BMW 120d for commuting?
Discussion
Hello all, my situation is as follows:
Currently have a jaguar xf 2.7d as a commuter and do about 120 miles a day, the xf gets an average of about 34 mpg so not the best. I get an allowance from work for fuel but it does not cover that cost so am thinking of selling the xf mid next year to get something more economical whilst still having a bit of driver enjoyment ( I have a 911 and a Westfield in the garage for proper driver fun).
Now been thinking of a BMW 120d with a remap as a commuter, and would look to get a 07 year on model.
So what do people reckon to the mpg etc from something like that and will it be any 'fun'? Also thinking of something like a golf gt tdi but prefer the BMW due to rear wheel drive!
Thanks
Lee
Currently have a jaguar xf 2.7d as a commuter and do about 120 miles a day, the xf gets an average of about 34 mpg so not the best. I get an allowance from work for fuel but it does not cover that cost so am thinking of selling the xf mid next year to get something more economical whilst still having a bit of driver enjoyment ( I have a 911 and a Westfield in the garage for proper driver fun).
Now been thinking of a BMW 120d with a remap as a commuter, and would look to get a 07 year on model.
So what do people reckon to the mpg etc from something like that and will it be any 'fun'? Also thinking of something like a golf gt tdi but prefer the BMW due to rear wheel drive!
Thanks
Lee
I bought the missus a 120d for her commute. It's about 35 miles each way and she gets 49.5mpg according to the OBC. I then ruin it at the weekend and she earns it back during the week 
I bought a 2006 to avoid the DPF issue, though admittedly using the car for a commute does away with the issue anyway.

I bought a 2006 to avoid the DPF issue, though admittedly using the car for a commute does away with the issue anyway.
Good choice to use alongside a 911 
If you can stretch to an F20, I'd recommend that. Picked up a one-year old, 11,000 mile 120d Sport last month for a tad over £17K and it's fantastic compared to my previous Golf TDi and has more torque than my 911 (996). Can set it to 'comfort' mode for normal driving and 'sports' for country lane hacks... With mode set to Sports the steering has nice feel and not dissimilar to the 911.
Getting 54mpg pottering about locally, 57 on long run (normal speeds) and got 65mpg on a 70mile journey at steady 60mph (tho was bored out of my mind, don't recommend that!). It feels very well constructed overall and perfect for day-to-day driving with all the modern stuff like parking sensors, bluetooth integration, puddle lights, auto wipers, folding mirrors and all that cr@p. The sports seats are so comfy too. Just have to disable the auto-start/stop as that's pain.

