - quite pricey? But, from a Co car point of view the emissions and BIK are really good for the performance on offer. Factor in the cheaper price of petrol compared to diesel and the plan is things will even out...I'm returning to the BMW fold again from the dark side - My 3 Series M Sport Hybrid arrives in a couple of weeks - can't wait!

Well worth having a shot in one if you get the chance.

deanobeano

462 posts

214 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
As a gen 3 Prius owner (for work) and a R32 owner (for play) I too am interested in this thread...

Sortie 10

744 posts

283 months

Wednesday 14th November 2012
quotequote all
Interestingly (?) - the only security vehicles in the athletes village of London 2012 were police-badged LHD pure electric (not hybrid) 1 series coupes. Very quiet, and their range was not tested in such a small area. Presumably prototypes (I'm not aware of them being a listed model in the UK or overseas), they appeared to be finished to production quality including the usual trim & fittings. Appearing soon at your local dealer?

dtmpower

3,972 posts

276 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
The Active E is on a field trial in the US, similar to the Mini-E trial here a few years ago.

http://www.bmwactivatethefuture.com/

peteA

Original Poster:

2,762 posts

265 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
The salesman at the BMW garage told me the 5 series Hybrids were on Olympic duty - in what capacity I dont know? It had just over 1200 miles on the clock so it doesnt appear to have gone very far!

Anyway, technically the Hybrids don't make sense...if you want to go fast buy the 335i and save yourself a few quid, if you want to go reasonably fast but have some reasonable fuel consumption buy the 330D and again, save a few quid. The Hybrid appears to be the answer to a question nobody asked?

But, the 5 series Hybrid I drove was great - you get the refinement of the petrol, more performance than a standard 335i (a little!) but when you back off and cruise and stick it in Eco-pro, most of the economy of a diesel. But its actually interesting to see how having the facility to change the driving modes impacts on your driving.

I doubt the extra refinement is worth paying for....and the diesel is more fuel efficient...but its an interesting if expensive option hence the request for other peoples thoughts?

Too late for me to change my mind now as my car arrives at the end of the month.

Cheib

25,489 posts

206 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
peteA said:
The salesman at the BMW garage told me the 5 series Hybrids were on Olympic duty - in what capacity I dont know? It had just over 1200 miles on the clock so it doesnt appear to have gone very far!
They were used for chauffering....I saw an Olympic 5 series hybrid on Bond St during the games. It was mostly 3 series that were used but I saw a few 7 series and that hybrid 5 series too.

chrisx666

808 posts

292 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
These have been pretty much under my radar so far - I'm very interested to see how you get on with it. Yes the list price is high, but list prices are getting less and less relevant in the days of lease offers/ex-demo's at 20% off etc.


I like the path BMW are taking on this.

"We need some hybrids in the range to cut our average CO2. Do we:

A. Add a motor to the smallest, most efficient engine we have and get a 0-60 time of around 10s? More than acceptable for most driving.

or

B. Add the motor to an already powerful 6-clyinder turbo making it really fast, like M3 from a few years ago fast."

dtmpower

3,972 posts

276 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all

peteA

Original Poster:

2,762 posts

265 months

Thursday 15th November 2012
quotequote all
chrisx666 said:
These have been pretty much under my radar so far - I'm very interested to see how you get on with it. Yes the list price is high, but list prices are getting less and less relevant in the days of lease offers/ex-demo's at 20% off etc.


I like the path BMW are taking on this.

"We need some hybrids in the range to cut our average CO2. Do we:

A. Add a motor to the smallest, most efficient engine we have and get a 0-60 time of around 10s? More than acceptable for most driving.

or

B. Add the motor to an already powerful 6-clyinder turbo making it really fast, like M3 from a few years ago fast."
Well...you hit the nail on the head....the car I ordered came within the monthly budget and is what I wanted / needed... The bonus is the C02 figures and BIK. Also, factor in cheaper petrol vs diesel....?

I know what you mean about the engine they added the electric motor to....I bet that was an interesting board meeting! Guess it won't be long before they extend the hybrid range though? The 5 hybrid was fast so here's hoping the 3 is even quicker!

Redeem

382 posts

214 months

Friday 16th November 2012
quotequote all
I owned a BMW 530 i and bought a Lexus 450h Premier two months ago. I love the Lexus, it is not as powerful as my BMW but it is more refined and has a lot of kits. It is also a 4WD. Whether I would buy an hybrid from BMW I am not so sure. These cars are very expensive to fix if the hybrid system goes wrong and except if BMW improves its dealership network I would probably not buy one from them.