If you can stretch to an F20, I'd recommend that. Picked up a one-year old, 11,000 mile 120d Sport last month for a tad over £17K and it's fantastic compared to my previous Golf TDi and has more torque than my 911 (996). Can set it to 'comfort' mode for normal driving and 'sports' for country lane hacks... With mode set to Sports the steering has nice feel and not dissimilar to the 911.
Getting 54mpg pottering about locally, 57 on long run (normal speeds) and got 65mpg on a 70mile journey at steady 60mph (tho was bored out of my mind, don't recommend that!). It feels very well constructed overall and perfect for day-to-day driving with all the modern stuff like parking sensors, bluetooth integration, puddle lights, auto wipers, folding mirrors and all that cr@p. The sports seats are so comfy too. Just have to disable the auto-start/stop as that's pain.
Edited by Diesel130 on Thursday 15th November 10:11
CooperS said:
I'm looking to get a 123d as i may soon be doing a larger commute.
Interested in peoples views on whether i get 118, 120, or 123d not bothered about hatch or coupe.
50mpg appeals after having sub 23 for the past 18 months.
You will not get 50mpg out of a 123d.Interested in peoples views on whether i get 118, 120, or 123d not bothered about hatch or coupe.
50mpg appeals after having sub 23 for the past 18 months.
I've had mine for 13000 miles now and can't get above 47.8 over a full tank (normally get 42-44mpg) no matter how slowly I drive although like you my old car only ever did a max of 25mpg so almost doubling it and nearly halving my fuel outlay is nice and not much of a performance drop. I do miss the noise of the Alfa V6 though
.The 123d has higher gearing so when you are cruising on the motorway the revs tend to sit at just over 2000rpm whereas from recollection (when I was researching) the 120d sits at about 1700rpm. The 120d is a better commuter due to this if you are after economy.
The biggest difference is if you remap it, a 123d can get from a normal tune of around 245-250bhp anything up to 280bhp and above if you are feeling lucky.
I have bought a roof rack for mine (coupe) so carrying the kayak and bikes isn't a problem. I do miss a hatch back sometimes when I end up at B&Q etc but the seats fold down and it's quite surprising how big the boot is on the coupe. Looks wise I do find it a bit marmite in the reactions from others, some instantly like it others think it looks like a hideous blob.
14-7 said:
You will not get 50mpg out of a 123d.
In the interests of balance I've got over 50mpg (just) brim to brim with two tanks since I've had mine.http://www.fuelly.com/driver/boom/123d
My average sits at 47 though. It will all depend on your driving habits and commuting route, but it can be done...
mike325112 said:
I'm not sure if I'd want to drive 120 miles a day in a 1 series. I never found mine all that comfortable. I think I'd be looking for something bigger at that mileage. How much are the early 520d's now?
Second that. And I found that what made it fun to drive on B roads meant it wasn't a relaxing drive on M'ways. Try a Golf?On the flip side I use to commute in my Elise and on the days when I felt less than adventurous I'd put in my ear buds to cut out the noise and was quite happy with this. Only the break down on me made me move it on.
Thanks for the heads up about mpg tbh anything over 40 and I'm winning.
Thanks for the heads up about mpg tbh anything over 40 and I'm winning.
leemarkadams said:
Good point about a 520d or a 320d as they seem to do about the same mpg?..
I consistently get 47mpg out of my 520d & it never drops below that, but I would recommend the 320d over mine as the 20d engine is woeful in the 5 series the car is far too heavy for the engine.One thing I will say is the 5 series in really comfy but so is the 3 series we did 154k miles in our old e90 330d, I think I would definitely plump for the 3 series in your position, my brother in law has a 320d coupe & he gets 58 mpg!
Good luck in your search

Stuart Thompson said:
I love my little 120. Has a decent amount of power and contrary to the last couple of posts I love taking it on a long run . I have a sport with leather interior pump the seat to fit and enjoy.
I have only drove a 116d & I really liked it I always think smaller means lighter so it's all the better for that & I bet the 1series goes well with the 20d engine in it. I like the short wheelbase on the one I bet it's nice & chuckable.
Stuart Thompson said:
I love my little 120. Has a decent amount of power and contrary to the last couple of posts I love taking it on a long run . I have a sport with leather interior pump the seat to fit and enjoy.
Snap. They're not perfect long-distance fodder, but I ran mine over to Nuremberg in one stint last year and it was great. Sat on the autobahn at a mild 1.1 Leptons and just gobbled it up.cerb4.5lee said:
I have only drove a 116d & I really liked it I always think smaller means lighter so it's all the better for that & I bet the 1series goes well with the 20d engine in it.
I like the short wheelbase on the one I
bet it's nice & chuckable.
If you liked the 116 you'd love the 120 there is a massive power difference. 1.6 has around 120 bhp I think whereas the 120 has 163 bhp.I like the short wheelbase on the one I
bet it's nice & chuckable.
Stuart Thompson said:
cerb4.5lee said:
I have only drove a 116d & I really liked it I always think smaller means lighter so it's all the better for that & I bet the 1series goes well with the 20d engine in it.
I like the short wheelbase on the one I
bet it's nice & chuckable.
If you liked the 116 you'd love the 120 there is a massive power difference. 1.6 has around 120 bhp I think whereas the 120 has 163 bhp.I like the short wheelbase on the one I
bet it's nice & chuckable.

Have current model 184 bhp 120D Sport 8 speed auto - use it on a daily basis within M25 - average economy is 47mpg - it could be a bit better if I drove it like a pussy - easy 10 mpg better on a run. Whilst it was away for 3 months being repaired following a near write I used a previous model 118D MSport auto - this was 10 mpg behind current 120D.
Effortless said:
cerb4.5lee said:
why BMW ever thought a 2 litre engine was acceptable in a 5 series I will never ever know
Didn't BMW do a 5 series with the 1.8 petrol back in the day?? 
Pudding, rice, inability and skin come to mind.
Cheers,
Effortless.
I won't make the same mistake again though 530d it is when I come to swap the hopeless 520d! (Engine is hopeless not the car)
Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


